29 December 2014
@CA Parul - Parul Ji Ayush hasn't replied in response to your answer. It is for Tushar who has rectified his answer after seeing your correct answer. We acknowledge and appreciate your knowledge.
29 December 2014
Tushar had given incorrect reply which was subsequently corrected by Parul Ji and further confirmed by Warrier Sir.
Now Tushar has modified his reply without accepting his mistake. All are witness to it. I request Parul Ji and warrier Sir to state the facts since modifying reply without accepting mistake is very bad. It gives wrong impression for replies made by other experts afterwards.
02 January 2015
To err is human to accept and forgive is divine.
What has happened here is that wrong answers were given by Tushar and new due dates for payment and return filing was also given. If i remember correctly due date for return was given as 15th March previously. Even now if he has modified his replies he could have atleast gone as per the queriest next query or replied as per his last query. But he could do neither here. So it would have been great if he could have accepted his mistake and not modified his reply after other experts had given corrected reply. Further I think its a matter of pride of being selected as CCI favourite of the club and people would look upon such members reply. If this would be happening then the award system itself could loose credibility. So its a request that this type of mistakes do not happen or even if mistakes happen please go ahead and accept it rather that modifying your earlier reply.
Nothing was wrong with Paruljis comment and Ayushji reply was for Tushar only and not for you and as Pulkit has stated we acknowledge and appreciate your knowledge.
CAclubindia
