Prashant Khurana
This Query has 1 replies

This Query has 1 replies

14 July 2011 at 02:33

Professional Ethics

Hello Sir.......

Sir, under clause 8 of part-1 of schedule-1, it is stated that before u accept the bank audit as current auditor you have to communicate with previous auditor. Suppose, u get the confirmation on 29th march that u have got one bank audit and u don't have enough time to communicate with previous auditor.

And u accept that work on conditional acceptance that if no objection was put by previous auditor then we will continue your work yet we are starting this audit work now as there is less time available.

but the previous auditor put an objection on your appointment or work then u will not continue your bank audit work and leave that bank's branch as unaudited.Because of that, the central statutory auditor(head office auditor of bank) will not be able to form final audit report as the audit of ur branch has not be done and audit report is not send.

In this case, who is ultimately responsible for the consequence or final audit report and ur branch audit and held guilty for the same?



Anonymous
This Query has 2 replies

This Query has 2 replies

13 July 2011 at 23:26

tds and service tax

we are auditing in one company.this company issue the invoice in next month. means feb invoice issued in the month of march and payment received in the month of april.my query is that whether i booked a invoice for the month of feb and march in the current period or not and what about TDS and Service on this bill.


CA PRAKASH M KHATRI
This Query has 1 replies

This Query has 1 replies

Kindly let me know the scale of audit fees payable for the statutory audit of co-opertive banks in maharashtra state.The allotment is received from the office of Commissioner of Cooperation,Maharashtra.


CA Abhiram Bharat.
This Query has 1 replies

This Query has 1 replies

13 July 2011 at 13:35

employee's contributuin to P.F. ESI

hello experts,,
please let me know what happens practically,
we all are aware that employer's cont, to P.f.etc is allowed if the same is deposited by the duedate of furnishing ROI, but the EMPLOYEE'S cont, should be deposited by the employer upto the due date of RELEVANT ACTS (i,e, PF Act, ESI Act).i.e. 15th of next month,(20th, or 21st of the following month including the grace period as suggested by the guidance note on TAX Audit by ICAI).
& if the EMPLOYEE'S cont, has not been deposited by the employer by the said date(i.e.20 or 21 of next month ), then no deduction is allowable to the employer u/s 36(1)(va) of the IT act. it will be the income of the employer U/S 2(22)(x).

now please tell me, since there is a contradicting judgement of the delhi high court (2010) in case of AIMIL LIMITED, which advocates that the employees cont shall be allowed to the employer if the same is also deposited by the due date of ROI furnishing..

but practically what happens that every company delays by one or two days,,then, wud it really be the income of the employer if he fails to deposit the employees cont by the due date of the relevant acts.

I want to know what is to be done practically..

please explain me in detail.

kind regdards-
abhiram
09268382789.






ashwin
This Query has 1 replies

This Query has 1 replies

12 July 2011 at 12:16

Reporting u/s 269 ss and 269 t

According to section 269ss and 269T loan or deposit taken or repaid over and above 20000/- rs. should not be made otherwise account payee cheque or DD. My question is whether loan repaid below the specified limit requires reporting under 3CD? If one party has made repayment of rs. 7500/- during previous year, should it be reported in 3cd??? Similary in case of 269SS, whether loan taken below rs.20000/- should be reported???



Anonymous
This Query has 2 replies

This Query has 2 replies

12 July 2011 at 11:52

Audit coverd u/s 44ad

one of my client is proprietor and having turnover below 60lacs n his profit is below 8 %.so he is require audit his books.now my question is that is there any diff.b/w regular audit and audit report or not.n if yes then plz give me any format ..thanks in adv



Anonymous
This Query has 3 replies

This Query has 3 replies

11 July 2011 at 23:22

Appointment of statutory auditor

our co. is listed on stock exchange. We want to change our existing auditor who is located out of state for future better liasoning and other genuine reasons and want to appoint one already identified local CA firm.

As per comanies act sec 224 provisions an statutory auditor holds office from the conclusion of AGM in which he is appointed till the conclusion of next AGM. our next AGM is scheduled in september 11 this year which we can not prepond. Also for removing the auditor before expiry of his tenure central govt approval is required and an resolution in GM needs to be passed.

Considering the above difficulties what we are planning is that we will take resignation from our existing auditor and appoint new firm who will conduct quarterly limited review for 1 quarer ending on june 11 for which we need to submit the report within 45 days to stock exchanges. Afterwards in next AGM scheduled in Sept 11 his appointment would be ratified by shareholders from back date. However as per comanies act sec 224 (6)(a) first proviso, casual vacancy caused by resignation of existing auditor can be filled in by appointment of new auditor in GM only. Please suggest whether ratificaton of appointment of auditor as stated above for carrying out limited review of q1 of FY11-12 in AGM is valid one or we need to first call EGM anyways.


NIRAV SAVLA
This Query has 1 replies

This Query has 1 replies

11 July 2011 at 11:48

APPLICABILITY OF TDS

IS CO OP SOCIETIES NOT HAVING PAN AND TAN BUT AUDITING ITS ACCOUNTS ARE LIABLE TO DEDUCT TDS ON CONTRACT AND PROFFESSIONAL CHARGES?

WHAT ARE THE PROVISIONS IF THEY DON'T DO SO?



Anonymous
This Query has 2 replies

This Query has 2 replies

10 July 2011 at 22:50

Loss on Sale of Capital Assets

A proprietor has truck for business purpose. After 2 years of use he sold trucks.There is no depreciation charged in current year and loss incurred in sale of trucks. Can it possible to adjust loss under section 50 against profit of current year.


CA AJAY SONI
This Query has 2 replies

This Query has 2 replies

10 July 2011 at 20:27

INTERNAL AUDIT & STATUTORY AUDIT

Let us assume X and his son Y, both are CA. X is working as a Partner in Firm A and his son is practicing as a Proprietor in Firm B. Firm A and Firm B are purely independent. Suppose X is statutory Audit of Company C Ltd. in capacity as a partner of Partnership Firm. Can Y, son of X can accept Internal Audit in company C Ltd. Note: X and Y are working independently and Y is having no relation with the Partnership Firm. In view of Code of Professional Ethics, Auditing Standard, Company Act or any other Notification/Circular etc Can Y accept as a Internal Auditor of C Ltd. or not.





CCI Pro
Meet our CAclubindia PRO Members


Follow us


Answer Query