Business or profession

This query is : Resolved 

Avatar

Querist : Anonymous

Profile Image
Querist : Anonymous (Querist)
08 November 2011 A pvt limited company running a hospital, Whether it will be covered under business or profession ?

What if a individual running a hospital in proprietorship.

08 November 2011 In Dr. Deepak Assudani v. ITO (2009) 29 (II) ITCL 527 (Del ‘E’-Trib) : (2009) 26 DTR (Del-Trib) 454 IT WAS HELD THAT income from running of hospital was liable to be treated as activities of carrying out business. Consequently, since total receipts do not exceed Rs. 40 lakhs, assessee was not liable for tax audit and provisions of section 40(a)(ia) were not applicable.
IN CASE OF A CO IT WILL B TREATED AS BUSINESS

CA MANOJ GUPTA
JODHPUR
09828510543

Avatar

Querist : Anonymous

Profile Image
Querist : Anonymous (Querist)
08 November 2011 What if individual running a hospital in proprietorship (individual is a doctor).

09 November 2011 Dr Deapak' s case is oof an individual

09 November 2011 Question :- Doctor running hospital as proprietor?

Observation :- It is a vexed issue. Extract from 'Issues on tax Audit' a priced publication of ICAI is given below.

"If the nursing home is run by medical practitioners who are also carrying on their medical practice at that place it is possible to argue that the assessee is carrying on profession. Alternatively, it is a case of composite activity of business and profession".

20 February 2018 Kindly help me to get this case law -

Dr. Deepak Assudani v. ITO (2009) 29 (II) ITCL 527 (Del ‘E’-Trib) : (2009) 26 DTR (Del-Trib) 454

20 February 2018 Pl see http://www.taxpundit.org/phocadownload/DTR_ITAT/26DTR_ITAT/26DTR_ITAT_454.pdf

20 February 2018 Thanks a lot sir, appreciate your prompt reply!


You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now


CCI Pro
CAclubindia's WhatsApp Groups Link


Similar Resolved Queries


loading


Unanswered Queries



CCI Pro
Meet our CAclubindia PRO Members

Follow us
add to google news



Answer Query



Company
Featured 28 March 2026
Accountant

Ashok Amol & Associates

New Delhi

B.Com

View Details
Company
Featured 12 March 2026
Customer Relationship Executive

TAXLET

Calicut

B.Com

View Details
Company
Featured 28 March 2026
CA Final

Ashok Amol & Associates

New Delhi

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured 14 April 2026
GST CONSULTANT

Abhishek G Agrawal & Co.

Korba

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured 13 April 2026
GST CONSULTANCY

Abhishek G Agrawal & Co.

Korba

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured 14 March 2026
Associate CA

N N V Satish&co

Hyderabad

CA

View Details
Company
Featured 14 March 2026
Article Trainee

N N V Satish&co

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 19 March 2026
Article Assistant

Gupta Sachdeva & Co. Chartered Accountants

New Delhi

CA Final

View Details