section 50 c
This query is : Resolved
13 December 2016
is the value of immovable property on registry always the circle rate? such that section 50 C is not evoked also, can registry get executed on less than circle rate?
13 December 2016
Question is not clear..
Which angle do you want the question to be answered??
I mean, from Local Tax complinace or Income Tax Compliance ?/
Which angle do you want the question to be answered??
I mean, from Local Tax complinace or Income Tax Compliance ?/
13 December 2016
I am asking from general paralance point of view (general commercial sense) Is registry of immovable property always executed on circle rate? is it mandatory or depends on party to the contract.
23 July 2025
Great question — let’s break this down from both general commercial practice and the income tax (Section 50C) and local stamp duty perspectives:
✅ 1. General Commercial Practice (Registry and Circle Rate)
Circle Rate (also called Guideline Value or Ready Reckoner Rate) is the minimum price set by the local government for valuation of property for stamp duty purposes.
In most states, registry cannot legally be executed for a value less than the circle rate. If parties mention a lower value, the stamp duty is still calculated on circle rate.
🔹 So, in general practice:
✅ Registry is usually done at or above the circle rate.
❌ Registry cannot be legally executed below circle rate, unless:
The circle rate has been wrongly assessed,
A valuation officer's report under special circumstances allows it,
The registering authority accepts a lower value after scrutiny (rare).
✅ 2. From Income Tax Angle – Section 50C
Section 50C applies to capital gains computation when a capital asset (land/building) is sold.
If sale consideration < circle rate, then circle rate is deemed as full value of consideration for capital gains purposes.
There is a 10% safe harbor:
If actual sale consideration is not less than 90% of the circle rate, then no adjustment under Section 50C is made.
🧾 Example:
Circle Rate: ₹1 CR
Sale Consideration: ₹91L
➡️ Since ₹91L ≥ ₹90L (i.e., 90% of ₹1 cr), Section 50C not invoked.
✅ Key Points Summary:
Aspect Can registry be below circle rate? Section 50C implications?
General registry law ❌ Generally no N/A
Income Tax (Sec 50C) Yes (in rare cases) If < 90% of circle rate, then 50C applies
Commercial practice Rarely done, usually avoided May trigger tax scrutiny
🔍 Final Take:
Registry is typically done at or above circle rate.
Section 50C will apply if property is sold for less than 90% of the circle rate without valid justification.
Parties may agree on a lower value, but it won’t avoid tax implications and may not be acceptable for registry.
✅ 1. General Commercial Practice (Registry and Circle Rate)
Circle Rate (also called Guideline Value or Ready Reckoner Rate) is the minimum price set by the local government for valuation of property for stamp duty purposes.
In most states, registry cannot legally be executed for a value less than the circle rate. If parties mention a lower value, the stamp duty is still calculated on circle rate.
🔹 So, in general practice:
✅ Registry is usually done at or above the circle rate.
❌ Registry cannot be legally executed below circle rate, unless:
The circle rate has been wrongly assessed,
A valuation officer's report under special circumstances allows it,
The registering authority accepts a lower value after scrutiny (rare).
✅ 2. From Income Tax Angle – Section 50C
Section 50C applies to capital gains computation when a capital asset (land/building) is sold.
If sale consideration < circle rate, then circle rate is deemed as full value of consideration for capital gains purposes.
There is a 10% safe harbor:
If actual sale consideration is not less than 90% of the circle rate, then no adjustment under Section 50C is made.
🧾 Example:
Circle Rate: ₹1 CR
Sale Consideration: ₹91L
➡️ Since ₹91L ≥ ₹90L (i.e., 90% of ₹1 cr), Section 50C not invoked.
✅ Key Points Summary:
Aspect Can registry be below circle rate? Section 50C implications?
General registry law ❌ Generally no N/A
Income Tax (Sec 50C) Yes (in rare cases) If < 90% of circle rate, then 50C applies
Commercial practice Rarely done, usually avoided May trigger tax scrutiny
🔍 Final Take:
Registry is typically done at or above circle rate.
Section 50C will apply if property is sold for less than 90% of the circle rate without valid justification.
Parties may agree on a lower value, but it won’t avoid tax implications and may not be acceptable for registry.
23 July 2025
Great question — let’s break this down from both general commercial practice and the income tax (Section 50C) and local stamp duty perspectives:
✅ 1. General Commercial Practice (Registry and Circle Rate)
Circle Rate (also called Guideline Value or Ready Reckoner Rate) is the minimum price set by the local government for valuation of property for stamp duty purposes.
In most states, registry cannot legally be executed for a value less than the circle rate. If parties mention a lower value, the stamp duty is still calculated on circle rate.
🔹 So, in general practice:
✅ Registry is usually done at or above the circle rate.
❌ Registry cannot be legally executed below circle rate, unless:
The circle rate has been wrongly assessed,
A valuation officer's report under special circumstances allows it,
The registering authority accepts a lower value after scrutiny (rare).
✅ 2. From Income Tax Angle – Section 50C
Section 50C applies to capital gains computation when a capital asset (land/building) is sold.
If sale consideration < circle rate, then circle rate is deemed as full value of consideration for capital gains purposes.
There is a 10% safe harbor:
If actual sale consideration is not less than 90% of the circle rate, then no adjustment under Section 50C is made.
🧾 Example:
Circle Rate: ₹1 CR
Sale Consideration: ₹91L
➡️ Since ₹91L ≥ ₹90L (i.e., 90% of ₹1 cr), Section 50C not invoked.
✅ Key Points Summary:
Aspect Can registry be below circle rate? Section 50C implications?
General registry law ❌ Generally no N/A
Income Tax (Sec 50C) Yes (in rare cases) If < 90% of circle rate, then 50C applies
Commercial practice Rarely done, usually avoided May trigger tax scrutiny
🔍 Final Take:
Registry is typically done at or above circle rate.
Section 50C will apply if property is sold for less than 90% of the circle rate without valid justification.
Parties may agree on a lower value, but it won’t avoid tax implications and may not be acceptable for registry.
✅ 1. General Commercial Practice (Registry and Circle Rate)
Circle Rate (also called Guideline Value or Ready Reckoner Rate) is the minimum price set by the local government for valuation of property for stamp duty purposes.
In most states, registry cannot legally be executed for a value less than the circle rate. If parties mention a lower value, the stamp duty is still calculated on circle rate.
🔹 So, in general practice:
✅ Registry is usually done at or above the circle rate.
❌ Registry cannot be legally executed below circle rate, unless:
The circle rate has been wrongly assessed,
A valuation officer's report under special circumstances allows it,
The registering authority accepts a lower value after scrutiny (rare).
✅ 2. From Income Tax Angle – Section 50C
Section 50C applies to capital gains computation when a capital asset (land/building) is sold.
If sale consideration < circle rate, then circle rate is deemed as full value of consideration for capital gains purposes.
There is a 10% safe harbor:
If actual sale consideration is not less than 90% of the circle rate, then no adjustment under Section 50C is made.
🧾 Example:
Circle Rate: ₹1 CR
Sale Consideration: ₹91L
➡️ Since ₹91L ≥ ₹90L (i.e., 90% of ₹1 cr), Section 50C not invoked.
✅ Key Points Summary:
Aspect Can registry be below circle rate? Section 50C implications?
General registry law ❌ Generally no N/A
Income Tax (Sec 50C) Yes (in rare cases) If < 90% of circle rate, then 50C applies
Commercial practice Rarely done, usually avoided May trigger tax scrutiny
🔍 Final Take:
Registry is typically done at or above circle rate.
Section 50C will apply if property is sold for less than 90% of the circle rate without valid justification.
Parties may agree on a lower value, but it won’t avoid tax implications and may not be acceptable for registry.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- How to add NRE account to income tax profile?
- Salary u/s 194C
- Upload Level Validation Error
- Nill TDS Return FY 2025-26
- Merger issue
- Deduction for HUF
- EXEMPTION UNDER SECTION 54 FOR UNDER CONSTRUCTION FLAT
- Form 10E requirement for Leave encashment and Gratuity received at retirement
- AY2025-26- Bug in ITR2 Online Filing - TDS Section related to Property Sale
- Sale of foreign shares by Indian resident
- TAXABILITY OF STATE INSURANCE MATURITY RECEIPTS BY RAJASTHAN GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEE ON RETIREMENT ?
- Document to add trade name
- GST Partners addition
- Non-disclosure of Foreign Shares & Dividend in Past ITRs – How to Rectify & Report Now?
- ICWAI-Final best coaching center for online by English
- "Please ensure that the Total of the Deductions u/s 54F match the same in Table D in Sch CG"
- Refund_ Insufficient in credit ledger
- EPF Withdrawal Where to show in ITR2
- 54 F disallowance presentation in ITR 2
- TDS on disallowance and reporting
Trending Online Classes
-
Input Tax Credit, GST refunds and Recovery of refunds- Roadblocks and way outs
CA Nipun Arora03 September 2025 -
GST LIVE Certification Course - 43rd Weekdays Batch(With Govt Certificate)
Industry Expert15 September 2025
CAclubindia
