Large commision from marketing
This query is : Resolved
15 July 2012
MY MANY CLIENTS HAVE BIG COMMSION FROM MARKETING OF FINANCIAL/HEALTH PRODUCTS.
MANY OF THEM HAVE INCOME OF ABOVE 25 LAKHS OR 40 LAKHS (BELOW 60 LACKS).
ALSO THEY DONT MAINTAIN ANY BILLS ETC OF THEIR EXPENSES & NO ANY A/C.
1) CAN I SHOW THIER INCOME UNDER "NON MAINTAINANCE OF BOOKS"...? IF YES THEN WILL THEIR BE ANY PENALY OR OBJECTIONS...?
2)HOW MUCH % OF EXPENSES CAN I SHOW AS PER THEIR INCOME LEVEL SO THAT A.O. WILL NOT OBJECTS....? AS PER YOUR EXPERIENCE....? (THEY DONT HAVE ANY ACTUAL EXP. RECORDS).
3)ANY SPECIAL CARE I HAVE TO TAKE AS PER YOUR EXPERIENCE...? DIPAK GULHANE 7276993000
MANY OF THEM HAVE INCOME OF ABOVE 25 LAKHS OR 40 LAKHS (BELOW 60 LACKS).
ALSO THEY DONT MAINTAIN ANY BILLS ETC OF THEIR EXPENSES & NO ANY A/C.
1) CAN I SHOW THIER INCOME UNDER "NON MAINTAINANCE OF BOOKS"...? IF YES THEN WILL THEIR BE ANY PENALY OR OBJECTIONS...?
2)HOW MUCH % OF EXPENSES CAN I SHOW AS PER THEIR INCOME LEVEL SO THAT A.O. WILL NOT OBJECTS....? AS PER YOUR EXPERIENCE....? (THEY DONT HAVE ANY ACTUAL EXP. RECORDS).
3)ANY SPECIAL CARE I HAVE TO TAKE AS PER YOUR EXPERIENCE...? DIPAK GULHANE 7276993000
16 July 2012
ALL EXPERTS R SO MUCH BUZY TO REPLY TO THIS QUERY...?
02 August 2024
When dealing with clients who have substantial income from marketing activities but do not maintain proper records, here’s how to approach their accounting and tax reporting, especially under the provisions of Indian tax law:
### **1. Income Reporting and Maintenance of Books**
**1.1. Income Reporting Under Non-Maintenance of Books**
If your clients have substantial income and do not maintain books of accounts, you may report their income under the presumptive taxation scheme if applicable, or otherwise as per regular provisions. Here are the key points:
- **Section 44AD**: For businesses with turnover up to ₹2 crore, income can be declared at a presumptive rate of 8% or 6% (for digital transactions) of gross receipts. However, this may not apply directly to marketing or commission income.
- **Section 44AE**: For businesses related to transport, if they own vehicles, they can use this section, but it typically doesn’t apply to marketing commissions.
- **Section 44ADA**: For professionals (accountants, doctors, etc.) with gross receipts up to ₹50 lakh, a presumptive income of 50% of gross receipts is considered. This might not apply if your clients are not classified as professionals.
If none of these apply, and if your clients’ income exceeds the limits for presumptive taxation, then their income should be reported under the regular provisions, which require maintenance of books of accounts.
**Penalties and Objections**:
- If the books are not maintained, and if the income is reported under non-maintenance, there might be penalties for non-compliance or incorrect reporting. It’s crucial to adhere to accurate income reporting and tax payment to avoid objections from the Assessing Officer (A.O.) or penalties.
### **2. Expense Deductions Without Records**
**2.1. Presumptive Expenses**
Without actual records, you can consider claiming a percentage of income as expenses based on general industry norms or historical data:
- **For Marketing Commission Income**: Generally, without records, it is challenging to determine the exact percentage of expenses. However, many tax practitioners use a range of 30-50% of gross income as a rough estimate, depending on the nature of marketing activities.
**2.2. **Suggested Approach**
- **Estimate**: Use a reasonable estimate based on the nature of the business and industry practices.
- **Documentation**: Maintain a note justifying the percentage used, and ideally, gather any available supporting documentation or reasonable approximations.
**2.3. **Experience-based Recommendations**
- **Documentation**: Even if exact records are not available, try to collect any documents, invoices, or receipts that can substantiate some of the expense claims.
- **Transparency**: Ensure transparency in your reporting and be prepared to provide justifications for the expense percentages used if queried by the A.O.
### **3. Special Considerations**
**3.1. **Prepare for Scrutiny**
- **Tax Audits**: Be prepared for possible tax audits if the income is high and books are not maintained. The A.O. may request additional information or justification.
- **Compliance**: Ensure that all income is reported accurately and taxes are paid as per the applicable provisions. This includes timely filing of returns and accurate declarations.
**3.2. **Advisory**
- **Consult a Tax Professional**: Given the complexity and the risk of scrutiny, consulting a tax professional or chartered accountant for accurate filing and tax planning is advisable.
- **Regular Records**: Encourage your clients to maintain proper records moving forward to avoid complications in the future.
**Summary**
- **Income Reporting**: If books are not maintained, consider presumptive taxation schemes where applicable, but be prepared for potential penalties if not.
- **Expenses**: Use reasonable estimates for expenses and maintain documentation or justification for these estimates.
- **Compliance**: Ensure accurate income reporting and tax payment, and consider consulting a tax professional to navigate complex scenarios.
By following these guidelines, you can better manage the tax reporting for clients with significant income and inadequate record-keeping.
### **1. Income Reporting and Maintenance of Books**
**1.1. Income Reporting Under Non-Maintenance of Books**
If your clients have substantial income and do not maintain books of accounts, you may report their income under the presumptive taxation scheme if applicable, or otherwise as per regular provisions. Here are the key points:
- **Section 44AD**: For businesses with turnover up to ₹2 crore, income can be declared at a presumptive rate of 8% or 6% (for digital transactions) of gross receipts. However, this may not apply directly to marketing or commission income.
- **Section 44AE**: For businesses related to transport, if they own vehicles, they can use this section, but it typically doesn’t apply to marketing commissions.
- **Section 44ADA**: For professionals (accountants, doctors, etc.) with gross receipts up to ₹50 lakh, a presumptive income of 50% of gross receipts is considered. This might not apply if your clients are not classified as professionals.
If none of these apply, and if your clients’ income exceeds the limits for presumptive taxation, then their income should be reported under the regular provisions, which require maintenance of books of accounts.
**Penalties and Objections**:
- If the books are not maintained, and if the income is reported under non-maintenance, there might be penalties for non-compliance or incorrect reporting. It’s crucial to adhere to accurate income reporting and tax payment to avoid objections from the Assessing Officer (A.O.) or penalties.
### **2. Expense Deductions Without Records**
**2.1. Presumptive Expenses**
Without actual records, you can consider claiming a percentage of income as expenses based on general industry norms or historical data:
- **For Marketing Commission Income**: Generally, without records, it is challenging to determine the exact percentage of expenses. However, many tax practitioners use a range of 30-50% of gross income as a rough estimate, depending on the nature of marketing activities.
**2.2. **Suggested Approach**
- **Estimate**: Use a reasonable estimate based on the nature of the business and industry practices.
- **Documentation**: Maintain a note justifying the percentage used, and ideally, gather any available supporting documentation or reasonable approximations.
**2.3. **Experience-based Recommendations**
- **Documentation**: Even if exact records are not available, try to collect any documents, invoices, or receipts that can substantiate some of the expense claims.
- **Transparency**: Ensure transparency in your reporting and be prepared to provide justifications for the expense percentages used if queried by the A.O.
### **3. Special Considerations**
**3.1. **Prepare for Scrutiny**
- **Tax Audits**: Be prepared for possible tax audits if the income is high and books are not maintained. The A.O. may request additional information or justification.
- **Compliance**: Ensure that all income is reported accurately and taxes are paid as per the applicable provisions. This includes timely filing of returns and accurate declarations.
**3.2. **Advisory**
- **Consult a Tax Professional**: Given the complexity and the risk of scrutiny, consulting a tax professional or chartered accountant for accurate filing and tax planning is advisable.
- **Regular Records**: Encourage your clients to maintain proper records moving forward to avoid complications in the future.
**Summary**
- **Income Reporting**: If books are not maintained, consider presumptive taxation schemes where applicable, but be prepared for potential penalties if not.
- **Expenses**: Use reasonable estimates for expenses and maintain documentation or justification for these estimates.
- **Compliance**: Ensure accurate income reporting and tax payment, and consider consulting a tax professional to navigate complex scenarios.
By following these guidelines, you can better manage the tax reporting for clients with significant income and inadequate record-keeping.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Selecting Tax Regime while for calculating tax relief on under Section89 of income tax act 1961.
- Cloud service
- Relief Calculation u/s 89 of ITax 1961 in TableA Form10E
- Applicability of RCM on Frieght Inward supplies received from un-registered person
- GST on Fresh Juice Center(Sugarcane)
- Sale of Gold ornaments
- GST ON FOREIGN CLIENT
- Can we issue an invoice today
- SALE OF GOODS FROM OTHER STATE
- Ca final exam registration may-26
- Expenses add back in profit
- Forgot to update debit note in gst
- B2B Amendment
- Restoration of certificate of practice
- Regarding change in correspondence address in SSP portal
- Regarding Advance Tax not claimed in the Return of Income for A.Y. 2025-26
- No Compliences after incorporation
- USEFUL LIFE OF USED/SECOND HAND COMMERCIAL VEHICLES
- Claiming TDS deducted by builder on Hardship compensation and Corpus
- Address Change to another state of a Registered Trust with 12AB approval
Trending Online Classes
-
DT & Audit (Exam Oriented Fastrack Batch) - For May 26 Exams and onwards Full English
CA Bhanwar Borana & CA Shubham Keswani
CAclubindia
