Construction cost
This query is : Resolved
19 December 2009
In the fy 1993-94,
15 August 2010
In the fy 1993-94, my client's father had constructed one property. After construction of ground floor, my client's father gave this property to his son (my client) on lease to continue further construction of property. The son constructed 2 floors in fy 1994-95 and 1995-96 and let out 1st and 2nd floor on rent. He duly recorded the cost of construction of 1st and 2nd floor in his balance sheet. In f.y. 2006-2007 my client constructed 3rd floor and duly recorded the cost of construction in the balance sheet. The case was selected for scrutiny and was referred to the valuation department. The valuation department made the valuation of the entire building including ground floor not constructed by my client. My client's mother (father not being alive now) gave an affidavit that her husband has made the ground floor. But the AO is saying that cost incurred in construction of ground floor is a concealed investment of my client and want to add the same in the income of Assessment year 2007-2008 !!!! Is he correct ? Please advice keeping in view that father of client in his Will bequeathed the land and ground floor in favor of his wife who shows the rent received from ground floor and lease rent from his son in her return of income.
20 July 2024
The situation you've described involves a complex issue related to the construction and ownership of a property, and how it is treated for taxation purposes. Here’s a breakdown and advice on the matter:
### Key Points to Consider:
1. **Initial Construction by Father:**
- The father of your client constructed the ground floor of the property in FY 1993-94.
- He then leased the property to your client to continue construction of additional floors.
2. **Subsequent Construction by Client:**
- Your client constructed the 1st and 2nd floors in FY 1994-95 and 1995-96 respectively. These floors were then let out on rent.
- In FY 2006-2007, your client constructed the 3rd floor and recorded the cost in their balance sheet.
3. **Valuation Department’s Assessment:**
- The valuation department valued the entire building, including the ground floor not constructed by your client.
- This valuation likely triggered scrutiny from the Assessing Officer (AO).
4. **Legal and Ownership Aspects:**
- The property originally belonged to the father, who in his Will bequeathed the land and ground floor to his wife (your client's mother).
- The mother receives rent from the ground floor and lease rent from her son (your client) for further construction.
### Assessment by the Assessing Officer (AO):
- The AO is asserting that the cost incurred in constructing the ground floor by the father should be considered as a concealed investment of your client, and wants to add this amount to your client's income for Assessment Year 2007-2008.
### Analysis and Advice:
- **Legal Documentation (Will and Affidavit):**
- The Will of your client's father and the affidavit from the mother are crucial documents. They establish legal ownership and the intention behind the construction and ownership of the property.
- The affidavit from the mother stating that her husband (the father) constructed the ground floor and her subsequent management of the property (rent receipts) provide supporting evidence.
- **Taxation Perspective:**
- From a taxation perspective, if your client did not incur the cost of constructing the ground floor and it was clearly documented as owned by the father and then passed to the mother, it should not be treated as your client's concealed income.
- The AO's assertion appears to be based on a misunderstanding or misinterpretation of the legal ownership and the construction activities.
- **Legal Assistance:**
- Given the complexity and potential tax implications, it would be advisable to seek assistance from a tax lawyer or a chartered accountant specializing in tax matters.
- They can review the legal documents (Will, affidavit) and provide detailed advice on how to present the case effectively to the AO during the scrutiny proceedings.
- **Submission of Evidence:**
- Ensure all relevant documents, including the Will, affidavit, lease agreements, and any correspondence with the valuation department, are submitted as part of your client's defense.
- Clearly articulate the sequence of events, legal ownership, and the lack of financial investment by your client in the construction of the ground floor.
### Conclusion:
Based on the information provided, the AO's assertion that the cost of constructing the ground floor should be added to your client's income seems incorrect. Your client appears to have legal documentation (Will, affidavit) supporting the ownership structure and the origin of the property. It’s crucial to present these documents effectively and seek professional assistance to navigate through the scrutiny process.
### Key Points to Consider:
1. **Initial Construction by Father:**
- The father of your client constructed the ground floor of the property in FY 1993-94.
- He then leased the property to your client to continue construction of additional floors.
2. **Subsequent Construction by Client:**
- Your client constructed the 1st and 2nd floors in FY 1994-95 and 1995-96 respectively. These floors were then let out on rent.
- In FY 2006-2007, your client constructed the 3rd floor and recorded the cost in their balance sheet.
3. **Valuation Department’s Assessment:**
- The valuation department valued the entire building, including the ground floor not constructed by your client.
- This valuation likely triggered scrutiny from the Assessing Officer (AO).
4. **Legal and Ownership Aspects:**
- The property originally belonged to the father, who in his Will bequeathed the land and ground floor to his wife (your client's mother).
- The mother receives rent from the ground floor and lease rent from her son (your client) for further construction.
### Assessment by the Assessing Officer (AO):
- The AO is asserting that the cost incurred in constructing the ground floor by the father should be considered as a concealed investment of your client, and wants to add this amount to your client's income for Assessment Year 2007-2008.
### Analysis and Advice:
- **Legal Documentation (Will and Affidavit):**
- The Will of your client's father and the affidavit from the mother are crucial documents. They establish legal ownership and the intention behind the construction and ownership of the property.
- The affidavit from the mother stating that her husband (the father) constructed the ground floor and her subsequent management of the property (rent receipts) provide supporting evidence.
- **Taxation Perspective:**
- From a taxation perspective, if your client did not incur the cost of constructing the ground floor and it was clearly documented as owned by the father and then passed to the mother, it should not be treated as your client's concealed income.
- The AO's assertion appears to be based on a misunderstanding or misinterpretation of the legal ownership and the construction activities.
- **Legal Assistance:**
- Given the complexity and potential tax implications, it would be advisable to seek assistance from a tax lawyer or a chartered accountant specializing in tax matters.
- They can review the legal documents (Will, affidavit) and provide detailed advice on how to present the case effectively to the AO during the scrutiny proceedings.
- **Submission of Evidence:**
- Ensure all relevant documents, including the Will, affidavit, lease agreements, and any correspondence with the valuation department, are submitted as part of your client's defense.
- Clearly articulate the sequence of events, legal ownership, and the lack of financial investment by your client in the construction of the ground floor.
### Conclusion:
Based on the information provided, the AO's assertion that the cost of constructing the ground floor should be added to your client's income seems incorrect. Your client appears to have legal documentation (Will, affidavit) supporting the ownership structure and the origin of the property. It’s crucial to present these documents effectively and seek professional assistance to navigate through the scrutiny process.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Payment for sale in March and Sale deed registration to be done in April
- Two pancard
- Transfer of MF
- Lifting and cross charges
- REGARDING ITR OF TRUST
- SSY for 2 daughters
- Eligibility for filling NEW Form 121 from April 2026
- E bike purchase can get input in GST
- How to correct Form 26QB
- PTRC PAYMENT & RETURN FILING (Annually)
- Treatment of TDS under Section 194-IA in case of cancelled property transaction
- Tax amount diff in Gstr1 and 3B in tax compare reports
- Spice form, ? mark comes in address
- Tds on GST in connection with sale to public company
- B2B Amendment
- Restoration of certificate of practice
- Regarding change in correspondence address in SSP portal
- Regarding Advance Tax not claimed in the Return of Income for A.Y. 2025-26
- No Compliences after incorporation
- USEFUL LIFE OF USED/SECOND HAND COMMERCIAL VEHICLES
Trending Online Classes
-
DT & Audit (Exam Oriented Fastrack Batch) - For May 26 Exams and onwards Full English
CA Bhanwar Borana & CA Shubham Keswani
CAclubindia
