Can you explain please what is the garner v/s more judgment
What is the treatment for that while accounting

Dear Sir/ Madam

our company manufacture
1. finished goods
2.manufacture some material which used in manufacturing of other finished goods by other company.

We calculate the turnover 1.5 crore for both products and we charge 1% excise duty on 1st product and 2% excise duty on 2nd product without cenvat credit.

Now we find that our 2nd product is not excisable, no need to charge 2 % excise duty. but while calculating 1.5 crore exemption most sale is of 2nd product only , the 1st product sale was only upto 50 lakh.
then now is we require to pay 1% excise duty for 1st product if we not cross the 1.5 crore limit for that?

We have filed return for Oct to Dec but with this query not filled return for Jan to march so what should we can do now?


please reply as early as possible

Dear Sir,
What is the applicable service tax on the work of civil construction.
Suppose a contractor received the contract to build a water tank for a real estate co.
And the cost of contract is Rs. 10 lacs. Then contractor has to pay service tax on 40% of bill amount
or on the 33% of bill amount.

Please clarify.

Respected Sir

is deduction u/s 16 (iii) is inclusive in 80C deduction. or apart from maximum limit of Rs.100000=00 under 80C, additional deduction is available u/s 16(iii).

Please guide.

Can XYZ Pvt. Ltd. Co. give or take a loan in F.Y 2013-14 & F.Y. 2014-15 from its managing or whole time directors who are also tha shareholders of the co.? What are the Provisions in thos regard

Sir my client has crossed limit of Rs. 10 lacs for room receipts so he has obtained the STR No.

Now as per act Service tax to be collected only in those rooms whose Declared tariff is more then Rs. 1,000/- and he raised has none of the invoice more then Rs. 1,000/-, hence he has not collected the Service Tax.

Now while return filing whether we have to file 'Nil' Return or we have to show Gross amount collected and show the same amount in the coloumn exempted service and thus taxable value be Nil.

Kindly clear the matter as there is lot of confusion.

How can we distinguish between VAT exempted dealers & VAT composite dealers through purchase bills?

I Have a client having public co. incorporated in june 2012. till date no document has been filled with roc.
plz tell the documents required to be submitted in the name of co. and also in the name of auditor and what will be the fees and penalty if any.


Thanks in advance

Dear All,

I have a query regarding the point of taxation in case of reverse charge as follows :-

We are paying commission to a foreign consultant on which service tax is applicable on reverse charge, the consultant has not issued us any bill for the commission due to him during the year. But we have to book the commission expense in the books so we recorded commission expenses in the books for the year ended on March'14 in the month of March itself for the service received during the year.


As per Rule 7 of Point of taxation rules, payment of service tax is to be paid within 6 months from the date of invoice.

But in our case, we do not receive the commission bill although the service has been received.

So Kindly suggest us whether service tax is to be paid or not and if yes what will be the point of taxation in that case.

i hadicap person not made any expenses for the year. can he able to get claims u/s 80 u