Is it possible to practice as CA in full time practice & Advocate simultaneously,if Bar Council permits to do so as is given in professional ethics of the Institute. Further is there any need to take special permission from ICAI or it is general permission.
03 October 2013
Give full reasons along with supported provision of the rules. No inadvertent reply please. I have read both Acts and got no negative rules. So please provide details if any.
10 August 2024
Yes, it is possible to practice as a Chartered Accountant (CA) and an Advocate simultaneously, provided you adhere to the regulations and ethical guidelines set by both the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) and the Bar Council of India (BCI). Below is a detailed explanation based on the relevant provisions and rules:
### **1. Legal Provisions and Ethical Guidelines**
**a. **Bar Council of India (BCI) Regulations:** - **Regulation 49:** According to Regulation 49 of the Bar Council of India Rules, an advocate can practice in other professions or occupations as long as such practice does not interfere with their duties as an advocate. This means that, subject to this condition, an advocate can engage in other professions, including accounting.
**b. **ICAI Guidelines:** - **Code of Ethics:** The ICAI Code of Ethics allows its members to engage in other professions, provided there is no conflict of interest. The key provisions related to practicing in multiple professions are:
- **Clause 1.4 of the Code of Ethics:** This clause stipulates that a member can engage in any business or profession provided it does not interfere with their professional duties and does not compromise their independence. - **Clause 1.2:** This clause emphasizes that members must maintain professional integrity and avoid conflicts of interest.
**c. **No Special Permission Required:** - **General Permission:** The ICAI does not require special permission for practicing in multiple professions as long as the practice adheres to the ethical standards. The ICAI expects its members to comply with its Code of Ethics and ensure that there are no conflicts of interest.
### **2. Requirements and Compliance**
**a. **Conflict of Interest:** - You must ensure that there are no conflicts of interest between your practices as a CA and as an advocate. For instance, avoid situations where your dual roles could compromise your impartiality or professional integrity.
**b. **Professional Conduct:** - **ICAI Professional Ethics:** Follow the ICAI’s ethical guidelines to avoid any compromise on professional standards. - **Bar Council Rules:** Ensure that your engagement in accounting does not interfere with your duties as an advocate and is in compliance with the Bar Council’s regulations.
**c. **Disclosure:** - It is advisable to disclose your dual profession status in your professional documentation and communications to maintain transparency and avoid any potential issues.
### **3. Practical Considerations**
**a. **Time Management:** - Efficiently manage your time to ensure that both your CA and legal practices are adequately attended to. This is crucial for maintaining high standards in both professions.
**b. **Record-Keeping:** - Maintain separate records and accounts for your CA practice and legal practice to ensure clarity and compliance with regulatory requirements.
### **Summary**
1. **Yes, you can practice** as both a CA and an advocate simultaneously. 2. **No special permission** is typically required from ICAI, as long as you adhere to the ICAI Code of Ethics and Bar Council regulations. 3. **Ensure there are no conflicts of interest** and manage your time and professional responsibilities effectively.
**Relevant Provisions:** - **Bar Council of India Regulation 49:** Allows practice in other professions if it does not interfere with advocacy duties. - **ICAI Code of Ethics:** Permits engagement in other professions provided it does not compromise professional integrity or create conflicts of interest.
By following these guidelines and maintaining adherence to both the ICAI and Bar Council rules, you can successfully manage dual professions while ensuring compliance with professional standards.
CAclubindia
