Excess salary payment.

Save Share

This query is : Resolved

Quick Summary

Gratuity generally cannot be withheld as lien for excess salary recovery. However, under Section 4(6), forfeiture is allowed for proven misconduct or loss, after due process like notice and inquiry, limited to actual loss.

abhijit majumder

abhijit majumder (Querist)

16 April 2026 sir
The subject is stated herein below:
1. The company is a 100% Govt undertaking.
2. One of its employee by fabrication in past able to manage two excess increments.
3.It was identified only after his retirement wherein he claimed gratuity 'under payment of gratuity act 1972'.
My query is:
As the company being entitled of the excess amount drawn by the employee by fabrication , can the company hold the gratuity amount as "LIEN' until the employee release such excess amount?
Regards
Abhijit

Dhirajlal Rambhia

Dhirajlal Rambhia (Expert)

16 April 2026 The company generally cannot hold the gratuity as a "lien" or withhold it for the recovery of excess payments, even in cases involving fabrication, unless specific statutory conditions under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 are met.

Under Section 13 of the Act, gratuity is protected from attachment by any court decree or order.
The Act has an "overriding effect" (Section 14) over other laws or contracts, meaning internal company rules cannot easily bypass these protections.
A "lien" is typically not a valid legal ground to withhold statutory gratuity for unrelated dues.

Since the fabrication was discovered after retirement, the company faces a procedural challenge. In a 100% Govt undertaking, the "employer-employee" relationship officially ends at superannuation. Without a pending disciplinary inquiry initiated before retirement (and rules allowing its continuation), a summary "lien" is often viewed by courts as impermissible.

abhijit majumder

abhijit majumder (Querist)

16 April 2026 Thanks to Sir Dhirajlal Rambhia for instant reply
Abhijit

abhijit majumder

abhijit majumder (Querist)

16 April 2026 Sir
Section 4(6) of Gratuity Act 1972 states Gratuity may be forfeited in some cases.
So as U/s 13 prohibit attachment, can we deduct the amount from his gratuity and balance will be released.
Regards
abhijit

Dhirajlal Rambhia

Dhirajlal Rambhia (Expert)

16 April 2026 Yes, in some cases...
To make the withholding legal and avoid a successful challenge by the employee, the company must:
Issue a Show-Cause Notice: The employee must be given a fair chance to explain why the amount should not be withheld.
Prove the Misconduct: A formal finding (via inquiry) must establish that the fabrication occurred and led to the specific financial loss.
Proportionality: The amount withheld should ideally be limited to the actual excess amount drawn plus any interest/damages, rather than arbitrarily seizing the entire gratuity if the loss was smaller.

Dhirajlal Rambhia

Dhirajlal Rambhia (Expert)

16 April 2026 Under Section 4(6) of the Act, an employer can forfeit or withhold gratuity in specific scenarios:
Financial Loss: If the employee's service is terminated for an act, willful omission, or negligence that causes financial loss to the employer, gratuity can be forfeited to the extent of that loss.
Moral Turpitude: If the service is terminated for an act involving moral turpitude (such as fabrication of records or fraud), the gratuity can be forfeited wholly or partially.

abhijit majumder

abhijit majumder (Querist)

17 April 2026 My sincere thanks to Sir Dhirajlal Rambhia for elaborately & lucidly explain the entire matter. It clear all doubt.
Regards
Abhijit

Dhirajlal Rambhia

Dhirajlal Rambhia (Expert)

17 April 2026 You are welcome.

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now