Revenue expenditure or capital expenditure

This query is : Resolved

Querist : Anonymous

Querist : Anonymous (Querist)

26 April 2013 purchase of plastic crates(used to trade fruits)is a revenue expenditure or capital expenditure?....pls i need an urgent rply....

CA.Sourabh Sethia

CA.Sourabh Sethia (Expert)
Follow

26 April 2013 pls clarify - what is the life span of these crates & how significant the amount of purchase is ??

Querist : Anonymous

Querist : Anonymous (Querist)

26 April 2013 well the life span is abt max. 8 months to 1year and the expnditure is in the range of 20lacs per annum

CA.Sourabh Sethia

CA.Sourabh Sethia (Expert)
Follow

26 April 2013 since the lifespan is very low it can be considered as Revenue Expenditure

its a Revenue Expenditure

Querist : Anonymous

Querist : Anonymous (Querist)

26 April 2013 thanks for your valuable feed back but is this explanation is sufficient to convince the IT deptt?

CA.Sourabh Sethia

CA.Sourabh Sethia (Expert)
Follow

26 April 2013 All the expenditures which are incurred in the day to day conduct and administration of a business and the effect-of which is completely exhausted within the current accounting year are known as "revenue expenditures". These expenditures are recurring by nature i.e. which are incurred for meeting day today requirements of a business and the effect of these expenditures is always short-lived i.e. the benefit thereof is enjoyed by the business within the current accounting year. These expenditures are also known as "expenses or expired costs."

Message likes : 1 times

Querist : Anonymous

Querist : Anonymous (Querist)

26 April 2013 bt there is some judgements agains it

Aashok Kumar Sharma

Aashok Kumar Sharma

(Expert)
Follow

22 July 2025 You're right to dig deeper — especially since the Income Tax Department may challenge the treatment of such expenditure if the amount is significant, even if the lifespan of the asset is short.

🔍 Case in Question:
Purchase of plastic crates (used in trading fruits)

Lifespan: ~8 months to 1 year

Cost: ₹20 lakhs per annum

Used in regular operations (transporting fruits)

✅ Argument for Revenue Expenditure
Based on standard accounting and tax principles:

Short Useful Life
Assets with a short useful life (under 1 year) are generally not capitalized, especially if they are not intended for long-term use.

Routine & Recurring Nature
If the crates are purchased every year and are consumed or rendered unusable in a short period, the expense is recurring and operational in nature.

Used in the Course of Business
The crates are used directly in the trading process—they are more like packing materials or tools than fixed assets.

Judicial Support – Revenue Treatment Allowed

In CIT v. Saravana Spinning Mills Ltd. [2007] 293 ITR 201 (SC), the Supreme Court held that parts with short lifespan used in day-to-day business operations can be treated as revenue expenditure.

In CIT v. Empire Jute Co. Ltd. [1980] 124 ITR 1 (SC), the Court held that even if the advantage lasts beyond the year, it may still be revenue if it facilitates trading operations without creating a new asset.

❌ Argument for Capital Expenditure (Possible IT Dept View)
Substantial Outlay (₹20 lakhs/year): Even if crates last under a year, the tax department may argue that the amount is large enough to warrant capital treatment.

Reusable for Several Cycles: If crates are used over multiple fruit seasons or reused across shipments, they may be considered as having enduring benefit.

Tangible, Identifiable Assets: Crates are physical goods used in business—this may make them fall under the scope of depreciable assets.

📌 Practical View & Suggestion
If crates are fully used up (damaged/lost) within the year, and new ones are bought every year → Revenue Expenditure is justified.

Maintain evidence/documentation showing:

Crates are broken/damaged/lost within a year.

They are expensed routinely.

Not reused or capitalized in previous years.

Mention treatment consistently in audited accounts and tax audit report under Form 3CD.

🧾 Suggested Disclosure (for IT Dept)
“Plastic crates are consumable tools used in the routine trading of perishable goods (fruits). The average life of a crate is less than 12 months due to rough handling and perishables’ nature. These crates are replaced annually, and hence, the expenditure is treated as revenue in nature and allowable under section 37(1) of the Income Tax Act.”

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now