Joint auditors 安定

Save Share

This query is : Resolved

Ting (Querist)

02 December 2009 Dear Sir/ Madam,

May I get your help for the below 2 questions,

1) Why some companies in India employ jonit auditors (excluding the
national banks that are required by regulation)?
Where can I get some official documentation on this phenomenon?

2)Comparing BSE and NSE, which is the more important stock exchange in India?

Can we say that the quality of the listed companies in BSE are generally
better than the ones listed in NSE?

If I want to choose a sample body for my research for Indian listed
companies, may I say BSE is a better choice than NSE?

And where can I get some official info on this?

Appreciate a lot.

Wish you a nice day.

Amol Gopal Kabra (CA,CS,DISA)

Amol Gopal Kabra (CA,CS,DISA) (Expert)

13 December 2009 Answer to Query No. (1)

There is no specific phenomenon on appointment of such joint auditors by the companies. Its a general thing noticed that one of the joint auditor is some Big 4 MNC and another is some local firm. There is no phenomenon or any law in this regard. However, there is a logic behind it. Generally the other local firm is the one which is the auditor of the company since its inception and generally it happens that companies don't change their old auditors. Further, as the operations of the company grow to a large extent, they require experts as auditors and as mentioned that old auditors are not changed generally, they appoint MNC Audit Firm as Auditor jointly with their old auditors. This is purely a logic.

Amol Gopal Kabra (CA,CS,DISA)

Amol Gopal Kabra (CA,CS,DISA) (Expert)

13 December 2009 Answer to Query No. (2)

Considering BSE and NSE, NSE is more important stock exchange in India as it account for almost 90% of the Volume in the Stock Market. There is no difference as such in the quality of the companies listed on either of the stock exchanges. The difference is in the trading volumes of the shares that are dealt with the stock exchange.
If you want to chose a sample for research in Indian Stock Market, then its better to go from a sample from NSE as the data on NSE most appropriately resembles the population rather than on BSE.

I hope both your queries are resolved.

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now