Set off of losses in case of mat


This query is : Resolved 

(Querist)
24 August 2013 PVT LTD COMPANY HAVING OPENING BALACNE IN PROFIT & LOSS A/C ON 1.04.2011 1500000 IN CREDIT & DURING THE YEAR F.Y 11-12 COMPANY MADE LOSS OF RS.1800000 AFTER DEPRECTION OF RS.1400000 SO COMPANY PAID MADE MAT AS PER INCOME Tax & LOSS OF 1800000 WAS C/F IN RETURN,IN BOOKS COMPANY SHOWED PFOFIT & LOSS CLOSING BALACE ON 31.3.2012 300000 DEBIT BALANCE NOW IN F.Y YEAR 12-13 COMPANY MADE PROFIT OF 1000000 WHICH WAS SET OFF AGANIST LAST YEAR B/F LOSS BUT IN MAT CAN I SET OFF LOSS OF 400000
AS 400000 LOSS {1800000-1400000(DEPRECIATION OF LAST YEAR) IS LOWER AS COMPARED TO DEPRECTION 1400000.
OR COMPANY CAN NOT SET OFF FULL 400000 AS 300000 WAS SETOFF AGANIST OPENING BALANCE...

BALAJI N V (Expert)
25 August 2013 See the decision of AAR in the case of Rashtriya Ispat Nigham.

jeetu (Querist)
25 August 2013 thanx a ton i read that but i m stil confused, can u tell me wat sould i do???please???

jeetu (Querist)
25 August 2013 please just clearify sir soon

25 July 2025 Let's go step by step to clarify how **MAT (Minimum Alternate Tax)** and **carry-forward losses** interact in this case.

### Key Points from Your Question:

* **Company** had an opening balance in **Profit & Loss A/c** of ₹1,500,000 (credit balance) on **01.04.2011**.
* During **FY 2011-12**, the company made a **loss of ₹1,800,000**, after depreciation of ₹1,400,000.
* As per the provisions of **MAT (Section 115JB)**, MAT was paid, and the company carried forward a **loss of ₹1,800,000** in the return.
* At the end of **FY 2011-12**, the company showed a **closing balance of ₹300,000** in the **Profit & Loss A/c** (debit balance).
* In **FY 2012-13**, the company made a profit of **₹1,000,000**, which was set off against the **brought forward loss** of ₹1,800,000.
* The question is whether the company can set off a **MAT loss** of ₹400,000.

---

### **Key Concepts to Understand:**

1. **Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT)**:

* MAT is applicable to **companies** that pay tax based on the **book profits** (as per **Section 115JB**) instead of regular income tax.
* If the company’s **book profit** is higher than the regular income tax, it pays **MAT** on that higher profit.

2. **Carry-forward Losses Under MAT**:

* If a company **pays MAT**, the excess MAT paid can be carried forward as **MAT Credit** and **set off** against future regular tax liabilities.
* However, the **carry-forward losses** of regular business operations (as per normal accounting) are **not directly related to MAT**. MAT losses are calculated based on the **book profit**, and they can be **carried forward** only for setting off against future **book profits** under MAT, not against regular income.

3. **Depreciation Adjustment**:

* **Depreciation** affects both the **book profits** and the **regular income tax profits**.
* The **depreciation** is deducted from the **book profit** under **MAT**, but when computing regular income tax, depreciation under **Section 32** is deducted from the regular profits.

---

### **Step-by-Step Analysis:**

1. **Understanding the MAT Adjustment:**

* In **FY 2011-12**, the company had a loss of **₹1,800,000** (after deducting depreciation of ₹1,400,000).
* After the **depreciation of ₹1,400,000**, the **remaining loss of ₹400,000** is effectively a **loss under MAT**, which means the company has no book profit for **MAT purposes** in that year.

2. **MAT Credit in FY 2011-12:**

* The company pays MAT based on the **book profits**.
* Even though the company made a loss in the regular accounts, **MAT credit** would be available for the excess tax paid under **Section 115JB**.
* If there’s a **book loss of ₹1,800,000**, the **MAT credit** would be available for future set-off against **book profits** in subsequent years.

3. **MAT Loss Carry-Forward (FY 2012-13):**

* For **FY 2012-13**, the company made a profit of **₹1,000,000**.
* This profit was first **set off against the brought forward loss of ₹1,800,000** (which reduces the carried forward loss).
* After the set-off, the company’s **remaining brought forward loss** is ₹800,000.

Now, as for the **MAT loss**:

* The **MAT loss** arising due to the depreciation adjustment (₹1,400,000 depreciation) is calculated based on the **book profit**.
* The total **MAT credit** for **FY 2012-13** can be set off **against book profits** in subsequent years.
* In this case, **₹400,000** can be set off against any **future MAT payable**.

---

### **Answer to Your Query:**

* The **MAT loss** of **₹400,000** (which is the **depreciation effect** on book profits) can be carried forward and set off **against future MAT** liabilities.
* **Regular business losses** (i.e., losses in the profit and loss account after depreciation) can be set off against future **business income**, but **MAT loss** (the difference created by depreciation) is specifically for **MAT purposes**.

Thus, in **FY 2012-13**, the company can set off the **₹1,000,000 profit** against the **brought forward business loss** of **₹1,800,000** (leaving a balance of ₹800,000).

The **₹400,000 MAT loss** is a **separate MAT credit** that can be carried forward and set off **only against future MAT payable**, not regular tax profits.

---

### **Conclusion:**

* **The ₹400,000 loss (due to depreciation)** in **MAT calculations** cannot be set off against **regular business income**. It is treated as **MAT credit** that can be carried forward.
* **The ₹1,000,000 profit in FY 2012-13** can be set off against the **brought forward loss of ₹1,800,000** (leaving ₹800,000). The MAT credit of ₹400,000 is a separate matter and can be utilized against future MAT liabilities.

---

Let me know if this clarifies things further, or if you need additional examples!


You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now



Similar Resolved Queries


loading


Unanswered Queries



CCI Pro



Answer Query



Company
ARTICLESHIP 25 October 2026
Article Intern (CA Articleship)

Arpan Bohra & Co

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
12 November 2026
Tax Product Specialist

BharatX.ai

Gurgaon

B.Com

View Details
Company
Featured 07 November 2026
Paid Assisstant

DPV & Associates

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
10 November 2026
Direct Tax Manager

CAAQ CONSULTANCY PVT LTD

New Delhi

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured ARTICLESHIP 17 November 2026
Associate/ Article Trainee

M/s. A V C & Co.

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 27 October 2026
semi-qualified CA

Saini Pati Shah & Co LLP, Chartered Accountants

Mumbai

CA Final

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 14 November 2026
Articleship Assistant

B Thejas and Associates

Bengaluru

CA Foundation

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 22 October 2026
Articleship intern

Srinath Manikanta

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details