ESOP unfair provisions

This query is : Resolved

Querist : Anonymous

Querist : Anonymous (Querist)

16 February 2011 My company has allotted me 25000 equity shares @31.50/share under ESOP scheme in Sept 2010. At the time of allotment average price of share was Rs.117. And the margin of Rs.85.50(117-31.50) has been taxed @ 30% as my salary including ESOP benefit is more than 8 lakhs. I have availed a loan of Rs.14,28,750/- for the purchase of shares including for tax payment. [25000*31.50+(25000*(117-31.50)*30%)]. That is I have paid tax of Rs.6,41,250/- for a nominal income. In Feb 2011 the share price has come down to Rs.89, and I have sold 16400 shares @ 89.50 to clear the loan including accrued interest from Jan 2011.

Now look at the pity situation. Our govt has taxed me Rs. 6,41,250/- for an income which was not really accrued to me. As per the present law the relaxation available to me is the setoff of Short Term Capital loss of Rs.1,03,125/-[(117 89.5) *25000*15%] against capital gains. And I do not have any capital gain.

What should I do against this unfair practice of law for taxing an unrealized income ?

CA. Lohith Jagadeesh

CA. Lohith Jagadeesh (Expert)
Follow

17 February 2011 Hi,
Can understand your emotions,
However taking a stand that ur been taxed on an unrealised sum may not be correct as youR cost of acquisition @ the time of sale would be Rs.117/ share & not Rs.31.5/ share.

Be happy that they have not given a provision to the effect that your Actual cost of Rs.31.5/share is the Cost of Acqusition.

Either ways...
Had they told that the Cost of Acqusition is amount which you have paid to the Co, i.e Rs.31.5/share, then you would have ended up having a Huge taxable Capital Gain...

So it Evens Out...

The Provisions of ESOP under Income Tax Act 1961 is a Master piece, no Doubts about it!!!!

May be you should do a bit of Tax-planning before being Emotional.

For Further clarification pls Join to my community "Lo Aca"

Regards
CA. LOHITH.J
B.Com,ACA,CS,(ICWA),SAPM Hons,ITF Hons

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now

Summarize this with AI

ChatGPT Perplexity Claude Google AI Grok