Sec. 14A of the Income Tax Act
This query is : Resolved
02 January 2009
Pl express your opinion with supporting case laws if any
A widely held Public Limited Company (Say A Ltd, a holding company of several other companies) invests Rs.30 Lakhs in a private limited company (Say B Pvt Ltd) by way of equity capital out of proceeds of its own equity (not from borrowed funds) say in AY 2003-04. B Pvt Ltd is regular in paying dividend to its shareholders incl. A Ltd.
In AY 2006-07, A Ltd for its general business purposes including investment in capital of various private limited companies, borrows money on interest from B Pvt Ltd Rs.20L at the ruling market interest rates on the basis of a loan agreement with all usual terms and conditions
The Assessing Officer (AO) while assessing the income of A Ltd would like to invoke the provisions of Sec 14A holding that the loan is nothing but withdrawl of capital investment in the guise of loan and investments are made in other companies after taking this loan.
IS THE ACTION OF AO JUSTIFIED?
A widely held Public Limited Company (Say A Ltd, a holding company of several other companies) invests Rs.30 Lakhs in a private limited company (Say B Pvt Ltd) by way of equity capital out of proceeds of its own equity (not from borrowed funds) say in AY 2003-04. B Pvt Ltd is regular in paying dividend to its shareholders incl. A Ltd.
In AY 2006-07, A Ltd for its general business purposes including investment in capital of various private limited companies, borrows money on interest from B Pvt Ltd Rs.20L at the ruling market interest rates on the basis of a loan agreement with all usual terms and conditions
The Assessing Officer (AO) while assessing the income of A Ltd would like to invoke the provisions of Sec 14A holding that the loan is nothing but withdrawl of capital investment in the guise of loan and investments are made in other companies after taking this loan.
IS THE ACTION OF AO JUSTIFIED?
02 January 2009
A Ltd has to prove that Rs 20 lakhs borrowed is for its business purposes otherwise the view of the AO will sustain.
07 December 2009
Pl elaborate
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- ESI Contribution after implementing COSS
- Cg on ancestral property sale distribution
- Can huf give gift to karta or kartas wife and son
- FY 24-25 Invoice Booked in FY 25-26 & ITC Claimed in FY 25-26
- TDS deduction liability ?
- Negative liability in GSTR-3B
- Query on applicability of Small Company, CARO & IFC
- Outward HSN details in Table 17 - unable to enter more than 6 HSN codes - Reg.
- Gst itc related queries
- GSTR - 9 Input Tax Credit
- Gstr9 annual return
- Schedule VDA
- Articlehsip_temination
- Salary journal entry
- Design work
- Goods stopped by DRI department at port
- Inventory Valuation and Closing Stock entry in books and opening stock entry in books
- IGST refund with GST amendment deadline over
- ITR revision intimation recd.
- "Please ensure that the Total of the Deductions u/s 54F match the same in Table D in Sch CG"
Trending Online Classes
-
FR & Direct Tax (Regular Batch Combo) For May 26 & Onwards
CA Bhanwar Borana & CA Aakash Kandoi
CAclubindia
