Clarification over Exemption.
This query is : Resolved
19 August 2009
Hi....
Just want to clarify regarding exemption criteria, suppose a student appeared in May 2009 exam and he cleared 1st grp and failed 2nd grp but got exemtion in one of subjects in 2nd grp.
Now Q??
1) For how many attempts can expemtion b carried frwd (the 1 subjt in whc he scrd 60+ 2nd grp)
2) For hw many attempts can GRP-1 Pass be carried frwd or its for indefnte period...
Just want to clarify regarding exemption criteria, suppose a student appeared in May 2009 exam and he cleared 1st grp and failed 2nd grp but got exemtion in one of subjects in 2nd grp.
Now Q??
1) For how many attempts can expemtion b carried frwd (the 1 subjt in whc he scrd 60+ 2nd grp)
2) For hw many attempts can GRP-1 Pass be carried frwd or its for indefnte period...
19 July 2024
Certainly! Here are the clarifications regarding exemption criteria for CA exams:
### 1. Exemption for Subjects in Second Group:
When a student appears in an examination and obtains a minimum of 60 marks in a subject but fails to clear the entire group, they are eligible for exemption in that subject for subsequent attempts.
- **Validity of Exemption:** The exemption in a subject is typically valid for the next three following attempts of that group. For example, if a student appeared for May 2009 exams:
- The exemption obtained in a subject of Group 2 (where they scored 60 or more) can be carried forward and used for the subsequent three attempts of the same group.
- If the student does not clear the remaining subjects of Group 2 within these three attempts, they would need to reappear for all subjects of Group 2 again.
### 2. Passing Group 1:
- **Validity of Group 1 Pass:** Once a student clears Group 1 of the CA exams, there is no time limit or attempt limit for carrying forward this pass result. It remains valid indefinitely.
- **Implication:** If a student passes Group 1 in May 2009, for instance, this pass result remains valid for as long as the student continues their attempts to clear the remaining groups (including Group 2).
### Summary:
- Exemption in a subject of Group 2 is valid for three subsequent attempts of that group.
- Passing Group 1 is valid indefinitely, allowing the student to focus on clearing other groups without time constraints.
These rules are generally applicable, but it's advisable to refer to the latest guidelines from the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) or consult with an authorized representative for any recent changes or specific circumstances.
### 1. Exemption for Subjects in Second Group:
When a student appears in an examination and obtains a minimum of 60 marks in a subject but fails to clear the entire group, they are eligible for exemption in that subject for subsequent attempts.
- **Validity of Exemption:** The exemption in a subject is typically valid for the next three following attempts of that group. For example, if a student appeared for May 2009 exams:
- The exemption obtained in a subject of Group 2 (where they scored 60 or more) can be carried forward and used for the subsequent three attempts of the same group.
- If the student does not clear the remaining subjects of Group 2 within these three attempts, they would need to reappear for all subjects of Group 2 again.
### 2. Passing Group 1:
- **Validity of Group 1 Pass:** Once a student clears Group 1 of the CA exams, there is no time limit or attempt limit for carrying forward this pass result. It remains valid indefinitely.
- **Implication:** If a student passes Group 1 in May 2009, for instance, this pass result remains valid for as long as the student continues their attempts to clear the remaining groups (including Group 2).
### Summary:
- Exemption in a subject of Group 2 is valid for three subsequent attempts of that group.
- Passing Group 1 is valid indefinitely, allowing the student to focus on clearing other groups without time constraints.
These rules are generally applicable, but it's advisable to refer to the latest guidelines from the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) or consult with an authorized representative for any recent changes or specific circumstances.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Leave encashment and gratuity on death of employee
- GST ON FREE SAMPLE
- Regarding selling goods
- Exemption u/s 10(23C)(iiiad) by ITAT
- Applicability of E Invoicing if turnover exceeds rs 5 cr
- Advocate is authorised for formation of company as per section 7 of the company act 2013
- Immovable gift deed
- STCG on International Mutual Fund
- ITC on Construction of Warehouses
- Mentioning of GST models in invoice
- Tax Liability on Trading Account in Name of Person with Disability (Autism) Operated by Guardian
- Adt1 dsc where to affix?
- TDS Applicability on Adobe Subscription u/s 195
- Tcs claim for previous financial year
- TDS Return filing if only have 15G /15H deductions and no other payments
- Portuguese Civil Code of 1867
- IGST ITC RELATED
- GST on Taxi Service
- IMPORT OF GOODS CREDIT
- Formation of company by advocate
Trending Online Classes
-
Online GST Course - Master the Fundamentals of GST with Practical Insights
Ruhi Joshirao19 January 2026
CAclubindia
