Rectification of Mistakes by AO
This query is : Open
04 March 2009
Hello all,
As per my reading of the sec. 154 i have understood that it is open for the AO to rectify any mistakes if it relates on the judments given by SC in any case even if such judment is passed after the completion of assessment by AO.Pls let me know whether my understabding of the concept is correct and pls correct me if i am wrong.
As per my reading of the sec. 154 i have understood that it is open for the AO to rectify any mistakes if it relates on the judments given by SC in any case even if such judment is passed after the completion of assessment by AO.Pls let me know whether my understabding of the concept is correct and pls correct me if i am wrong.
04 March 2009
i dont thik so :
reference is from direct taxes AY 2008-09 Vinod K Singhania :
if the supreme court has subsequently reversed or modified the exxiting interpretation of law in another case it does not render earlier judgement open to review nor does it constitute mistake or error apparent on face of record envisaged US 154.
reference is from direct taxes AY 2008-09 Vinod K Singhania :
if the supreme court has subsequently reversed or modified the exxiting interpretation of law in another case it does not render earlier judgement open to review nor does it constitute mistake or error apparent on face of record envisaged US 154.
05 March 2009
Hello sir,
Thanks for helping me out, but i still have s little doubt as regards to the case law and wordings given in the book of Mr. Girish Ahuja,which says and I quote " The case law of CIT v Subodhchandra.S.Patel (2004) 138 Taxman 185 (Guj),held that the non consideration of a judgment of the HC or SC would always constitute a mistake apparent from record regardless of the judgment being rendered prior to or subsequent to the order proposed to be rectified." Would in this situation too the Ao would not be in the position to rectify the order.
Thanks for helping me out, but i still have s little doubt as regards to the case law and wordings given in the book of Mr. Girish Ahuja,which says and I quote " The case law of CIT v Subodhchandra.S.Patel (2004) 138 Taxman 185 (Guj),held that the non consideration of a judgment of the HC or SC would always constitute a mistake apparent from record regardless of the judgment being rendered prior to or subsequent to the order proposed to be rectified." Would in this situation too the Ao would not be in the position to rectify the order.
05 March 2009
case laws given in VKS are :
geo miller & Co. Ltd. V CIT [2004] 134 taxman 552 (Cal.)
Smriti Properties Pvt. Ltc. v Settlement Commission [2005] 149 taxman 386 (Cal.)
he further adds :
likewise a later judgement of jurisdictional High Court can not give rise to a mistake apparent from record in order passed by Tribunal earlier - Trilok Ship Breakers PVt. Ltd. v CIT [2003] 84 ITD 48 (Mum.)
i need to refer book of Mr. Girish Ahuja, and the case law of CIT v Subodhchandra.S.Patel (2004) 138 Taxman 185 (Guj), and many times different High court take diffrent views,so there is controversy
geo miller & Co. Ltd. V CIT [2004] 134 taxman 552 (Cal.)
Smriti Properties Pvt. Ltc. v Settlement Commission [2005] 149 taxman 386 (Cal.)
he further adds :
likewise a later judgement of jurisdictional High Court can not give rise to a mistake apparent from record in order passed by Tribunal earlier - Trilok Ship Breakers PVt. Ltd. v CIT [2003] 84 ITD 48 (Mum.)
i need to refer book of Mr. Girish Ahuja, and the case law of CIT v Subodhchandra.S.Patel (2004) 138 Taxman 185 (Guj), and many times different High court take diffrent views,so there is controversy
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- GST ITC REVERSE
- Fixe term employment
- Is any professional CA is here please reply
- EXPORT BILL UNDER LUT FREIGHT CHARGE INCLUED IN INVOICE IT LIABLE TO TAX
- Gift Received from nonblood relative
- Section 50-fixed asset-->building ceases to exist
- RCM ISSUE ON RENT AND TRANSPORTATION CHARGES
- Foreign lottery ticket bought online from India: legality, tax and consequences
- Putting a heading on received mail
- Tax Audit u/s 44AB for Transport Business A proprietorship is engaged in transportation business and
- Goods sold but invoice not issued
- Tally: Imported bank entries do not show up in manual reconciliation
- Sales of goods of amount Rs97 lakhs to a party
- Confused About My Career After 12th — Cyber Security, AI or Finance? Need Guidance
- STATUTORY AUDIT OF A SMALL PRIVATE COMPANY INCORPORATED ON 28.03.2025
- Guidance Needed: Linking Multiple Form 26QB Payments and Responding to ITD Defaulter Notice
- How to pay remaining amount of TDS after due date?
- Resigning a auditor from the company for misconduct
- RCM @ 5% on Hamali charges, Transport Charges, Unloading charges we take ITC or not
- CALCULATION OF DEFFERED TAX - OP BL IS DTL & CURRET IT DTA
Trending Online Classes
-
DT & Audit (Exam Oriented Fastrack Batch) - For May 26 Exams and onwards Full English
CA Bhanwar Borana & CA Shubham Keswani
Subscribe to Pro
Join an elite circle of professionals
CAclubindia
