GCL (query)

Save Share

This query is : Resolved

RAHUL KUMAR TAANK (Querist)

03 November 2010 WHICH STATEMENT IS CORRRECT:-

A PERSON CAN APPROACH THE SUPREME COURT DIRECTLY IF:-

(1)ANY OF HIS RIGHT IS VIOLATED ;

(2)ANY OF HIS FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS IS VIOLATED.

THX IN ADVANCE FOR REPLY .........

CA.JAYAKUMAR.J

CA.JAYAKUMAR.J (Expert)

04 November 2010 any person cannot approch supreme court directly , only after deprevied by the lower courts one can appeal to superem court, simple if we can apprach supreme court directly why shud we have district, state high courts.

Message likes : 1 times

vardan sharma

vardan sharma (Expert)

04 November 2010 In case of violation of fundamental right if the violation falls within the ambit of Article 32 one can move directly to SC

CS Vardaan Jangid

Message likes : 1 times

RAHUL KUMAR TAANK

RAHUL KUMAR TAANK (Querist)

24 November 2010 thankyou sir,

can i write your name IN cs examination as like defination that according "In case of violation of fundamental right if the violation falls within the ambit of Article 32 one can move directly to SC"

ACCORDING CS VARDAN SHARMA

and

any person cannot approch supreme court directly , only after deprevied by the lower courts one can appeal to superem court, simple if we can apprach supreme court directly why shud we have district, state high courts.

ACCORDING CA JAYKUMAR L

RAHUL KUMAR TAANK

RAHUL KUMAR TAANK (Querist)

24 November 2010 please tell me whom of above said statement is right?

A PERSON CAN APPROACH THE SUPREME COURT DIRECTLY IF:-

(1)ANY OF HIS RIGHT IS VIOLATED ;

(2)ANY OF HIS FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS IS VIOLATED.

THX IN ADVANCE FOR REPLY .........

RAHUL KUMAR TAANK

RAHUL KUMAR TAANK (Querist)

24 November 2010 please explain me sir, sanjay ji and vardan sharma ji's your explanation in the said statement.

in waiting of ur reply sir ...............

vardan sharma

vardan sharma (Expert)

24 November 2010 Rahul
understand like this
if any right is violated a person has to move to the court of lowest jurisdiction.
But if any fundamental right is violated article 32 gives remedy to move to the SC directly.
AS far as related to your II part of querry about "According to" definitions or explanation specially for constitution must be adduced from the explanation given by Judges of supreme court and not according to any second person.
you can quote "J.C.Johri P 109 Indian consitution and politics" or "B.P.Gajendragadkar P.60-62 Indian constitution"
if you have any other querry you can write to vardansharma@gmail.com

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now