Ca foundation paper 2 - business law
This query is : Resolved
25 April 2019
In November 2018 exam there was one question as under :
Mr. Ramesh promised to pay Rs. 50,000 to his wife Mrs. Lali so that she can spend the sum on her birthday. Mrs. Lali insisted her husband to make a written agreement if he really loved her. Mr. Ramesh made a written agreement and registered the agreement under the law.
Mr. Ramesh failed to pay the specified amount to his wife Mrs. Lali.
Now Mrs. Lali wants to file a suit against Mr. Ramesh and recover the promised amount. Referring to the applicable provisions of the Contract Act 1872, advise whether Mrs. Lali will succeed?
The suggested answer as posted on ICAI site shown the answer as under :
To create a valid contract, there must be an intention on the part of the parties to create legal relationship between them. In social agreements it is presumed that there is no intention to create legal relationship. So social or domestic types of agreements are not enforceable in court of law and hence they do not result into contracts.
In the given circumstances wife will not be able to recover the amount as it was a social agreement and the parties did not intend to create any legal relations.
Is this answer correct? Is there any relevance of section 25 of ICA which provides for exception to consideration - Out of natural love and affection, written registered agreement and close relation between the parties.
Please give answer with reason
Mr. Ramesh promised to pay Rs. 50,000 to his wife Mrs. Lali so that she can spend the sum on her birthday. Mrs. Lali insisted her husband to make a written agreement if he really loved her. Mr. Ramesh made a written agreement and registered the agreement under the law.
Mr. Ramesh failed to pay the specified amount to his wife Mrs. Lali.
Now Mrs. Lali wants to file a suit against Mr. Ramesh and recover the promised amount. Referring to the applicable provisions of the Contract Act 1872, advise whether Mrs. Lali will succeed?
The suggested answer as posted on ICAI site shown the answer as under :
To create a valid contract, there must be an intention on the part of the parties to create legal relationship between them. In social agreements it is presumed that there is no intention to create legal relationship. So social or domestic types of agreements are not enforceable in court of law and hence they do not result into contracts.
In the given circumstances wife will not be able to recover the amount as it was a social agreement and the parties did not intend to create any legal relations.
Is this answer correct? Is there any relevance of section 25 of ICA which provides for exception to consideration - Out of natural love and affection, written registered agreement and close relation between the parties.
Please give answer with reason
Message likes :
1 times
07 June 2019
you are talking of exception to "No consideration no contract"
The question is aiming at "intention of the parties"
Please note the difference between the two.So to say husband and wife can very well enter into contract without consideration but then it has to have intentions to create legal relation. Intention to create legal relationship is missing in this and hence the answer.
The question is aiming at "intention of the parties"
Please note the difference between the two.So to say husband and wife can very well enter into contract without consideration but then it has to have intentions to create legal relation. Intention to create legal relationship is missing in this and hence the answer.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- CG Tax On residential property
- Post Office RD Interest
- Applicable TDS for Purchase of Flat from NRI
- Eway bill for machinery reparing
- Claiming exemption of perquisite for employee-owned car under New Tax Regime in ITR-2
- Under construction property in ITR
- Gift of mutual fund units to daughter
- Not able to file ITR
- Upload Level ValidationITR3Category of Defect B/D
- Reporting of STCG on Property in ITR
- ITR-4 vs ITR 5
- PF Taxable Income
- Clarification on Tax Audit Applicability and Reporting of F&O Transactions in ITR-3
- Interest credited in FY2025-2026 & TDS therein by EPFO does not reflect in AIS or Form 26AS
- 44ad eligble money lending interest
- Delisted shares sold in off market/ Rebate u/s87A
- In Exports Sales HSN details where to fill
- Opting out" of regime provided under subsection (1A) of Section 115BAC but Form 10IEA is not filed.
- Difference in tax comparison report
- Gst invoice numbering and delivery challan numbering
Trending Online Classes
-
DT & Audit (Exam Oriented Fastrack Batch) - For May 26 Exams and onwards Full English
CA Bhanwar Borana & CA Shubham Keswani
Subscribe to Pro
Join an elite circle of professionals
CAclubindia
