banner_ad

Chirayu Arora

Hospital is backed by a Partnership firm of 3 partners (Partner X - General Physician, MBBS, Partner Y - Assistant Surgeon (Not MBBS), Partner Z- Gynecologist .

Query - Hospital charges various expenses through different components for example Room rent, nursing charges etc. Similarly, hospital Invoice also includes Doctor fees which doctor charges for treating the patients, Sometimes patient is treated by partner or external doctor (which is not a partner) or both .

Query 1 - Can Partner X take these fees for treating the patients under 194 J other than Salary or limit specified under section 40 b ? If Yes/No - Kindly suggest relevant case law
Query 2 - Can Partner Y & Z take these fees for treating the patients ( as based on their experience they also treats patients for other diseases like Malaria, Jaundice etc. ) other than Salary or limit specified under section 40 b? If Yes/No - Kindly suggest relevant case law

Kindly provide suggestions with case law if possible.


archana
24 May 2021 at 09:46

Deduction for mental disability

My father in law who is a senior citizen is suffering from a disease named Herpes Encephalitis a kind of neuro disease since january 2018. My husband is taking care of his medical expenditures. He wants to claim deduction u/s 80DD for his father's maintenance and medical treatment. Is he eligible for this deduction? if yes then how much? Is this disease listed anywhere? Is he required to get a certificate regarding this from any neuro specialist?


Guest

In the previous year 2017-18 & 2018-19, 2019-20 we exported goods to Nepal through GTA on payment of IGST. Now for the purpose of availing refund we need to update SB and other details in export bills. But in case of export of goods to Nepal no shipping is received back through GTA then how to claim refund for IGST paid. If anyone can help this will be of great help.


DEBASISH BODHAK

In a Pvt Ltd Co there are 10 shareholders (2 of them are directors) holding 52% of shares (Group-A) and 6 shareholders (2 of them are directors) holding 48% of the shares (Group-B). One of the directors of Group-B died recently.
In this circumstances Group-A wants to appoint a director in please of the deceased director in EGM. Please tell me is it possible without the consent of Group-B?


Neha

Sir/Madam please provide guidance. GSTR-1 Of April 2021 submitted but not filed yet. By mistake HSN wise summary table has been left blank. Now cannot add details of HSN. What should be done please guide. Thanks in advance.


SANJEEV KUMAR

courier charges charged from customers is part of sale or not if not than how to post it in freight account because it is charged with item and posting of item sale goes to sales ledger and courier charges to expense account but i gstr3b it is shown combined but is sales ledger its sale amount of item only it creates difference in sales ledger and gstr 3b i have made courier charges a item and posting has ben assigned to freight ledger


Rajeshpro badge
22 May 2021 at 16:30

GST rate on Alphonso Mangos

In my knowledge Mangoes are exempt from GST. But if they are not, what is the latest rate on Mangoes?


Anil Sharma
22 May 2021 at 15:53

AOP/ AOP (Trust)

One of my client is registered under Rajasthan Society Act having PAN status as AOP (Not registered as AOP trust) but working for charitable purpose my query is regarding

1. Does audit applies to him if his receipts from donation is upto 100000 and expenditure for charitable purpose is 998000 ?

2. If answer is yes to above then which form applies ?

3. Can such types of AOP can be registered under 12AA by filing Form 10A ?

4. Is is compulsory to file the Return ?

5. What should we prepare Receipt & Payment / Income & Expenditure / Profit & Loss Account ?


Piyush
22 May 2021 at 14:02

Transfer of Funds from NRE Account

In case of Non resident, wants to buy property in India, while making the payment for the same can he directly pay from his NRE Account or he Should transfer the fund from NRE to NRO Account & then make the payment from NRO Account ? He may sell the property in near future & consideration will come in NRO Account.

From which Account payment should be made for purchase to avoid much tax & any other implication in the year of sale of the same ?


ANOOP V.P
22 May 2021 at 13:28

Advance tax - urgent help needed

Mr. A, aged 59 years, won 9 lakh and Mr. B, aged 50 years, won
8 lakh from lotteries. Tax deductible at source under section 194B
was duly deducted. Assuming that this is the only source of income of
Mr. A and Mr. B for A.Y.2021-22, are Mr. A and Mr. B liable to pay
advance tax for that year?

(a) No, Mr. A and Mr. B are not liable to pay advance tax as tax
deductible at source under section 194B has been fully
deducted

(b) Yes, Mr. A and Mr. B are liable to pay advance tax

(c) Mr. A is liable to pay advance tax but Mr. B is not liable to pay
advance tax

(d) Mr. B is liable to pay advance tax but Mr. A is not liable to pay
advance tax

Please anyone give answer with reason







CCI Pro
Meet our CAclubindia PRO Members

Follow us
add to google news



Answer Query

Company
22 May 2026
Sr. Financial Analyst - Consolidation

Search Synergy

Mumbai

CA

View Details
Company
04 May 2026
Articleship

S.K Gairola & CO

New Delhi

B.Com

View Details
Company
04 May 2026
Content Writer Intern

Interactive Media Pvt Ltd.

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 15 May 2026
Audit Assistant / Article Trainee / Intern

SSGS and Associates

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 28 May 2026
SEMI QUALIFIED/ CA DROPOUTS/ ARTICLES

T R SOOD & CO

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
19 May 2026
Accountant

ca kunjan

Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 27 May 2026
Lead Conversion Executive / Sales Closing Executive

SMJ global advisors pvt ltd

New Delhi

B.Com

View Details
Company
26 May 2026
Audit executive

vdsr & co LLP

Chennai

CA Inter

View Details