Minakshi Jhawar
27 May 2023 at 16:09

Software Related queries

A company is manufacturing paper in one factory(use Tally) & transfer it to another factory (use Finsys for production) where they manufacture cartoon as per the specifications provided by the customer. What software should use in Factory 1 for inventory management & operational controls & production so that management can figure out correct accounting figures & avoid wastage

akshay maloo


Rakesh Kumar Arya

Company A and company B are under the same management. Company A owns a plot, the market value of which is about 2.50 Cr. Company A allows company B to construct a showroom on plot of A. Company B gives proposed map as per its own requirements, which is submitted to development authority by Company A. Map approval charges and development charges are paid by Company A to the Development Authority. The cost of construction of showroom is borne by B. No rent is charged by A from B for giving possession and allowing use of plot by Company B. Period of allowing use of plot is likely to be quite long. There is no written agreement between two Companies.

Any transaction between two companies under the same management should be made at arms length price, whereas in the instant case there is no consideration.

On these facts of the case, my questions are:

1. Is there violation of any Act!?
2. Should the Auditor report such transaction in his Audit report, if no reference of this transaction is made in the Notes on Accounts?
3. How and in what manner the Auditor should report in his Audit Report?

Amal G Cherian

Hi, how to close a CA firm having 2 partners when one of the partner died? What is the procedure for closing firm in the institute records in this situation

Ajaykumar Chaudhary

Dear Experts,

As per 8th edition of the ICAI, turnover of Option will be calculated by ABSOLUTE formula, like a Future. Is it correct as below?

(i) The total of favourable and unfavourable differences shall be
taken as turnover.
(ii) Premium received on sale of options is also to be included in
turnover. However, where the premium received is included for
determining net profit for transactions, the same should not be
separately included.

Incase of Loss or less than 6% Profit in Option Trading and Turnover is below 2 Crore, will 44AD be OPTIONAL or MANDATORY? In case of Loss, can it be carry forwarded to future years without Tax Audit where Turnover below 2 Crore and 44AD not adopted?

29 April 2023 at 14:43

Auditors Trial Version

Ours is a private limited company having a sales Turnover for the financial year 2022-23 around 2.24 Crores as at 31st March 2023. We are maintaining our books in tally 7.2. We have come to know that our auditors will have to follow rules of auditors trial version. Can someone make me understand in detail the issue of auditors trial version.

28 April 2023 at 10:21

Vehicle number in e invoice

is it compulsory to mention Vehicle number in E invoice ?

Abhishek kar
22 April 2023 at 12:20

Auditors Re-appointment

Hello Experts!

I have a small question i.e.

Do we need to re-appoint an auditor in the same AGM where his tenure is completed? Considering he is eligible for reappointment.

For example: Mr Anmol & Co. an Audit Firm, was appointed as the auditor of ZEN Pvt Ltd in AGM on 30.09.2018 and as per the rules he will hold office till the conclusion of the sixth AGM i.e. AGM to be held in the calendar year 2023 (Period 01.04.2018 to 31.03.2023). For the sixth AGM to be held on, let's say 31.07.2023, Do we need to pass a resolution for him to be reappointed in the same AGM. To be more specific, do need to reappoint him in the same AGM where his tenure is getting completed?

Now if the answer is no, then when we should convene a Board Meeting and thereafter hold AGM for such reappointment? By when he shall be reappointed?

10 April 2023 at 16:29

File ITR-3

Dear Sir,
Please tell me about Tax Audit, My business is only F&O trading and 100 % digitally.
In Fy 2022-23  Option trading premium received is 79 Lakh and premium buy is 80 Lakh so my net losses is 1 lakh and carry forward loss to next year,  so know whether I am liable for tax audit or not ?
If not, can I file ITR-3 file without tax audit without error? Is it applicable In my case 6 % profit of Gross Receipt criteria in my case I have no any income ?
If I file ITR -3 without a tax audit and show error what can I do?
Please  know me in detail about it.
Warm Regards,

Can I face a problem at time of ITR 3 file because of loss? Previous year this problem is occurring because of profit is less than 6% of gross receipt then I was go wit audit in fy 21-22

darshan k. panchal
05 April 2023 at 14:43

Tax Audit limit 2022-23

What is Tax Audit Limit of Future option transactions for the year of 2022-23?

Certificate in Quantitative Finance IIM Calcutta Applied Finance(Batch 17) GST Course
Follow us

Answer Query