VAT on DG Rent or DG Hire

This query is : Resolved

ManishTanawala (Querist)
Follow

26 October 2010 Whether there is any VAT liability on Dg Rent or DG Hire income?

Whether giving of DG on Rent or Hire is called transfer of right to use goods?

Kindly site case laws in support of your answer, if any.

CA Shailesh Kumar Bhagat

CA Shailesh Kumar Bhagat (Expert)
Follow

26 October 2010 If DG is given on rent to one party , it is taxable under VAT.

However, if it is given on hiring to various person , it does not come under VAT.

Aashok Kumar Sharma

Aashok Kumar Sharma (Expert)
Follow

02 August 2025 Here’s a clear explanation about VAT on Diesel Generator (DG) rent/hire:

---

### VAT Liability on DG Rent or Hire:

* **Giving DG on Rent:**
When you rent out a DG to a single party, it is generally considered a **“transfer of right to use goods”** and hence **VAT is applicable**. Renting means exclusive use of the DG for a period, so it falls under VAT on goods/services depending on the state.

* **Giving DG on Hire:**
Hiring out DGs to multiple parties (like on hourly or short-term basis) is often treated differently. It may be viewed as providing a service rather than transferring goods’ possession or control, so **VAT may not apply** in many states. Instead, Service Tax (now GST) could be relevant.

---

### Why the difference?

* **Rent** implies exclusive possession and control for a period → VAT on goods applies.
* **Hire** often means temporary use without transferring control → usually service, VAT may not apply.

---

### Case Laws / References:

* Many VAT authorities treat renting of machinery as taxable under VAT since it involves transfer of right to use goods.
* Hiring on short-term basis is often treated as a service, falling under Service Tax (pre-GST) or GST (post-2017).
* However, the classification may vary slightly by state VAT laws and judicial pronouncements.

---

### Practical takeaway:

* If you rent DG exclusively to one party → VAT is applicable.
* If you hire DGs frequently or on short-term basis → generally no VAT, but service tax (now GST) applicable.

---

If you want, I can help you draft a formal note or find specific state VAT provisions or case laws on this. Would that help?

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now