Uploading ECR with new rules but getting error "Error RFE-33 (EDLI Wages): EDLI Wages can't be greater Rs. 15,000/-. found on line numbers: [1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 9, 10, 14]
Error RFE-25 (EPS Contribution): EPS Contribution must be 8.33% of EPS wages (plus an additional 1.16% for POHW cases). found on line numbers: [1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 10, 14]
Error RFE-37 (Employer PF contribution): The Employer PF contribution must match the difference between the Due EPF and Due EPS contributions calculated on wages. found on line numbers: [1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 10, 14]"

Dear Experts
Kindly guide me on the following practical issue:
1. Both concerns are sole proprietorships owned by different family members and have separate GST Registrations.
2. The proprietorship holding the physical stock filed its ITR for FY 2025-26 under section 44AD. In the balance sheet section of the ITR, all columns were reported as Nil, except Cash. The Trade Name of Business was not mentioned in the ITR. Further, the GST Turnover reflected in AIS/TIS was not separately reported in the ITR, although the turnover declared in the ITR exceeds the GST Turnover reflected in AIS/TIS.
3. During FY 2026-27, the proprietor intends to transfer the existing physical stock to the other family owned proprietorship concern.
Query:
Can the physical stock be transferred to the other proprietorship despite the above reporting position in the earlier ITR? If yes, what is the appropriate procedure under the applicable GST and Income Tax laws?
Kinly provide your expert opinion.
Thank you.

Dear Experts ,
While filing our TDS Q2 return through the new TRACES portal, we are receiving an error stating that mandatory responsible person details are missing.

We have already updated all the required Contact Details, Correspondence Address, and Authorized Person Details. However, the same error persists, and we are unable to proceed by clicking Submit.

Kindly resolve this technical issue at the earliest to enable us to file our TDS return.

Thanks & Regards
Ch.Siva Nageswara Rao

Hi All,
Today, I received a SCN from PTO , Mumbai on my registered email for non filing of ptrc returns and non payment of tax since fy 2023- 24.

But I have already paid correct tax and filed ptrc returns timely. It says if returns filed and taxes paid submit evidences.

So how do I reply to this scn ? Is there any online option on mahagst / pt web portal now ? Or do I reply back on email ? Or do I have to personally visit pt office at Mazagon?

Thanks
Niki

Sir,

our client has not provided the msme details,so we are not able to track the payments.how to report in 3cb-cd

Sir
Does 100% Govt Company are exempt from GST Audit.
One colleague told me that those concerns audited by CAG are exempt from GST Audit.
Is it true?

Sir
I need depreciation chart as per companies act for pvt ltd company to prepare chart for the current financial year... Pl send me in excel format showing all formulas. On the basis of WDV, so that I can prepare according to my figures correctly.
Thanks for your cooperation in advance.
Regards
Sanjay

Is a Capital Gain Exemption Certificate obtained through a CBDT-registered valuer legally valid?

**Query: Taxation of Crypto Futures in India (FY 2026–27)**

I am an Indian resident planning to trade BTC/ETH perpetual futures on:

1. **Binance Global:** USDT-settled futures.
2. **Delta Exchange India:** INR-settled futures.

My main question is whether I can pay income tax on **net annual trading profit after adjusting eligible losses, trading fees and funding charges**, instead of paying 30% tax under the VDA regime.

Please clarify:

1. Are cash-settled crypto futures taxable as business/speculative income or under the 30% VDA tax regime?
2. Can winning and losing futures trades be netted for tax purposes?
3. Does receiving profits in USDT make the futures profit taxable under VDA rules? Is converting USDT into INR a separate taxable event?
4. Is Delta Exchange's INR settlement treated differently from Binance's USDT settlement?
5. What is the legally correct tax treatment, with relevant sections or circulars, for FY 2026–27?

I would appreciate a concise answer from a CA familiar with crypto derivatives. Thank you.

Hi All,

We generated the sales invoice in October 2025 without including the customer’s GST number and reported it as a B2C invoice in GSTR-1, with GST charged.

Now, in October 2026, (After one Year) the customer is requesting us to add their GST number and share the revised invoice.

Could you please confirm whether it is possible to revise the invoice at this stage?

Regards
Chandrashekar BM