Sec 44ab applicable to credit society or not ?
This query is : Resolved
06 August 2018
Is Tax Audit Applicable to Co-operative Society which providing credit faciltiy to its members having total sale of services more than 2 Crore and also enjoying deduction u/s 80P(100% profit exempt) ?
If Its applicable then which audit report to file ?
If Its applicable then which audit report to file ?
06 August 2018
Tax audit not applicable.
06 August 2018
but sir ITR 5 is showing error that 44ab applicable as turnover exceeds 1 crore
23 July 2025
The applicability of **Section 44AB** to **Co-operative Societies**, especially those providing credit facilities to their members, is a bit nuanced. Let's break it down:
### **Section 44AB** - Applicability:
Section 44AB mandates the **tax audit** of accounts for businesses if the **total turnover** or **gross receipts** exceeds Rs. **1 crore** (or Rs. 50 lakh for professionals). However, in the case of **cooperative societies**, there are additional considerations.
### **Co-operative Society with Credit Facilities:**
A **cooperative society** providing credit facilities to its members would typically fall under the category of a **cooperative bank** or a **credit cooperative society**. If such a society is **providing credit services**, then:
1. **Tax Audit Applicability**:
* **Tax audit is generally applicable** under **Section 44AB** for cooperative societies if the **total turnover or gross receipts exceed Rs. 1 crore** in a financial year.
* The fact that the cooperative society is enjoying **100% deduction under Section 80P** for profits does **not** exempt it from the tax audit requirements. Section 80P exemption applies to the **income of the cooperative society**, not the **compliance requirement** like tax audits.
2. **ITR Filing**:
* Since the **turnover exceeds Rs. 1 crore**, the **ITR 5** is showing an error because **Section 44AB** is applicable due to turnover crossing the threshold.
* Even though the society enjoys a deduction under **Section 80P**, the tax audit under **Section 44AB** is required as per the **Income Tax Act**, and the correct audit report (Form 3CA/3CB) should be filed.
3. **Filing ITR**:
* The **correct audit report** is typically **Form 3CA/3CB** for **cooperative societies** that are subject to tax audit under **Section 44AB**.
* The fact that the society enjoys an exemption under **Section 80P** does not affect the requirement for the audit under **Section 44AB**.
4. **Section 80P Exemption**:
* The **100% profit exemption** under **Section 80P** applies only to the income of the society (i.e., the income earned from the business activities that are eligible for the exemption), not to the overall **audit requirement**.
* The exemption means the profits are not taxable, but the **audit obligation** still applies due to the **size of the turnover**.
### **What Should Be Done:**
* Even though the cooperative society is **enjoying 100% exemption under Section 80P**, **Section 44AB** will apply if the **turnover exceeds Rs. 1 crore**, and the society needs to conduct a **tax audit**.
* **Form 3CA/3CB** will be required, and the **audit report** should be filed along with **ITR 5**.
* **ITR 5** showing an error indicating the applicability of **Section 44AB** is correct, and the **tax audit** requirement is valid.
### **Conclusion:**
Yes, **tax audit under Section 44AB is applicable to the cooperative society**, even if it enjoys **100% exemption under Section 80P**, **if the turnover exceeds Rs. 1 crore**. The society will need to file **Form 3CA/3CB** along with **ITR 5**.
### **Section 44AB** - Applicability:
Section 44AB mandates the **tax audit** of accounts for businesses if the **total turnover** or **gross receipts** exceeds Rs. **1 crore** (or Rs. 50 lakh for professionals). However, in the case of **cooperative societies**, there are additional considerations.
### **Co-operative Society with Credit Facilities:**
A **cooperative society** providing credit facilities to its members would typically fall under the category of a **cooperative bank** or a **credit cooperative society**. If such a society is **providing credit services**, then:
1. **Tax Audit Applicability**:
* **Tax audit is generally applicable** under **Section 44AB** for cooperative societies if the **total turnover or gross receipts exceed Rs. 1 crore** in a financial year.
* The fact that the cooperative society is enjoying **100% deduction under Section 80P** for profits does **not** exempt it from the tax audit requirements. Section 80P exemption applies to the **income of the cooperative society**, not the **compliance requirement** like tax audits.
2. **ITR Filing**:
* Since the **turnover exceeds Rs. 1 crore**, the **ITR 5** is showing an error because **Section 44AB** is applicable due to turnover crossing the threshold.
* Even though the society enjoys a deduction under **Section 80P**, the tax audit under **Section 44AB** is required as per the **Income Tax Act**, and the correct audit report (Form 3CA/3CB) should be filed.
3. **Filing ITR**:
* The **correct audit report** is typically **Form 3CA/3CB** for **cooperative societies** that are subject to tax audit under **Section 44AB**.
* The fact that the society enjoys an exemption under **Section 80P** does not affect the requirement for the audit under **Section 44AB**.
4. **Section 80P Exemption**:
* The **100% profit exemption** under **Section 80P** applies only to the income of the society (i.e., the income earned from the business activities that are eligible for the exemption), not to the overall **audit requirement**.
* The exemption means the profits are not taxable, but the **audit obligation** still applies due to the **size of the turnover**.
### **What Should Be Done:**
* Even though the cooperative society is **enjoying 100% exemption under Section 80P**, **Section 44AB** will apply if the **turnover exceeds Rs. 1 crore**, and the society needs to conduct a **tax audit**.
* **Form 3CA/3CB** will be required, and the **audit report** should be filed along with **ITR 5**.
* **ITR 5** showing an error indicating the applicability of **Section 44AB** is correct, and the **tax audit** requirement is valid.
### **Conclusion:**
Yes, **tax audit under Section 44AB is applicable to the cooperative society**, even if it enjoys **100% exemption under Section 80P**, **if the turnover exceeds Rs. 1 crore**. The society will need to file **Form 3CA/3CB** along with **ITR 5**.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Credit rating model
- Insurance make against any item and later get insurance claim received
- GST APPEAL ITC
- Youtube income
- TDS U/S 194S VDA
- TCS Return Without PAN
- Multiple warehouse
- Surcharge on discretionary AOP/TRUST for AY 25-26
- Surcharge applicability on LTCG loss
- Requirement of Form 15CA CB - Rent payment
- 115-BAC-for AOP-private discretionary trust
- Statutory Deduction-PF
- Query regarding applicability of UDIN on MCA forms signed using DSC by a Chartered Accountant
- GST ON PERSONAL MOTORCAR SOLD
- Cash gift by grand mother to her grand daughter
- APPLICABILITY OF RCM ON MAN POWER SUPPLY BY UN REGISTERED PERSON TO REGISTERED PERSON.
- Tax amount diff in Gstr1 and 3B in tax compare reports
- Spice form, ? mark comes in address
- Tds on GST in connection with sale to public company
- B2B Amendment
Trending Online Classes
-
DT & Audit (Exam Oriented Fastrack Batch) - For May 26 Exams and onwards Full English
CA Bhanwar Borana & CA Shubham Keswani
CAclubindia
