Buyer received a brass invoice with 18% GST, but supplier reported 28% on portal. ITC is allowed only at the correct legal rate (18%), not 28%. Supplier must amend GSTR-1, and buyer should claim correctly and track updates in GSTR-2B.
09 March 2026
We have a brass purchase bill dated Feb-2026 in which 18% GST is applicable, but the supplier party has reported the bill on the GST portal with 28% GST. In that case, can we claim ITC of 28%?
09 March 2026
You cannot claim ITC of 28% just because the supplier uploaded the invoice with that rate. Legally, ITC is restricted to the tax actually charged in accordance with law (18% in this case), and any excess tax paid by the supplier (28%) is not eligible for ITC. The supplier must correct the invoice or amend their GST return to align with the correct rate.
09 March 2026
Restrict your claim: Only claim the 18% GST as per your purchase bill in your GSTR-3B. Contact the supplier: Ask them to amend the invoice in their next GSTR-1 filing to reflect the correct 18% rate. Monitor GSTR-2B: Once the supplier amends the entry, ensure the corrected amount reflects in your future GSTR-2B statement.
14 November 2026
Claiming 18% is the safe course. The legal position is more nuanced than a flat 'no', though.
1. The argument for 28%. Sec 16(1) allows ITC of tax 'charged' on supplies used in business. There is no express provision limiting credit to the correct rate, and some rulings have allowed credit of tax actually charged and paid to the government.
2. The department's view. Tax charged above the correct rate is not 'tax' payable under the Act, so the excess 10% is not eligible. In audits and scrutiny, officers routinely disallow it with interest and penalty. Part of the risk is that the supplier may later amend the invoice, and you would then have to reverse the credit.
3. Best route: • Ask the supplier to issue a credit note (Sec 34) for the excess 10% and report it in GSTR-1. You keep 18% ITC and recover the excess from the supplier. • Claim 18% now. The rest stays visible in GSTR-2B and you can reconcile it. • Only if the supplier refuses and you are prepared to litigate, consider claiming 28%, with all documents on file.
4. Check the current rate for the specific brass item after the 22.09.2025 rate rationalisation, so the 'correct' rate is itself certain.
Overall Summary: Claim 18% ITC and get the supplier to issue a credit note for the excess 10%. A 28% claim has an arguable legal basis but is routinely disallowed with interest and penalty, so it is not worth the risk.