Interesting case. need suggestion n case law.
This query is : Resolved
19 January 2012
Two Cases:-
1.) Y purchase goods(i.e gold) from Z on challan basis(not by invoice)due to non fixation of goods price on 29.12.2010 n 30.11.2011, and sold these goods on the same day. Later on 4.4.2011 invoice prepared by Z of the above goods.
Y claim the vat input given on purchase of goods in Quarter- IV of 2010-11 but department can't accept it n raised demand of vat output of goods sold without giving credit of vat input n said vat input should be claim in Ist Quarter of 2011-12.
Was Y claim acceptable? What should Y do? Is there any case law related to this situation?...
2.) P sold stolen goods to Q against vat invoice. Q purchased goods in good faith. So,
Is Q liable for confiscation of goods, for any penalty, for any legal proceedings ? Is there any Case Law related?
1.) Y purchase goods(i.e gold) from Z on challan basis(not by invoice)due to non fixation of goods price on 29.12.2010 n 30.11.2011, and sold these goods on the same day. Later on 4.4.2011 invoice prepared by Z of the above goods.
Y claim the vat input given on purchase of goods in Quarter- IV of 2010-11 but department can't accept it n raised demand of vat output of goods sold without giving credit of vat input n said vat input should be claim in Ist Quarter of 2011-12.
Was Y claim acceptable? What should Y do? Is there any case law related to this situation?...
2.) P sold stolen goods to Q against vat invoice. Q purchased goods in good faith. So,
Is Q liable for confiscation of goods, for any penalty, for any legal proceedings ? Is there any Case Law related?
21 January 2012
Input Credit is available on the basis of tax invoice which is dated 04-04-2011. Input credit can be allowed in Qrt I of 11-12.
Claim of Y is not acceptable.
2. Q is liable for confiscation at present by Police Department. Has to contest the case on bonafide to prove the genuineness of transaction. Depends on judgement of Criminal Court.
Claim of Y is not acceptable.
2. Q is liable for confiscation at present by Police Department. Has to contest the case on bonafide to prove the genuineness of transaction. Depends on judgement of Criminal Court.
Message likes :
1 times
21 January 2012
thanks Mr. Kochar 4 ur consideration.
In 1st case, can u give any reference to either any CASE decided or any PROVISION of Vat Act.
2nd case, is there any CASE similar to dis situation?
In 1st case, can u give any reference to either any CASE decided or any PROVISION of Vat Act.
2nd case, is there any CASE similar to dis situation?
27 January 2012
1. u/r. 51(1)(a) : Setoff is available of the sum collected seperately on purchases by the other Regd. dealer from whom the purchases are effected. Input credit is to be claimed only in the return as per periodicity in which dt. 04-04-11 is covered.
Message likes :
1 times
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Tax on Deemed Capital Gain
- Exiting partner in partnership firm in gst portal
- F & O PROFIT REPORTING FOR AY 2026-27
- Type of Capital Gain
- Banking Related Issue
- Traces submitting correction statement error
- Difff in ais receipts and gst turnover
- ASMT-10 received from A O
- IT returns for fresh job holders
- Consequences of Non-Deduction of TDS under Income Tax???????????????
- Gst on travel by air for business purposes
- Loss of interest in PF transfer from EPFO to Trust
- Seeking Advice: High Tax Shortfall on Job Switch + Let-Out House Property Loss in FY 2025-26
- TDS offline utility
- TDS on rent received on hardship compensation being rent on redevelopment of building
- Housing Society-ITR5
- TDS on Rent received on redevelopment of building
- Indian IT Portal issue in computing tax as per UK-India DTAA
- Capital Gains on sale of residential flat
- Upload Level ValidationITR3Category of Defect B/D
Trending Online Classes
-
DT & Audit (Exam Oriented Fastrack Batch) - For May 26 Exams and onwards Full English
CA Bhanwar Borana & CA Shubham Keswani
Subscribe to Pro
Join an elite circle of professionals
CAclubindia
