Treatment of sales returns in vat calculation
This query is : Resolved
09 July 2013
Treatment of Sales returns in VAT Calcultion:
Dear Sir,
I wish to know exact treatment of Sales returns from VAT angle.
Mr. A sold 12.5% VAT goods to Mr. B on 02/07/2012. Mr. A files monthly VAT returns.
1) However few goods were returned by the Mr. B after more than six months i.e. say on 05/05/2013. How to consider this sales returns during the FY 2013-14? Whether to deduct this sale from 12.5% VAT sales of May 13 to arrive at VAT liability?
2) Suppose these sales are interstate sales of 2% CST and if the ‘C’ forms are issued and the same are returned backed after more than six months then whether to deduct this sale from 2%CST sale of May 13? What will be the impact if ‘C’ forms are already issued?
3) Further how to treat this VAT / CST sale return in May 13 if there is no corresponding same VAT / CST rate sale in May 13 i.e. there is no 12.5% VAT or 2% CST sale.
Whether the accounting treatment suggested for above cases will remain the same for Purchase returns also?
Kindly Guide.
Regards,
Suraj
Dear Sir,
I wish to know exact treatment of Sales returns from VAT angle.
Mr. A sold 12.5% VAT goods to Mr. B on 02/07/2012. Mr. A files monthly VAT returns.
1) However few goods were returned by the Mr. B after more than six months i.e. say on 05/05/2013. How to consider this sales returns during the FY 2013-14? Whether to deduct this sale from 12.5% VAT sales of May 13 to arrive at VAT liability?
2) Suppose these sales are interstate sales of 2% CST and if the ‘C’ forms are issued and the same are returned backed after more than six months then whether to deduct this sale from 2%CST sale of May 13? What will be the impact if ‘C’ forms are already issued?
3) Further how to treat this VAT / CST sale return in May 13 if there is no corresponding same VAT / CST rate sale in May 13 i.e. there is no 12.5% VAT or 2% CST sale.
Whether the accounting treatment suggested for above cases will remain the same for Purchase returns also?
Kindly Guide.
Regards,
Suraj
10 July 2013
VAT is a STATE subject matter.
In order to get a perfect and correct reply mention the STATE.
In order to get a perfect and correct reply mention the STATE.
02 August 2025
Thanks for specifying Maharashtra. Here’s how **sales returns** are generally treated for VAT and CST purposes under Maharashtra VAT rules and applicable practices:
---
### 1) **Sales Returns after More Than Six Months (Intra-State, VAT @12.5%)**
* In Maharashtra VAT, **sales returns can be adjusted only in the same financial year** in which the original sale was made.
* If the goods are returned **after six months or in the next FY**, you **cannot adjust the sales return against the VAT liability of that month or financial year**.
* Instead, the sales return should be treated as a **separate transaction in the FY in which the goods are returned** (here, FY 2013-14).
* You will need to record the **return as a negative sale (or credit note) in the VAT return for the month of May 2013** or whichever month the return took place.
* The **VAT liability for May 2013 will reduce accordingly**, even if there was no original sale in May 2013. This means you can show a negative sale in that month.
---
### 2) **Interstate Sales (CST @ 2%) with C Forms issued and Returns after 6 Months**
* **C Forms allow concessional CST at 2%**, provided the goods are actually sold interstate.
* If the goods are returned **after more than 6 months**, the concessional CST benefit may be at risk because CST liability is tied to actual sale.
* The **sales return should be adjusted in the month of return (May 2013 here)**.
* If the **C Form was already issued for the original sale**, then upon return:
* The seller should **reverse the concessional CST benefit** for the returned goods.
* The return should be reported in the CST return of the month in which return took place.
* **If there is no sale in May 2013 but return happens, record negative sales and adjust CST liability accordingly.**
---
### 3) **When No Corresponding Sale in the Return Month**
* If there is no original sale in May 2013 (or the month of return), but return is happening in that month:
* You still record the **sales return as negative sales** in that month’s VAT or CST return.
* This will reduce your taxable turnover and VAT/CST liability in that month.
* The tax authority allows this adjustment because you cannot adjust returns against sales of the previous year (except within the same FY).
---
### 4) **Treatment of Purchase Returns**
* Purchase returns are treated similarly.
* If purchase returns occur in the same FY as original purchase, they adjust your input tax credit.
* If purchase returns occur in a subsequent FY, they should be recorded in the month and FY when the return happens, as negative purchases.
* This means your input tax credit will reduce in the month of return, even if there was no corresponding purchase in that month.
---
### Summary Table
| Situation | Treatment in VAT/CST Return | Notes |
| --------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------ |
| Sales return within same FY | Adjust sales and VAT/CST in original sale month | Simple adjustment |
| Sales return after 6 months (next FY) | Show as negative sales and reduce VAT/CST in return month | Even if no sale in that month |
| Interstate sales with C Form, return after 6 months | Reverse concessional CST in month of return | C Form benefit to be reversed |
| Purchase returns in different FY | Adjust input credit in month of return | Negative purchase recorded in return month |
---
### Important:
* Always issue **credit notes** for sales returns and maintain proper documentation.
* Maintain clear records for returns when filing returns or during audits.
* Check Maharashtra VAT Circulars or notifications for any specific instructions.
---
If you want, I can help draft a sample journal entry or VAT return treatment for these cases. Would that be helpful?
---
### 1) **Sales Returns after More Than Six Months (Intra-State, VAT @12.5%)**
* In Maharashtra VAT, **sales returns can be adjusted only in the same financial year** in which the original sale was made.
* If the goods are returned **after six months or in the next FY**, you **cannot adjust the sales return against the VAT liability of that month or financial year**.
* Instead, the sales return should be treated as a **separate transaction in the FY in which the goods are returned** (here, FY 2013-14).
* You will need to record the **return as a negative sale (or credit note) in the VAT return for the month of May 2013** or whichever month the return took place.
* The **VAT liability for May 2013 will reduce accordingly**, even if there was no original sale in May 2013. This means you can show a negative sale in that month.
---
### 2) **Interstate Sales (CST @ 2%) with C Forms issued and Returns after 6 Months**
* **C Forms allow concessional CST at 2%**, provided the goods are actually sold interstate.
* If the goods are returned **after more than 6 months**, the concessional CST benefit may be at risk because CST liability is tied to actual sale.
* The **sales return should be adjusted in the month of return (May 2013 here)**.
* If the **C Form was already issued for the original sale**, then upon return:
* The seller should **reverse the concessional CST benefit** for the returned goods.
* The return should be reported in the CST return of the month in which return took place.
* **If there is no sale in May 2013 but return happens, record negative sales and adjust CST liability accordingly.**
---
### 3) **When No Corresponding Sale in the Return Month**
* If there is no original sale in May 2013 (or the month of return), but return is happening in that month:
* You still record the **sales return as negative sales** in that month’s VAT or CST return.
* This will reduce your taxable turnover and VAT/CST liability in that month.
* The tax authority allows this adjustment because you cannot adjust returns against sales of the previous year (except within the same FY).
---
### 4) **Treatment of Purchase Returns**
* Purchase returns are treated similarly.
* If purchase returns occur in the same FY as original purchase, they adjust your input tax credit.
* If purchase returns occur in a subsequent FY, they should be recorded in the month and FY when the return happens, as negative purchases.
* This means your input tax credit will reduce in the month of return, even if there was no corresponding purchase in that month.
---
### Summary Table
| Situation | Treatment in VAT/CST Return | Notes |
| --------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------ |
| Sales return within same FY | Adjust sales and VAT/CST in original sale month | Simple adjustment |
| Sales return after 6 months (next FY) | Show as negative sales and reduce VAT/CST in return month | Even if no sale in that month |
| Interstate sales with C Form, return after 6 months | Reverse concessional CST in month of return | C Form benefit to be reversed |
| Purchase returns in different FY | Adjust input credit in month of return | Negative purchase recorded in return month |
---
### Important:
* Always issue **credit notes** for sales returns and maintain proper documentation.
* Maintain clear records for returns when filing returns or during audits.
* Check Maharashtra VAT Circulars or notifications for any specific instructions.
---
If you want, I can help draft a sample journal entry or VAT return treatment for these cases. Would that be helpful?
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Applicability of TDS on CFS, CHA fees, and shipping line charges
- Notice from IT DEPTT IF FD AMOUNT EXCEEDS 10 LACS
- Applicablity on tds
- Unable to generate and save json file for updated return
- GST payable under RCM
- Regarding TDS not deducted on rent
- Section 194I not showing in TDS RPU for Compnay Assessee for TDS on rent
- WRONGLY UPLOADED 10IF FOR COOPERATIVE SOCIETY
- Tax audit & Switching from Presumptive taxation
- PRODUCT AND SERVICE CATEGORY CODE
- Import purchase entry
- Rule 54(1A) for Distributing ITC
- EXCESS CREDIT REALTED GST REVERSAL
- Export invoice not reported
- CA Articleship Extension Matter
- GST OFFICER WRONG NOTICE
- "Please ensure that the Total of the Deductions u/s 54F match the same in Table D in Sch CG"
- Composition Dealer GST Annual Return Filing process
- Revision under Section 264 in The Income Tax Act, 1961
- TDS under section 195.
Trending Online Classes
-
LIVE Course on GSTR-9 & GSTR-9C (Technical | Practical | Concept - Based)
Sachin Jain03 November 2025
CAclubindia
