Negotiable instrument act,1881
This query is : Resolved
01 November 2011
can a bill of exchange be endorsed without acceptor being accepting it ?
01 November 2011
No without acceptance it does not come into effect and therefore can not be endorsed.
Also see below link for more details---
https://www.caclubindia.com/forum/knowledge-bank-negotiable-instruments-act--108880.asp
Also see below link for more details---
https://www.caclubindia.com/forum/knowledge-bank-negotiable-instruments-act--108880.asp
Message likes :
1 times
04 November 2011
but its given that all bills need not be accepted, only bills payable after sight or if it is specifically mentioned that bills need to be accepted , in these 2 cases only it should be accepted.....
03 August 2024
Yes, a bill of exchange can be endorsed without the drawee (acceptor) having accepted it, but the implications of this endorsement depend on the nature of the bill and the role of the acceptor. Let's break this down:
### **1. Acceptance of a Bill of Exchange**
**Definition and Types of Bills**:
- **Bill of Exchange**: A written order by the drawer to the drawee to pay a certain sum to the payee or bearer on a specific date or upon demand.
- **Acceptance**: The drawee's agreement to pay the bill when it is due. Acceptance is typically done by signing the bill.
**Types of Bills**:
- **Bill Payable on Demand**: No acceptance is necessary. The drawee is not required to accept it for the bill to be negotiable.
- **Bill Payable at a Future Date**: Acceptance is not mandatory unless the bill is specifically marked as payable after sight or is explicitly required to be accepted.
### **2. Endorsement of a Bill of Exchange**
**Endorsement Without Acceptance**:
- **Endorsement**: The act of transferring the ownership of a bill to another person by signing on the back or assigning it.
- **Possibility**: A bill of exchange can be endorsed before acceptance, especially if it is a bill payable on demand or a bill payable at a future date without a specified acceptance requirement.
**Implications**:
- **Endorsement Before Acceptance**: Endorsing a bill before acceptance does not invalidate the bill. However, the endorsee (the person to whom the bill is transferred) will only have recourse to the drawer if the drawee does not accept or pay the bill.
- **Recourse**: If the bill is not accepted and remains unpaid, the endorser (the person who endorsed it) may have liability under the bill, depending on the circumstances. However, if the bill is accepted, the holder of the bill can claim payment from the acceptor.
### **3. Legal Provisions Under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881**
- **Section 45**: Provides for the endorsement of a bill of exchange. It allows for a bill to be endorsed without acceptance, and the endorser will be liable if the bill is dishonored.
- **Section 42**: Specifies that a bill of exchange must be accepted if it is payable after sight or if it is explicitly mentioned that acceptance is required. For other bills, acceptance is not a prerequisite for validity.
### **Practical Implications**
- **For Demand Bills**: No acceptance is required, and they can be endorsed and transferred directly. Payment can be demanded immediately.
- **For Time Bills**: If not explicitly required, acceptance is not needed, but it is generally preferred to ensure the drawee's commitment to pay at maturity.
- **Endorsement Risks**: Endorsing a bill before acceptance poses a risk. If the bill is dishonored, the endorser is liable to the endorsee.
### **Summary**
- **Yes, a bill of exchange can be endorsed before acceptance.** This is particularly common for demand bills or those payable at a future date without explicit acceptance requirements.
- **Acceptance is essential** for bills that are specifically payable after sight or where acceptance is explicitly mentioned.
- **Endorsees** may rely on the drawer or other endorsers if the drawee fails to accept or pay the bill.
This flexibility allows the negotiable instruments to be used effectively in various financial transactions, while ensuring that holders have a clear legal path to recourse if the bill is dishonored.
### **1. Acceptance of a Bill of Exchange**
**Definition and Types of Bills**:
- **Bill of Exchange**: A written order by the drawer to the drawee to pay a certain sum to the payee or bearer on a specific date or upon demand.
- **Acceptance**: The drawee's agreement to pay the bill when it is due. Acceptance is typically done by signing the bill.
**Types of Bills**:
- **Bill Payable on Demand**: No acceptance is necessary. The drawee is not required to accept it for the bill to be negotiable.
- **Bill Payable at a Future Date**: Acceptance is not mandatory unless the bill is specifically marked as payable after sight or is explicitly required to be accepted.
### **2. Endorsement of a Bill of Exchange**
**Endorsement Without Acceptance**:
- **Endorsement**: The act of transferring the ownership of a bill to another person by signing on the back or assigning it.
- **Possibility**: A bill of exchange can be endorsed before acceptance, especially if it is a bill payable on demand or a bill payable at a future date without a specified acceptance requirement.
**Implications**:
- **Endorsement Before Acceptance**: Endorsing a bill before acceptance does not invalidate the bill. However, the endorsee (the person to whom the bill is transferred) will only have recourse to the drawer if the drawee does not accept or pay the bill.
- **Recourse**: If the bill is not accepted and remains unpaid, the endorser (the person who endorsed it) may have liability under the bill, depending on the circumstances. However, if the bill is accepted, the holder of the bill can claim payment from the acceptor.
### **3. Legal Provisions Under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881**
- **Section 45**: Provides for the endorsement of a bill of exchange. It allows for a bill to be endorsed without acceptance, and the endorser will be liable if the bill is dishonored.
- **Section 42**: Specifies that a bill of exchange must be accepted if it is payable after sight or if it is explicitly mentioned that acceptance is required. For other bills, acceptance is not a prerequisite for validity.
### **Practical Implications**
- **For Demand Bills**: No acceptance is required, and they can be endorsed and transferred directly. Payment can be demanded immediately.
- **For Time Bills**: If not explicitly required, acceptance is not needed, but it is generally preferred to ensure the drawee's commitment to pay at maturity.
- **Endorsement Risks**: Endorsing a bill before acceptance poses a risk. If the bill is dishonored, the endorser is liable to the endorsee.
### **Summary**
- **Yes, a bill of exchange can be endorsed before acceptance.** This is particularly common for demand bills or those payable at a future date without explicit acceptance requirements.
- **Acceptance is essential** for bills that are specifically payable after sight or where acceptance is explicitly mentioned.
- **Endorsees** may rely on the drawer or other endorsers if the drawee fails to accept or pay the bill.
This flexibility allows the negotiable instruments to be used effectively in various financial transactions, while ensuring that holders have a clear legal path to recourse if the bill is dishonored.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- ADT-3 AND ADT-1
- FOREIGN GAIN AND LOSS
- Itr .….......
- TDS on rent paid to NRI rate
- TDS Under Section 194IA Where More than one Buyer and More than one Seller
- E-way bill issue with two invoice
- Interest on Capital-Partnership Firm
- Inheritances Share Tax Implications
- OLD MACHINERY SALE
- LABOUR SUPPLY BILL - RCM APPLICABLITY
- IRN was not generated for October-2025 Invoice but generated e waybill, now it is self identified,
- 80G deduction eligibility
- GST on Tobacco - as per new notification
- Cant amend a 26QB
- "Please ensure that the Total of the Deductions u/s 54F match the same in Table D in Sch CG"
- Composition Dealer GST Annual Return Filing process
- TDS under section 195.
- Filing GST Returns after death of proprietor
- Registered Required in GST Act
- Switch over to Composition Scheme
Trending Online Classes
-
Online GST Course - Master the Fundamentals of GST with Practical Insights
Ruhi Joshirao19 January 2026
CAclubindia
