HEENA ANAND
This Query has 2 replies

This Query has 2 replies

18 December 2014 at 12:15

Appointment of auditor in companies

I m a practicing chartered accountant, while filing ADT-1 for the appointment of Auditor in companies, I have been appointed in 22 companies. What should i do to rectify it. We are 3 partner in our firm and i signed all 22 ADT-1 on the behalf of my firm.


parth shah
This Query has 1 replies

This Query has 1 replies

17 December 2014 at 17:56

Audit report

Hello....plz tell me when it is compulsory to upload audit report along with it return?

What is the difference between form 3CA , 3CB and form 3CD?



Anonymous
This Query has 6 replies

This Query has 6 replies

17 December 2014 at 11:08

Medical transcription service

Would you please advise me if a Medical Transcription service provider (ITES/BPO) firm comes under Business or Profession for audit purpose. The gross annual receipt for service provided is 45 lakh annually.

Please advise


chanchal khetan
This Query has 3 replies

This Query has 3 replies

16 December 2014 at 14:55

Concurrent bank audit

During my working I faced a problem regarding revenue leakage where bank charges i.e.Processing and inspection charges are not charged by the bank and given reason that by debiting customer account the drawing power exceeds. Therefore bank is not debiting the charges resulting loss to the Revenue Income of the Bank. Could you please provide me the solutions regarding this that how this Income can be recovered.



Anonymous
This Query has 3 replies

This Query has 3 replies

16 December 2014 at 13:30

Export

Can a company Export goods in INR instead of USD?
IF it chooses to do so what are the merits & Demerits?
And which is more preferable?


JAY RUPARELIA
This Query has 1 replies

This Query has 1 replies

15 December 2014 at 18:30

Treatment of purchase

currently I am Auditing one private LTD. Co. That co. received one invoice on, say 10-04-2014 dated as 29-03-2014. they have recorded in current year 10-04-2014. is this right practice? the invoice is received from another state. then is it correct?



Anonymous
This Query has 3 replies

This Query has 3 replies

14 December 2014 at 19:35

Can jv be used

An amt is deposited by our customer in our group co a/c,now can we debit grp co by jv or debit note should be used


Dheeraj Jakhar
This Query has 3 replies

This Query has 3 replies

12 December 2014 at 18:18

Tds applicable

Dear sir Agreement Date 09/11/2012 Agreement value -5450000 but total payment received 3875000. TDS is applicable or not



Anonymous
This Query has 3 replies

This Query has 3 replies

12 December 2014 at 17:00

Tax audit

If a person has two business one retailing and another stock Broking in two different state, the retail business has been audited by CA in that state and stock broking business has (whichever had loss in previous year) not been audited,
my question are :
1. Is this necessary to audit stock broking business too, whereas is in loss ?
2. If CA already made audit report on retail business, can another CA audit again for both business ?
3. what is penalty arises on 2 month late audit filing after due date ?




RAJ KUMAR
This Query has 13 replies

This Query has 13 replies

Dear Experts,
I am associated with a Pvt Ltd company as Deputy Manager in Finance & Accounts.

My query is:
My company Statutory auditors are also doing as tax auditors and filing Income tax returns on behalf of us.

Recently, my company faced due diligence audit in the process of merger with another company. The due diligence auditors pointed out errors committed by tax auditors in the last 3 years Income tax computation and arrived to pay additional tax liability to the tune of 60 Lakhs. We informed the same thing to our tax auditors about the error occurred in computation of income and tax liability. But their contention on the above issue is overlook happened at our end also.

Now, Just I want to know, Who is the ultimate person responsible for preparation of Computation of Income and tax liability and who is responsible for any mistakes or errors committed.

My contention is, Auditors are professionally qualified and experts in preparation of IT returns. Being appointed as tax auditors of the company, they are also held responsible for preparation of accurate IT computation and filing of returns. We are simply relying on them on the assumption that they are into the filed of full time practice and they know better than us because of full time involvement in the field of practice. we are limited to provide the information as requested by tax auditors.

Now, just I want to know, who is the final person responsible for this error.
Is it really again company responsible to check the errors done by tax auditors.
If that is the case, then why to appoint and pay tax audit fees to them.

Please reply to the query with relevant guidelines provided by ICAI so that we can explain the same to Due diligence auditors.





CCI Pro
Meet our CAclubindia PRO Members


Follow us


Answer Query