appointment of auditor as director

This query is : Resolved

shruti (Querist)
Follow

02 June 2008 can any body guide me over this -

the query is regarding applicability of the Indian companies act and
other applicable legislation of a partner of the stautory auditors of a
listed company(abc ltd.) appointed as a director on the board of a 100%
subsidiary company registered and incorporated in a foreign country.

it is also pertinent to clarify that the aforesaid partner of the
auditors firms is not a signatory to the annual accounts and auditors
report of M/s abc tld..

Q. whether the partner of the statutory auditors firm can be appointed
by M/S ABC ltd. on the board of its 100% foreign subsidiary even if
such partner is not auditing / signing the annual reports and auditors
report?

Reagrds
Shruti

Shekar

Shekar (Expert)
Follow

02 June 2008 Hi Shruthi..

Am not aware of any provisions Relating to above issue...But going by prudence appointment of statutory auditors as director of susdiary co would not provide Auditor with one of basic aspects of Audit that is INDIPENDENCE...

I may be wrong also...please let me know if u find correct answer..

CA. Yayati Tyagi

CA. Yayati Tyagi (Expert)
Follow

02 June 2008 hi Shruti, pls have some patience, ans. is long:

226 (1): if all partners of a firm are elegible to be appointed as auditors of that company, the firm can be appointed as auditor of that co.

sec 226(3) : if a person is a officer or employee of a company, he can't be appointed as auditor of that co.

sec. 226(4): clearly says that a person can't be appointed as auditor of the company, if he is not eligible to be appointed as an auditor of that company's holding or subsdiary co.

226(5) : if auditor becomes disqualified for any reason after the appointment, he will be deemed to vacate his office (office of auditor).

now i summarise:

1) in ur case, a partner bacame director of subsidiary, means he is now disqualified to be appointed as auditor of that subsidiary by virtue of 226(3).

2)means, he can't be appointed as auditors of ur company (holding co.) also, by virtue of sec 226(4)

3)if he is disqualified, it means firm is also disqualified to be appointed as auditor, by virtue of sec. 226(1)

4)if firm become disqualified, it is deemed to have vacated its office (auditors' office), by virtue of sec. 226(5).

5)in nut shell, if a partner is appointed as director of a subsidiary, the firm can't act as auditor of that holding company.

shruti

shruti (Querist)
Follow

02 June 2008 thank you sir.. its was quite expressive and clear to clear all doubts

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now

Summarize this with AI

ChatGPT Perplexity Claude Google AI Grok