Labour charges v/s manpower supply
This query is : Resolved
28 August 2012
My client is a contractor worker. he give service in a manufacturing company, he has done welding,cutting, painting etc. in company's factory. he charged on the basis of work (not on his workers basis which have done work)he is liable for PF,EICS etc for his worker.
but company says that his worker done the work so it is a manpower supply and cover under reverse charge.
pl. advise me with legal preposition and difference between manpower supply and labour contract.
but company says that his worker done the work so it is a manpower supply and cover under reverse charge.
pl. advise me with legal preposition and difference between manpower supply and labour contract.
28 August 2012
The Company's stand is not correct. The contract between the Company and your client is for repairing or maintenance etc. of the building and hence it comes under works contract. If Company's logic is right the AMC contract contract for construction or fumigation or any such contract where a person comes in the premises and carry out the work shall be a contract for supply of manpower.
When number of workers are supplied as per the quantity and quality specified by a person and the supplier of the workers is not liable to supervise the work or not responsible to carry out the work it is said to be a contract for supply of manpower
sureshjain.nj@gmail.com
When number of workers are supplied as per the quantity and quality specified by a person and the supplier of the workers is not liable to supervise the work or not responsible to carry out the work it is said to be a contract for supply of manpower
sureshjain.nj@gmail.com
Message likes :
2 times
29 August 2012
Thank you Mr. Suresh Sir,
client's work is a part of manufacturing process of FG. and company give him contract of job on labour charge basis and his workers done work under his control in factory premises of company.
as per my opinion his work not a jobwork because company not give him RM on any challan or invoice and not receive back.
but it a labour contract and liable for ST.
but company view i think wrong for consider
under manpower suppy.
pl. give your opinion on this.
client's work is a part of manufacturing process of FG. and company give him contract of job on labour charge basis and his workers done work under his control in factory premises of company.
as per my opinion his work not a jobwork because company not give him RM on any challan or invoice and not receive back.
but it a labour contract and liable for ST.
but company view i think wrong for consider
under manpower suppy.
pl. give your opinion on this.
02 August 2024
The distinction between "manpower supply" and "labour contract" is crucial in determining the correct treatment for service tax (or GST) and other related legalities. Here's a breakdown to help you understand the differences and clarify the situation:
### Manpower Supply
1. **Definition**: Manpower supply involves providing human resources to another company. The supplier of manpower (in this case, your client) essentially leases out their workers to the client company, where the workers perform tasks under the client’s control and direction.
2. **Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM)**: Under the reverse charge mechanism, the recipient of the service (the company) is liable to pay the service tax/GST instead of the supplier. This generally applies to manpower supply services.
3. **Contractual Control**: In manpower supply, the supplier's workers are typically managed by the client company. The manpower supplier has less control over the work environment and processes, as their workers are integrated into the client’s workforce.
### Labour Contract
1. **Definition**: Labour contracts involve a contractor providing a specific service or completing a job based on agreed terms. The contractor manages their workers, and the client pays for the completion of the job rather than the hours worked.
2. **Service Tax/GST**: For labour contracts, the contractor is responsible for service tax/GST on the labour charges, and they should manage their own statutory obligations such as PF and ESI.
3. **Contractual Control**: In labour contracts, the contractor maintains control over their workers and often supplies materials or tools. The client specifies the work but does not control how the work is executed.
### Key Differences Relevant to Your Case:
1. **Control and Integration**: In your client’s case, the workers are performing tasks under the client’s supervision and within the client’s premises, which suggests a degree of integration typical of manpower supply. However, if your client maintains control over the work execution, it might align more with a labour contract.
2. **Job Work vs. Labour Contract**: Job work typically involves processing raw materials supplied by the client. Since the company does not provide raw materials or receive processed goods back, it does not fit the job work definition.
3. **Documentation**: In a labour contract, you would expect to see charges based on the work completed rather than a per-worker basis, and the contractor is responsible for all statutory compliances.
### Legal Precedents and Opinions:
1. **GST Laws**: Under GST, manpower supply services fall under reverse charge if the recipient is a business entity. However, if the service provided is more aligned with a labour contract (where the contractor’s workers are under their control), then the contractor is liable to pay GST.
2. **Judicial Interpretation**: Courts have generally differentiated between manpower supply and labour contracts based on control and supervision over the workers. If the contractor’s workers are under the direct supervision of the client, it may lean towards manpower supply.
### Conclusion:
Based on your description, it seems your client’s work might fit better into a labour contract rather than a manpower supply, especially since the work involves control and execution by your client’s workers under the contractor’s supervision. However, if the client company exerts significant control over how the work is performed, it might be viewed as a manpower supply service.
To resolve the issue definitively, it may be wise to:
1. **Review Contracts**: Examine the terms of the contract between your client and the company to understand the nature of the agreement.
2. **Consult a Tax Professional**: Engage a tax advisor or legal professional who can provide specific advice based on the complete details and current legal standards.
3. **Refer to GST Guidelines**: Consult GST laws and rulings for a clear interpretation based on similar cases.
This nuanced distinction will help ensure that both your client and the company comply with the correct tax treatment and statutory requirements.
### Manpower Supply
1. **Definition**: Manpower supply involves providing human resources to another company. The supplier of manpower (in this case, your client) essentially leases out their workers to the client company, where the workers perform tasks under the client’s control and direction.
2. **Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM)**: Under the reverse charge mechanism, the recipient of the service (the company) is liable to pay the service tax/GST instead of the supplier. This generally applies to manpower supply services.
3. **Contractual Control**: In manpower supply, the supplier's workers are typically managed by the client company. The manpower supplier has less control over the work environment and processes, as their workers are integrated into the client’s workforce.
### Labour Contract
1. **Definition**: Labour contracts involve a contractor providing a specific service or completing a job based on agreed terms. The contractor manages their workers, and the client pays for the completion of the job rather than the hours worked.
2. **Service Tax/GST**: For labour contracts, the contractor is responsible for service tax/GST on the labour charges, and they should manage their own statutory obligations such as PF and ESI.
3. **Contractual Control**: In labour contracts, the contractor maintains control over their workers and often supplies materials or tools. The client specifies the work but does not control how the work is executed.
### Key Differences Relevant to Your Case:
1. **Control and Integration**: In your client’s case, the workers are performing tasks under the client’s supervision and within the client’s premises, which suggests a degree of integration typical of manpower supply. However, if your client maintains control over the work execution, it might align more with a labour contract.
2. **Job Work vs. Labour Contract**: Job work typically involves processing raw materials supplied by the client. Since the company does not provide raw materials or receive processed goods back, it does not fit the job work definition.
3. **Documentation**: In a labour contract, you would expect to see charges based on the work completed rather than a per-worker basis, and the contractor is responsible for all statutory compliances.
### Legal Precedents and Opinions:
1. **GST Laws**: Under GST, manpower supply services fall under reverse charge if the recipient is a business entity. However, if the service provided is more aligned with a labour contract (where the contractor’s workers are under their control), then the contractor is liable to pay GST.
2. **Judicial Interpretation**: Courts have generally differentiated between manpower supply and labour contracts based on control and supervision over the workers. If the contractor’s workers are under the direct supervision of the client, it may lean towards manpower supply.
### Conclusion:
Based on your description, it seems your client’s work might fit better into a labour contract rather than a manpower supply, especially since the work involves control and execution by your client’s workers under the contractor’s supervision. However, if the client company exerts significant control over how the work is performed, it might be viewed as a manpower supply service.
To resolve the issue definitively, it may be wise to:
1. **Review Contracts**: Examine the terms of the contract between your client and the company to understand the nature of the agreement.
2. **Consult a Tax Professional**: Engage a tax advisor or legal professional who can provide specific advice based on the complete details and current legal standards.
3. **Refer to GST Guidelines**: Consult GST laws and rulings for a clear interpretation based on similar cases.
This nuanced distinction will help ensure that both your client and the company comply with the correct tax treatment and statutory requirements.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Flat purchase in name of myself,my wife and son
- Tax on Goodwill on LLP
- Capital Gain Tax & Exemption us 54
- Registration of Articleship
- Procedure to surrender export incentive
- Reverse charge on commercial property
- Slight spelling change in PAN Surname
- Audit report for a private limted company ( small company) FY 2024-25
- Old car transaction
- Capital gains -1
- INCOME TAX SLAB RATE AND 87A REBATE
- Trial balance matching
- Drafting Grounds of Appeal under Service Tax
- TDS on Crypto section 194S
- GST Practitioner Details
- MSME Reporting in 3CB-CD
- SECTION 50AA SHORT TERM CAPITAL GAIN IN CASE OF MLD
- GSTR 3B and GST Challan payment
- How to surrender Duty Drawback
- ITC Reversal & re-claim statement [FY 2023-24]
Trending Online Classes
-
GST LIVE Certification Course - 42nd Weekend Batch(With Govt Certificate)
Industry Expert17 May 2025
CAclubindia
