Very urgent...applicability of 44 ad
This query is : Resolved
23 August 2015
can 44 AD be applied to a firm providing advertising agency services?
( turnover 30,00,000 )
( turnover 30,00,000 )
23 August 2015
Yes. 44AD can be applied.
23 August 2015
The scheme of section 44AD is designed to give relief to small taxpayers engaged in any business, except the following businesses: Business of plying, hiring or leasing of goods carriages referred to in section 44AE. A person who is carrying on any "agency business". A person who is earning income in the nature of commission or brokerage
Do Advertising agency come under "agency business" as mentioned above?
Ifyes , 44 AD is applicable?
Do Advertising agency come under "agency business" as mentioned above?
Ifyes , 44 AD is applicable?
23 August 2015
I dont think advertising business will come under agency business and therefore 44AD should apply.
Still wait for views of other experts.
Still wait for views of other experts.
23 August 2015
TDS is deducted from payment to the advertising agency u/s 194 J.
so is it considered as a profession? ..
If yes , 44 AD applicable?
so is it considered as a profession? ..
If yes , 44 AD applicable?
23 August 2015
Please tell what is the exact nature of service. TDS on advertising contract is deducted u/s 194C.
23 August 2015
services relates to branding , promotional campaign etc..
24 August 2015
answer please........
24 August 2015
Not clear. Whether there is any advertisement contract or only consultancy service is provided?
24 August 2015
service relates to planning of promotional campaigns and advertisements for creating brands of products..
advertisement contracts were made..
also provide advertisement consultancy
advertisement contracts were made..
also provide advertisement consultancy
25 August 2015
Deduction of TDS depends upon type of service. If it is purely advertising, then section 194C would apply, if it is any type of consultancy then 194J.
Regarding audit, 44Ad would not apply here. It is a case of section 44AB where revenues exceed Rs. 25 lakhs.
Regarding audit, 44Ad would not apply here. It is a case of section 44AB where revenues exceed Rs. 25 lakhs.
25 August 2015
type of service in service tax return is "advertising agency services".
so can it be considered as a business rather than profession?
so can it be considered as a business rather than profession?
25 August 2015
type of service in service tax return is "advertising agency services".
so can it be considered as a business rather than profession?
so can it be considered as a business rather than profession?
25 August 2015
If TDS u/s 194 J is deducted , is it necessary to consider it as a profession ?
03 August 2025
This is a crucial and nuanced issue, especially regarding **Section 44AD** of the Income Tax Act, and whether it can be applied to **advertising agency services**.
Let’s break it down in **legal terms** and reach a clear, final answer:
---
## ✅ What is Section 44AD?
Section 44AD allows **eligible businesses** with turnover up to ₹2 crore (now ₹3 crore w\.e.f. AY 2024-25, subject to cash receipt limits) to **declare profits presumptively** at 8% (or 6% for digital receipts), **without maintaining books of account** or auditing.
### But: **Certain businesses are specifically excluded** under **Section 44AD(6)**:
1. **Professionals** referred to in **Section 44AA(1)** – including legal, medical, engineering, accountancy, technical consultancy, etc.
2. **Agency business**
3. **Commission or brokerage income**
4. Business covered under **Section 44AE** (transport).
---
## ❓ Does an **advertising agency** fall under "agency business" or "profession"?
### 🔹 If you are **merely acting as a conduit** between client and media (TV, print, digital), then:
* You are an **“agent”**, and
* Your income is likely **commission-based** from the media or a **markup** on media cost.
➡️ In this case, **Section 44AD does ***not*** apply**.
### 🔹 If you are doing **full-fledged campaign planning, creative design, branding, media buying, etc.**, and **billing clients directly** for all services:
* You are operating a **business**, not just an agency.
* Your income is **not commission-based**, but **direct billing**.
* TDS may be deducted **u/s 194C (advertising contracts)**, or **u/s 194J** if **consultancy/branding** work.
➡️ In such a case, **you may be eligible for Section 44AD**, **but with caution**.
---
## ⚖️ CBDT Clarification & Judicial View:
* There is **no specific CBDT circular** defining “agency” in Section 44AD, but **courts interpret it based on the degree of control and whether services are rendered directly or through third parties**.
* If you're **retaining creative control** and not just acting as an intermediary, you’re not an "agent" in the strict sense.
* However, **if you're earning via commission or markup**, 44AD is **not applicable**.
---
## ❗About TDS u/s 194J vs 194C:
* TDS under **194J** (professional/technical consultancy) does not **automatically mean** the income is **“professional”** under Section 44AA.
* But, **if you offer consultancy services as your core business**, it **may be construed** as a **profession**, which excludes you from 44AD.
---
## ✅ Final Answer:
Based on your facts:
> “**Service relates to planning of promotional campaigns and advertisements for creating brands of products. Advertisement contracts were made. Also provide advertisement consultancy.**”
### 🚫 **Section 44AD not applicable** **if:**
* You are providing **consultancy services** (strategy, brand advice).
* Or you are an **agent** between client and media (earning commission).
* Or your income is covered under **Section 44AA(1)** profession list.
### ✅ **Section 44AD may apply** **if:**
* You’re doing **end-to-end execution**: design, content, booking, billing.
* You **bill clients directly** (not just acting as a media agent).
* Income is **not from commission or consultancy**, and
* TDS is deducted u/s **194C**, not 194J.
---
## 🔍 Suggestions:
* If your income **mainly comes from consultancy or commission**, avoid opting for 44AD.
* Consider opting for **Section 44ADA** if you're a **qualified professional** (and your service fits into that list).
* Otherwise, maintain regular books and comply under **normal provisions or 44AB** if audit is applicable.
---
### Need Help?
If you want help drafting a **clarification letter to your CA or AO**, or a **comparative sheet** between 44AD, 44ADA, and regular scheme, let me know.
Let’s break it down in **legal terms** and reach a clear, final answer:
---
## ✅ What is Section 44AD?
Section 44AD allows **eligible businesses** with turnover up to ₹2 crore (now ₹3 crore w\.e.f. AY 2024-25, subject to cash receipt limits) to **declare profits presumptively** at 8% (or 6% for digital receipts), **without maintaining books of account** or auditing.
### But: **Certain businesses are specifically excluded** under **Section 44AD(6)**:
1. **Professionals** referred to in **Section 44AA(1)** – including legal, medical, engineering, accountancy, technical consultancy, etc.
2. **Agency business**
3. **Commission or brokerage income**
4. Business covered under **Section 44AE** (transport).
---
## ❓ Does an **advertising agency** fall under "agency business" or "profession"?
### 🔹 If you are **merely acting as a conduit** between client and media (TV, print, digital), then:
* You are an **“agent”**, and
* Your income is likely **commission-based** from the media or a **markup** on media cost.
➡️ In this case, **Section 44AD does ***not*** apply**.
### 🔹 If you are doing **full-fledged campaign planning, creative design, branding, media buying, etc.**, and **billing clients directly** for all services:
* You are operating a **business**, not just an agency.
* Your income is **not commission-based**, but **direct billing**.
* TDS may be deducted **u/s 194C (advertising contracts)**, or **u/s 194J** if **consultancy/branding** work.
➡️ In such a case, **you may be eligible for Section 44AD**, **but with caution**.
---
## ⚖️ CBDT Clarification & Judicial View:
* There is **no specific CBDT circular** defining “agency” in Section 44AD, but **courts interpret it based on the degree of control and whether services are rendered directly or through third parties**.
* If you're **retaining creative control** and not just acting as an intermediary, you’re not an "agent" in the strict sense.
* However, **if you're earning via commission or markup**, 44AD is **not applicable**.
---
## ❗About TDS u/s 194J vs 194C:
* TDS under **194J** (professional/technical consultancy) does not **automatically mean** the income is **“professional”** under Section 44AA.
* But, **if you offer consultancy services as your core business**, it **may be construed** as a **profession**, which excludes you from 44AD.
---
## ✅ Final Answer:
Based on your facts:
> “**Service relates to planning of promotional campaigns and advertisements for creating brands of products. Advertisement contracts were made. Also provide advertisement consultancy.**”
### 🚫 **Section 44AD not applicable** **if:**
* You are providing **consultancy services** (strategy, brand advice).
* Or you are an **agent** between client and media (earning commission).
* Or your income is covered under **Section 44AA(1)** profession list.
### ✅ **Section 44AD may apply** **if:**
* You’re doing **end-to-end execution**: design, content, booking, billing.
* You **bill clients directly** (not just acting as a media agent).
* Income is **not from commission or consultancy**, and
* TDS is deducted u/s **194C**, not 194J.
---
## 🔍 Suggestions:
* If your income **mainly comes from consultancy or commission**, avoid opting for 44AD.
* Consider opting for **Section 44ADA** if you're a **qualified professional** (and your service fits into that list).
* Otherwise, maintain regular books and comply under **normal provisions or 44AB** if audit is applicable.
---
### Need Help?
If you want help drafting a **clarification letter to your CA or AO**, or a **comparative sheet** between 44AD, 44ADA, and regular scheme, let me know.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Regarding Appointment of auditor in case of casual vacancy
- GST- DRC 03 RCM Liability
- Query on managerial remuneration u/s 197 of CA 2013
- Conversion of Proprietorship Firm to Partnership Firm
- Updated return filing
- Validity of form 15 G and 15 H on Interest on fixed deposit
- Supply to unit situated in SEZ
- Temporary GST registration
- TDS AFTER SUBMISSION OF 15G OR H
- Additional income for updated return
- GSTR 1- Amend Credit Note
- Audit of F and O T/O
- EXCESS CREDIT REALTED GST REVERSAL
- Export invoice not reported
- CA Articleship Extension Matter
- GST OFFICER WRONG NOTICE
- "Please ensure that the Total of the Deductions u/s 54F match the same in Table D in Sch CG"
- Composition Dealer GST Annual Return Filing process
- Revision under Section 264 in The Income Tax Act, 1961
- TDS under section 195.
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
