Why business loss cannot be set off against salary

This query is : Resolved

Share Report Follow Query Ask a Query

Akshay R Jain

Akshay R Jain (Querist)
Follow

29 March 2013 whats the reason or logic

CA. PIYUSH GOEL

CA. PIYUSH GOEL (Expert)
Follow

29 March 2013 dear Akshay lets take an example..

i earned salary say for Rs. 250000/-

and i does not have any investment u/s 80C..

but i have to save tax...

now i would show that i have started a new business in the month of march but no sale has taken place in the month of march..

in that case my P&L show business loss..

which i would set off my salary income..

to prevent such manipulation government has provided a restriction that income from salary cannot be set off with the business loss

Akshay R Jain

Akshay R Jain (Querist)
Follow

29 March 2013 If this is the reason sir i will give you an example i have a huge capital gain.In order to save the tax, i will create the business loss of what you gave as example than why govt is not preventing that manipulation

Akshay R Jain

Akshay R Jain (Querist)
Follow

08 August 2013 Please provide the ans for the above

Akshay R Jain

Akshay R Jain (Querist)
Follow

08 August 2013 Please provide the ans for the above

Aashok Kumar Sharma

Aashok Kumar Sharma (Expert)
Follow

03 August 2025 This is a very good and practical question, and it touches the core principles of income tax law and anti-abuse rules.

✅ Why Business Loss Cannot Be Set Off Against Salary Income (As per Section 71 of the Income Tax Act)?
Section 71(2A) of the Income Tax Act expressly prohibits the set-off of any loss from business or profession against salary income.

💡 The Logic or Reasoning Behind This Restriction:
❌ To prevent tax evasion or artificial loss creation
If allowed, high-salary earners could start a dummy or artificial business, show huge losses, and evade tax on genuine salary income.

Example: If someone earns ₹30 lakh salary and shows ₹25 lakh business loss (by inflating expenses), their taxable income becomes only ₹5 lakh — an easy loophole if allowed.

🔐 Salary is a secure and regular source of income
Salary income is subject to TDS, traced, and well-regulated, so it has less scope of manipulation.

Business loss, however, is self-assessed, more flexible in terms of expense booking, and thus easier to manipulate.

🏛️ Consistency and fairness in taxation
Income from different heads is treated differently because the nature, risk, and flexibility of those incomes differ.

Business involves entrepreneurship and risks — losses from it are allowed to be carried forward or set off against business income, but not to shelter regular salary.

📜 Parliamentary Intent
The law was amended to insert Section 71(2A) in Finance Act, 2005 with clear intent to prevent misuse.

🔁 What You Can Do Instead:
Business loss can be set off against capital gains, house property income, and other sources, but not salary.

Unabsorbed business loss can be carried forward for 8 years and set off against future business profits.

🔍 Summary:
Loss Type Can be set off against Salary? Notes
Business loss ❌ No Per Sec 71(2A)
House Property Loss ✅ Yes Max ₹2 lakh/year
Capital Loss ❌ No Can only be set off against capital gains

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now