Professional Ethic
This query is : Resolved
21 March 2010
Hi,
I have a doubt relating to professional ethics of CA's. I will explain it with an example. AB and associates is a firm of Chartered Accountants. Mr.A signs the audit report of few clients for example x pvt ltd. Here Mr.A retires from the firm and starts his on sole proprietary concern named A and associates. Now he signs for the audit report of x pvt ltd under his new concern name A and associates. Does nt he need to communicate to the old firm about this as the old auditor is AB and Associates. If he does nt communicate will it lead to professional misconduct as the new auditor needs to communicate to the old auditor who had signed the report.
Here my doubt is as Mr.A himself signing in both the cases, is he exempt from informing to AB and Associates.
Since he is taking one of the clients from AB and Associates which belongs to it. It becomes a professional misconduct. So he is Liable to communicate it to AB and Associates. Is'nt it?
Please let me know.
I have a doubt relating to professional ethics of CA's. I will explain it with an example. AB and associates is a firm of Chartered Accountants. Mr.A signs the audit report of few clients for example x pvt ltd. Here Mr.A retires from the firm and starts his on sole proprietary concern named A and associates. Now he signs for the audit report of x pvt ltd under his new concern name A and associates. Does nt he need to communicate to the old firm about this as the old auditor is AB and Associates. If he does nt communicate will it lead to professional misconduct as the new auditor needs to communicate to the old auditor who had signed the report.
Here my doubt is as Mr.A himself signing in both the cases, is he exempt from informing to AB and Associates.
Since he is taking one of the clients from AB and Associates which belongs to it. It becomes a professional misconduct. So he is Liable to communicate it to AB and Associates. Is'nt it?
Please let me know.
21 March 2010
Necessarily Mr. A has to seek no objection from AB and Associates through communication before he take up the audit of x pvt ltd.
22 March 2010
Sir thank you for your kind response. Can you tell me, is there any specific case law relating to my query. If there is any can you please let me know.
22 March 2010
.
10 August 2024
The scenario you've described involves several important aspects of professional ethics for Chartered Accountants (CAs) in India, particularly in relation to transitioning from a partnership to a sole proprietorship and handling client relationships.
### **Key Points on Professional Ethics**
1. **Ethical Guidelines:**
- **Transfer of Clients:** According to the guidelines provided by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI), when a partner leaves a firm and starts a new practice, there are specific protocols for dealing with clients of the old firm.
- **Professional Conduct:** Even if Mr. A is the same individual and is now working under a new firm name, he must adhere to professional conduct rules regarding client transition and communication.
2. **Communication to the Old Firm:**
- **Notification Requirement:** It is generally expected that if a partner leaves a firm and takes clients with them, the new firm (in this case, Mr. A’s sole proprietorship) should inform the old firm (AB and Associates) about the transition.
- **Client Consent:** The new auditor should also ensure that there is proper consent from the client and that all ethical procedures are followed to avoid any conflict of interest.
3. **Professional Misconduct:**
- **Potential Misconduct:** If Mr. A does not inform the old firm and takes over the audit work for X Pvt. Ltd. without following the proper protocol, it could be considered professional misconduct. This is particularly true if the transition involves a conflict of interest or if the client has not provided proper consent for the transition.
### **ICAI Guidelines and Code of Ethics**
- **ICAI Code of Ethics:** The ICAI Code of Ethics mandates that a Chartered Accountant must maintain confidentiality, avoid conflicts of interest, and adhere to professional conduct standards. This includes the requirement to communicate with the previous firm when clients are transitioning between firms.
- **Regulation 190A of the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949:** This regulation addresses the procedure for the transfer of clients when a CA moves from one firm to another. It mandates that a CA must obtain client consent and communicate with the old firm.
### **Relevant Case Law**
While specific case law might not be directly applicable in this context, the principles of professional ethics and conduct outlined by the ICAI and the Chartered Accountants Act provide a framework. The ICAI’s disciplinary cases often cover issues related to professional conduct, but you would need to refer to specific disciplinary rulings or ethical guidance issued by the ICAI for detailed precedents.
### **Summary**
- **Communication is Crucial:** Mr. A should inform AB and Associates about the transition of the client to avoid any issues of professional misconduct.
- **Follow Ethical Guidelines:** The transition must be handled in accordance with the ICAI’s Code of Ethics and relevant regulations, including obtaining client consent and ensuring no conflict of interest.
### **Recommended Actions**
- **Consult ICAI Guidelines:** Refer to the ICAI’s Code of Ethics and other relevant professional guidelines for detailed procedures on client transitions.
- **Seek Professional Advice:** If there is any uncertainty, consulting with the ICAI or seeking legal advice from a professional specializing in ethics and compliance may provide further clarification.
Ensuring compliance with these guidelines helps maintain professional integrity and avoid any potential issues related to professional misconduct.
### **Key Points on Professional Ethics**
1. **Ethical Guidelines:**
- **Transfer of Clients:** According to the guidelines provided by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI), when a partner leaves a firm and starts a new practice, there are specific protocols for dealing with clients of the old firm.
- **Professional Conduct:** Even if Mr. A is the same individual and is now working under a new firm name, he must adhere to professional conduct rules regarding client transition and communication.
2. **Communication to the Old Firm:**
- **Notification Requirement:** It is generally expected that if a partner leaves a firm and takes clients with them, the new firm (in this case, Mr. A’s sole proprietorship) should inform the old firm (AB and Associates) about the transition.
- **Client Consent:** The new auditor should also ensure that there is proper consent from the client and that all ethical procedures are followed to avoid any conflict of interest.
3. **Professional Misconduct:**
- **Potential Misconduct:** If Mr. A does not inform the old firm and takes over the audit work for X Pvt. Ltd. without following the proper protocol, it could be considered professional misconduct. This is particularly true if the transition involves a conflict of interest or if the client has not provided proper consent for the transition.
### **ICAI Guidelines and Code of Ethics**
- **ICAI Code of Ethics:** The ICAI Code of Ethics mandates that a Chartered Accountant must maintain confidentiality, avoid conflicts of interest, and adhere to professional conduct standards. This includes the requirement to communicate with the previous firm when clients are transitioning between firms.
- **Regulation 190A of the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949:** This regulation addresses the procedure for the transfer of clients when a CA moves from one firm to another. It mandates that a CA must obtain client consent and communicate with the old firm.
### **Relevant Case Law**
While specific case law might not be directly applicable in this context, the principles of professional ethics and conduct outlined by the ICAI and the Chartered Accountants Act provide a framework. The ICAI’s disciplinary cases often cover issues related to professional conduct, but you would need to refer to specific disciplinary rulings or ethical guidance issued by the ICAI for detailed precedents.
### **Summary**
- **Communication is Crucial:** Mr. A should inform AB and Associates about the transition of the client to avoid any issues of professional misconduct.
- **Follow Ethical Guidelines:** The transition must be handled in accordance with the ICAI’s Code of Ethics and relevant regulations, including obtaining client consent and ensuring no conflict of interest.
### **Recommended Actions**
- **Consult ICAI Guidelines:** Refer to the ICAI’s Code of Ethics and other relevant professional guidelines for detailed procedures on client transitions.
- **Seek Professional Advice:** If there is any uncertainty, consulting with the ICAI or seeking legal advice from a professional specializing in ethics and compliance may provide further clarification.
Ensuring compliance with these guidelines helps maintain professional integrity and avoid any potential issues related to professional misconduct.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Treatment of Proceeds from sale of Jointly held Flat
- Refund of return filed for deceased
- TDS Under Section 194IA Where More than one Buyer and More than one Seller
- Want to zero reversal electronic credit reversal ledger
- ISSUANCE OF TAX INVOICE IF CAR/BIKE SOLD SHOWN IN FIXED ASSET
- GSTR 1 CAN NOT BE FILED AFTER 3 YEARS
- LTCG loss on delisted shares
- Share valuation MTHOD
- Investment in Two Residential Houses
- Regarding Itr Filing
- Interest on Capital-Partnership Firm
- 80G deduction eligibility
- Amount received in account which was given to sons as gift
- GST on Tobacco - as per new notification
- Cant amend a 26QB
- "Please ensure that the Total of the Deductions u/s 54F match the same in Table D in Sch CG"
- Composition Dealer GST Annual Return Filing process
- TDS under section 195.
- Filing GST Returns after death of proprietor
- Registered Required in GST Act
Trending Online Classes
-
Online GST Course - Master the Fundamentals of GST with Practical Insights
Ruhi Joshirao19 January 2026
CAclubindia
