Inter compane expenses reimbursement

This query is : Resolved 

Avatar

Querist : Anonymous

Profile Image
Querist : Anonymous (Querist)
11 April 2014 There is a demarger in Public Ltd Company A and it became Public Ltd company A & B .

In the demarketed area of the new company B the original company A runs a factory. All the Salary, Wages, and other expenses of A's factory are initially paid by B and then reimbursed by A against a Debit note.

Does the above reimbursement attract Service Tax liability ??

11 April 2014 on reimbursement there is no service tax liability.

Avatar

Querist : Anonymous

Profile Image
Querist : Anonymous (Querist)
11 April 2014 Thanks Tushar,
Just to add that the employees and infrastructure used by Company A belongs to Company B and A reimburses the expenses.

Regards

11 April 2014 on reimbursement of exp still there is no service tax is applicable...

Avatar

Querist : Anonymous

Profile Image
Querist : Anonymous (Querist)
11 April 2014 Thanks a lot for clearing my doubts

11 April 2014 please note that you need to satisfy Rule 5(2) of valuation rules. otherwise service tax shall be chargeable.

Avatar

Querist : Anonymous

Profile Image
Querist : Anonymous (Querist)
11 April 2014 Kindly let me know contents of the Rule 5(2) of Valuation rules.

Avatar

Querist : Anonymous

Profile Image
Querist : Anonymous (Querist)
12 April 2014 After studying the Rule 5 of Service Tax I could understand that Service Tax is not payable on reimbursement of Inter Company expenses provided the expenses are contingent in nature.Planned / budgeted expenses paid by a sister company is included for Service Tax valuation.

In the instant case, since the company B deploys its employees and infrastructure for manufacturing the products of company A, I feel the expenses are to be added during valuation of Service Tax.
Please provide your comments and suggestions.

Avatar

Querist : Anonymous

Profile Image
Querist : Anonymous (Querist)
14 April 2014 Further, Reimbursement of expenses do not attract service Tax Liability only if the payments are made to a third party. In the aforesaid case Salary & Wages are paid to B's own employees. Expenses like electricity bill, fuel etc paid by B are also not contingent in nature and may be taxed.
Advise required if the understanding is okay or not.

01 August 2024 In the scenario you described, where Company B initially pays salaries, wages, and other expenses for the operations of Company A and then seeks reimbursement from Company A, there are specific considerations under service tax regulations. Here's a detailed analysis:

### **Service Tax on Reimbursement of Inter-Company Expenses**

1. **Rule 5 of the Service Tax Valuation Rules:**
- **Rule 5(2)** of the Service Tax (Determination of Value) Rules, 2006 (as amended) specifies that:
- **Expenses paid by the service provider to a third party** for providing a taxable service, if reimbursed by the recipient, are not to be included in the value of taxable service.
- **Contingent expenses**, such as expenses incurred by the service provider for which reimbursement is sought from the recipient, are not included in the service value.

2. **Application to Inter-Company Transactions:**
- **Expenses Paid to Third Parties:**
- If Company B pays expenses to third parties (like utilities, fuel, etc.), and these expenses are reimbursed by Company A, these reimbursements would typically not attract service tax, provided they are reimbursed as per actuals and are not marked-up.
- **Expenses Paid to Own Employees:**
- **Salaries and wages** paid to employees of Company B, where Company A only reimburses the actual amount, are generally considered as part of internal management and should not attract service tax.
- **Planned/Budgeted Expenses:**
- If the expenses are planned and budgeted, and then Company B charges these to Company A, this is considered part of the service cost and should be included in the service tax valuation if it is a taxable service.

3. **Practical Application:**
- **Salary and Wages:**
- Salaries and wages paid to Company B’s employees for the benefit of Company A’s factory would typically not be subject to service tax as they are internal expenses of Company B. The reimbursement should reflect actual costs without additional service tax implications.
- **Utilities and Other Costs:**
- If Company B incurs costs such as electricity or fuel which are directly linked to the operation of Company A’s factory, and these costs are reimbursed, such reimbursements might not attract service tax provided they are passed on at actuals.
- **Service Tax Liability:**
- If the expenses are contingent and not planned or budgeted, and are reimbursed as-is, service tax is generally not applicable. However, if there is any markup or if the reimbursement involves charges beyond actuals, that portion may be subject to service tax.

### **Summary:**
- **Reimbursement of actual, contingent expenses** paid to third parties does not generally attract service tax if they are passed on at actuals without mark-up.
- **Salaries and wages** paid to own employees of Company B do not attract service tax.
- **Planned or budgeted expenses**, if charged to Company A and not passed on as-is, may include service tax in their valuation.

### **Recommendation:**
- **Documentation and Compliance:**
- Maintain clear documentation of all reimbursed expenses, including details on how they were calculated and whether they are third-party expenses or internal.
- Ensure that all inter-company transactions are well-documented and align with service tax regulations.

- **Consultation with a Tax Professional:**
- Given the complexity of service tax regulations and inter-company transactions, consult with a tax professional or advisor to ensure compliance and proper treatment of such transactions.

By following these guidelines, you can better manage service tax implications on inter-company reimbursements and ensure accurate reporting and compliance.


You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now


CCI Pro
CAclubindia's WhatsApp Groups Link


Similar Resolved Queries


loading


Unanswered Queries


CCI Pro

Follow us
OR add as source on Google news


Answer Query