Query on error while filing Updated Return u/s 139(8A) under old tax regime. It was clarified that if the original return was not filed under old regime within due date (along with Form 10-IE), updated return cannot be filed in old regime. The taxpayer must proceed under the default new tax regime.
02 January 2026
I HAVE FILED LAST YEAR (AY 2024-25) RETURN UNDER OLD TAX REGIME , FOR THIS YEAR I AM FILING UPDATED RETURN UNDER OLD TAX REGIME BUT THE ERROR IS SHOWING BY SOFTWARE THAT " DEAR USER, ORGINAL RETURN WAS NOT FILED FOR THIS AY , SO YOU WILL NOT BE ABLE TO PROCEED TO FILE UPDATED RETURN U/S 139(8A) WITH OLD TAX REGIME" SO IN THIS REGARDS PLEASE PROVIDE ME GUIDANCE HOW TO PROCEED....
03 January 2026
Correct. If you have not filed original return(in old regime), you have to file the updated return in default tax regime, which is new regime.
14 November 2026
The software is right. Here is why, and what you can still do.
1. Law. From AY 2024-25 the new regime is the default under Sec 115BAC(1A). Opting out of it: • Without business income: only in the return filed by the Sec 139(1) due date. • With business income: Form 10-IEA by the Sec 139(1) due date. Last year's old-regime choice does not carry over to the next year without business income.
2. Your case. No original return was filed for AY 2025-26 by the due date (31 July 2025, extended to 15 September 2025), so the old regime cannot be chosen now. The updated return under Sec 139(8A) must be in the new regime. Form 10-IEA can no longer be filed.
3. What to do. File ITR-U under the new regime. Pay the tax, interest and the additional tax: 25% of tax plus interest within 12 months, 50% within 24 months, 60% within 36 months and 70% within 48 months, as extended by Finance Act 2025. Remember that ITR-U cannot create or increase a refund.
4. For future years: if the old regime is better (large 80C, 80D or home loan claims), file by the 139(1) due date, and for business income, file Form 10-IEA by that date.
Overall Summary: Without an original return filed by the due date, the old regime is not available, so the AY 2025-26 updated return must be filed under the new regime. Pay the additional tax under Sec 139(8A), and file on time in future years if the old regime suits you.