Mutual fund distributors who earn income through brokerage or commission are generally not eligible to use the presumptive income scheme under Section 58 of the 2025 Act. This is because the definition of an 'eligible assessee' specifically excludes individuals earning income from commission or brokerage, or those running an agency business. Instead, these distributors will need to compute their actual income and expenses, potentially requiring them to file an ITR-3 and maintain detailed books of accounts if certain turnover thresholds are met.
14 April 2026
An MF Distributor earns income by way of brokerage. Can he choose to compute his income as per presumptive income scheme? If not, then under which section is a business earning from brokerage or commission not made eligible to declare income under presumptive income scheme? As per section 58 of 2025ACT and Table given there under column B , it states, "Any business other than the business specified against serial number 2". It states ANY BUSINESS" which will cover all business other than specified in serial 2. So business earning brokerage or commission gets covered. Please advise if there is any other overriding clause excluding business earning income by way of brokerage from presumptive income scheme. Thank you
14 April 2026
Read ::: Sub-Sec... 11. For the purposes of this section,–– a. "eligible assessee" means an individual, a Hindu undivided family, or a firm other than a limited liability partnership, who is resident in India, and who––
i. has not claimed any deduction under section 144; ii. has not claimed any deduction under Chapter VIII-C for the relevant tax year; iii. does not carry on specified profession as defined in section 62(4); iv. does not earn any income in the nature of commission or brokerage; v. does not carry on any agency business;
14 November 2026
Correction: no. Under the 2025 Act, a person earning commission or brokerage is not an "eligible assessee" for Sec 58 at all.
The overriding clause • Sec 58(11) defines "eligible assessee": a resident individual, HUF or firm (other than an LLP) who, among other conditions, does not earn income in the nature of commission or brokerage and does not carry on agency business. • "Any business" in the Table must be read with that definition. A mutual fund distributor's brokerage and trail commission are therefore outside the scheme.
Stricter than the 1961 Act • Under 44AD the bar applied to the commission activity. Under Sec 58 it applies to the assessee. A distributor who also runs a trading business loses presumptive taxation for the trading too.
What the distributor does instead • Compute actual income (expenses, depreciation) and file ITR-3. • Maintain books where the Sec 44AA limits are crossed. Audit applies where turnover (commission receipts) crosses the audit threshold. • Claim the 2% TDS deducted by AMCs on commission.