Tax on pf withdrawl

This query is : Resolved

Amit (Querist)
Follow

02 July 2012 Hi,
recently i withdraw PF from my prevous company where i worked from dec 2004 to Aug 2006. the PF was credited on my account on 22 oct 2011 ( after 5 years of leaving the company)
Now i have recived the form 16 from previous employer and a breakup of tax and income.
they have levied a tax of Rs 11399 ( excluding cess 342) on Gross salary ( PF settlement) of 44276. which is roughly 26%.
i do not understand how they calculated this amount.

my 2011-12 ( ay 2012-13) taxable salary with my current employer is 525000 which falls under 20% tax bracket.
The old PF was maintiained by DK Malik and Co. with the trust name as 'perot system TSI (INDIA) Pvt Ltd Employees PF trust.
can someone please help me understand as how the old employer has calculated the tax.

Thanks and Regards,
Amit

Amit

Amit (Querist)
Follow

20 July 2012 Any suggestion please

Aashok Kumar Sharma

Aashok Kumar Sharma (Expert)
Follow

26 July 2025 Hi,

Thanks for your detailed query — you're not alone in being confused about the **tax on PF withdrawal from a private trust**, especially after such a long gap (2006 to 2011). Let’s break down what likely happened, why you were taxed at around **26%**, and what options you may have.

---

## ✅ Your Scenario:

* Worked in **previous company** from **Dec 2004 to Aug 2006** (\~1.75 years).
* PF was managed by a **Private Trust** (Perot Systems TSI Pvt Ltd Employees PF Trust).
* You **withdrew PF in October 2011**, i.e., **after 5+ years** of leaving, but **before completing 5 years of active service**.
* You received **Form 16** showing:

* **PF withdrawal as salary**: ₹44,276
* **Tax deducted (TDS)**: ₹11,399 + ₹342 (cess) = ₹11,741 (\~26.5%)

---

## 📌 Key Rule: 5-Year Continuous Service Condition

As per the **Income Tax Act**, withdrawal from a **Recognized Provident Fund (RPF)** is **tax-free** *only* if:

* You have rendered **5 years of continuous service**, OR
* You transferred the PF to another employer's PF account.

You **worked only \~1.75 years**, so this condition is **not met**.

👉 Therefore, your PF withdrawal is considered **taxable**.

---

## 🧾 Tax Treatment of PF Withdrawal Before 5 Years:

| Component | Taxable? | Head |
| --------------------------------- | -------------------------- | -------------------------- |
| Your Contribution | ❌ (unless 80C was claimed) | — |
| Reversed 80C Claimed Earlier | ✅ | Added back to total income |
| Employer Contribution | ✅ | Salary income |
| Interest on Employer Contribution | ✅ | Salary income |
| Interest on Your Contribution | ✅ | Income from Other Sources |

So, the **entire withdrawal (₹44,276)** could have been **classified as “salary income”** (from employer contribution + interest), and thus taxed accordingly.

---

## 📌 Why TDS @ \~26%?

Since your **PF was managed by a private trust**, **they are responsible for deducting TDS** (unlike EPFO, which deducts TDS only if withdrawal exceeds ₹50,000 and at 10%).

Trusts often deduct tax **at the applicable slab rate** or a **flat rate of \~30%** if PAN is not updated or income estimate is uncertain.

In your case:

* You were in the **20% tax slab** in AY 2012–13.
* They likely added **cess/surcharge** or treated you as **having no PAN or high income**, and applied the **maximum marginal rate (\~30%)**.
* That’s why you see **TDS at \~26% on ₹44,276**.

This is **not necessarily your final tax liability** — just tax withheld. You can adjust it in your return.

---

## ✅ What You Can Do:

### 1. **File Your Income Tax Return (AY 2012–13)** (if not already filed):

* Include the ₹44,276 under **“Salary”** or split based on components if breakup is available.
* Show **TDS of ₹11,741** from Form 16 (old employer).
* If your total tax liability is **lower**, you can **claim a refund**.

📎 **Tip**: Use Form 26AS (or now AIS) to ensure the TDS is reported correctly under your PAN.

---

## 🔍 Additional Notes:

* If **you did not claim Section 80C** benefit in FY 2004–05 or 2005–06 for your own PF contributions, then that portion is **not taxable**.
* If your **PAN was not linked** or not given to the Trust, TDS could have been deducted at **higher flat rate** (up to 30%).

---

## ✅ Summary:

| Item | Amount |
| ------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- |
| PF Withdrawn | ₹44,276 |
| TDS Deducted | ₹11,741 |
| Reason for Tax | PF withdrawal before 5 years of service |
| Why High Rate? | Likely taxed at flat or marginal rate by private trust |
| Can You Get Refund? | ✅ Yes, if total tax liability is lower after return filing |

---

Would you like help preparing a **reconstruction of income/tax for AY 2012–13**, or a sample **refund claim** if TDS exceeds your actual tax liability?

Happy to assist further.

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now

Summarize this with AI

ChatGPT Perplexity Claude Google AI Grok