Income tax treament of chit dividend & discount
This query is : Resolved
Querist : Anonymous
Querist :
Anonymous
(Querist)
02 July 2012
My client Raj is a dealer in food grains and files his return of income u/s 44AD as his T/O will be less than 30 lakhs.
He participates in chit scheme in one of reputed chit co.He gets chit dividend and takes chit ie total amount on discount.
If his chit dividend is more than chit discount, under which head we have to show surplus dividend ?
If his chit discount is more than chit dividend, where to claim the loss from chit?
He does not maitain any accounts.
Is it necessary to offer surplus for tax
as he files return u/s 44AD.?
CAN we claim loss from chit when we file return under sec 44AD?
Kindly advise me reg treatment of chit dividend / chit discount in the above circumstances?
He participates in chit scheme in one of reputed chit co.He gets chit dividend and takes chit ie total amount on discount.
If his chit dividend is more than chit discount, under which head we have to show surplus dividend ?
If his chit discount is more than chit dividend, where to claim the loss from chit?
He does not maitain any accounts.
Is it necessary to offer surplus for tax
as he files return u/s 44AD.?
CAN we claim loss from chit when we file return under sec 44AD?
Kindly advise me reg treatment of chit dividend / chit discount in the above circumstances?
Querist : Anonymous
Querist :
Anonymous
(Querist)
05 July 2012
KINDLY advice me on the above issue as due date is 31 july 12
01 August 2024
In the context of your client's chit transactions, here's a breakdown of how to handle chit dividend and discount for tax purposes:
### **1. Understanding Chit Transactions**
- **Chit Dividend**: This is the amount received as a part of the chit fund scheme, which is treated as a gain or income.
- **Chit Discount**: This is the amount received less than the total amount of the chit, which could be considered as a discount.
### **Tax Treatment**
**1. If Chit Dividend is More than Chit Discount**
- **Chit Dividend**: The surplus amount received as a dividend is considered as income and should be included in the calculation of income for tax purposes.
- **Head of Income**: Since your client is a dealer in food grains and files under section 44AD, the surplus chit dividend should be treated as **"Other Income"**. You should show it in the **"Income from Other Sources"** section of the ITR form.
**2. If Chit Discount is More than Chit Dividend**
- **Chit Discount**: If the amount received is less than the total value of the chit, resulting in a discount, this could be treated as a loss. However, since the client does not maintain accounts and files under section 44AD, claiming this loss directly may not be straightforward.
- **Head of Income**: Under section 44AD, the computation of income is done based on a presumptive basis and does not allow for deductions or losses from other sources. Therefore, the loss from chit discount cannot be directly claimed under this scheme.
### **Implications for Filing Under Section 44AD**
- **Income Under Section 44AD**: Section 44AD provides for a presumptive taxation scheme where income is presumed to be a certain percentage of turnover, and no further deductions are allowed. Therefore:
- **Chit Dividend**: Should be included as "Income from Other Sources" in the ITR, outside the presumptive income under section 44AD.
- **Chit Discount**: Since losses from chit transactions cannot be claimed under section 44AD, they cannot be used to reduce taxable income under this section.
### **Necessary Actions**
1. **Declare Surplus Dividend**: Include the chit dividend as "Income from Other Sources" while filing the return, even though the return is filed under section 44AD.
2. **Non-Claim of Loss**: Do not claim the loss from chit discount under section 44AD as it is not permissible to adjust such losses in this presumptive taxation scheme.
### **Filing the Return**
- Ensure that the surplus chit dividend is reported correctly in the "Income from Other Sources" section.
- For losses from chit discount, you cannot claim it under section 44AD, but you may need to address this separately if there are other sources of income or if you consider moving out of the presumptive taxation scheme.
If there are complications or uncertainties, or if you need further clarification, consulting a tax professional would be beneficial to ensure accurate reporting and compliance.
### **1. Understanding Chit Transactions**
- **Chit Dividend**: This is the amount received as a part of the chit fund scheme, which is treated as a gain or income.
- **Chit Discount**: This is the amount received less than the total amount of the chit, which could be considered as a discount.
### **Tax Treatment**
**1. If Chit Dividend is More than Chit Discount**
- **Chit Dividend**: The surplus amount received as a dividend is considered as income and should be included in the calculation of income for tax purposes.
- **Head of Income**: Since your client is a dealer in food grains and files under section 44AD, the surplus chit dividend should be treated as **"Other Income"**. You should show it in the **"Income from Other Sources"** section of the ITR form.
**2. If Chit Discount is More than Chit Dividend**
- **Chit Discount**: If the amount received is less than the total value of the chit, resulting in a discount, this could be treated as a loss. However, since the client does not maintain accounts and files under section 44AD, claiming this loss directly may not be straightforward.
- **Head of Income**: Under section 44AD, the computation of income is done based on a presumptive basis and does not allow for deductions or losses from other sources. Therefore, the loss from chit discount cannot be directly claimed under this scheme.
### **Implications for Filing Under Section 44AD**
- **Income Under Section 44AD**: Section 44AD provides for a presumptive taxation scheme where income is presumed to be a certain percentage of turnover, and no further deductions are allowed. Therefore:
- **Chit Dividend**: Should be included as "Income from Other Sources" in the ITR, outside the presumptive income under section 44AD.
- **Chit Discount**: Since losses from chit transactions cannot be claimed under section 44AD, they cannot be used to reduce taxable income under this section.
### **Necessary Actions**
1. **Declare Surplus Dividend**: Include the chit dividend as "Income from Other Sources" while filing the return, even though the return is filed under section 44AD.
2. **Non-Claim of Loss**: Do not claim the loss from chit discount under section 44AD as it is not permissible to adjust such losses in this presumptive taxation scheme.
### **Filing the Return**
- Ensure that the surplus chit dividend is reported correctly in the "Income from Other Sources" section.
- For losses from chit discount, you cannot claim it under section 44AD, but you may need to address this separately if there are other sources of income or if you consider moving out of the presumptive taxation scheme.
If there are complications or uncertainties, or if you need further clarification, consulting a tax professional would be beneficial to ensure accurate reporting and compliance.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Selecting Tax Regime while for calculating tax relief on under Section89 of income tax act 1961.
- Relief Calculation u/s 89 of ITax 1961 in TableA Form10E
- Cloud service
- Forgot to update debit note in gst
- GST ON FOREIGN CLIENT
- Can we issue an invoice today
- SALE OF GOODS FROM OTHER STATE
- Ca final exam registration may-26
- Sale of Gold ornaments
- Conversion of Pvt Ltd Company to a LLP
- Tds on GST in connection with sale to public company
- B2B Amendment
- Restoration of certificate of practice
- Regarding change in correspondence address in SSP portal
- Regarding Advance Tax not claimed in the Return of Income for A.Y. 2025-26
- No Compliences after incorporation
- USEFUL LIFE OF USED/SECOND HAND COMMERCIAL VEHICLES
- Claiming TDS deducted by builder on Hardship compensation and Corpus
- Address Change to another state of a Registered Trust with 12AB approval
- Updated return in budget 2026
Trending Online Classes
-
DT & Audit (Exam Oriented Fastrack Batch) - For May 26 Exams and onwards Full English
CA Bhanwar Borana & CA Shubham Keswani
CAclubindia
