Very urgent pl help

This query is : Resolved

ramanathan (Querist)
Follow

04 July 2012 Is an appeal pending with CIT appeals a contingent asset if the amount has actually been transferred from advance tax paid to claims receivable due to recovery of penalty from refund due.

CA UMESHKUMAR R. ACHARYA

CA UMESHKUMAR R. ACHARYA (Expert)
Follow

18 July 2012
Will you please clarify your query in

details because matter cannot be understood

from information given by you.

Message likes : 1 times

Aashok Kumar Sharma

Aashok Kumar Sharma (Expert)
Follow

03 August 2025 Your question relates to whether an appeal pending before the CIT(A) creates a "contingent asset" in the books, especially where a penalty has been adjusted from a tax refund, and the amount has been transferred to “claims receivable.”
Let’s unpack this in technical accounting and tax terms.

✅ Summary of the Situation:
Penalty has been recovered by the department from a refund due.
You have filed an appeal before CIT(A) against the penalty.
You have recorded the amount as claims receivable.
You're asking: Is this receivable a contingent asset?
✅ What is a Contingent Asset? (Accounting Standards View)
As per AS-29 or Ind AS 37 (Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets):
Contingent Asset is a possible asset that arises from past events and whose existence will be confirmed only by the occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more uncertain future events not wholly within the control of the enterprise.
So, the amount receivable on success of appeal is:
Not a real asset as of now,
Depends on favorable outcome of appeal,
Therefore, qualifies as a contingent asset.
✅ Should You Recognize It in Books?
🔸 According to AS/Ind AS:
Contingent assets are not recognized in financial statements unless realization is virtually certain.
Only disclosed in notes if inflow is probable, but not certain.
🔸 However, in practice (especially in tax accounting):
Some companies do record it as "claims receivable", if they believe the refund is likely, especially if appeal has strong merit.
But this is a judgment call, and should be disclosed with proper notes about the nature of the claim and status of appeal.
✅ In Your Case:
Since the penalty amount has already been adjusted against a refund, it has resulted in an actual cash outflow.
You've filed an appeal to recover this amount = claim under dispute.
Therefore:
It is not yet an asset you can realize — so it's a contingent asset.
You may show it as "Claims Receivable – under dispute" in financials with clear disclosure.
Do not recognize it as income unless and until the CIT(A) decides in your favor.
✅ Recommended Accounting Treatment:
Scenario Treatment
Appeal pending, uncertain outcome Disclose as Contingent Asset in notes only
Strong case, refund likely Show under “Claims Receivable – disputed”, but do not treat as income
Appeal allowed by CIT(A) Recognize as asset and reverse earlier entry
📝 Suggested Note to Financial Statements:
"An amount of ₹[X] was adjusted by the department against refund due, being penalty under dispute. The Company has filed an appeal before CIT(A), and the matter is pending. The said amount has been shown as 'Claims Receivable – under dispute'. The ultimate outcome and impact will be recognized on final resolution of the matter."
✅ Final Answer:
Yes, the amount under appeal with CIT(A), though shown as “claims receivable,” is in substance a contingent asset, and should not be recognized as income unless the realization becomes virtually certain.

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now