06 May 2014
if not material is provided by you, it would be a sale contract and no tds shall apply.
Querist :
Anonymous
Querist :
Anonymous
(Querist)
20 May 2014
Dear Sir , Our Paper Trader providing Paper to the Offset Printer & Offset printer printing Books & supply to us with 5% Vat. So may I deduct TDS while paying Bill amount & If Yes on Which amount TDS will be Deducted-Basic or Gross bill amount?
27 July 2025
Here’s a clear explanation regarding **TDS on printing of books** in your case:
---
### 1. **Is TDS applicable on printing of books?**
* If the **printer is providing printing services** (i.e., you are paying for service of printing, and not just buying goods/materials), **TDS is applicable**. * Section **194C** (Payment to Contractors) generally applies to payments made for works contracts and services related to printing. * However, if the printer is merely selling printed books (goods), and not providing service, then **TDS is not applicable**.
---
### 2. **How to determine if it’s service or sale?**
* Since your paper trader provides paper (material) to the printer, and the printer prints and delivers books, this is typically treated as a **works contract service** (service plus supply of goods). * In such cases, **TDS under Section 194C is applicable on the gross amount charged by the printer** (including VAT, but VAT can be excluded if separately shown).
---
### 3. **At what rate should TDS be deducted?**
* Under **Section 194C**, TDS rate is generally:
* **1%** if the payee is an individual or Hindu Undivided Family (HUF). * **2%** if the payee is any other person (including companies). * So, if your offset printer is a company, deduct **2% TDS on the gross bill amount**.
---
### 4. **TDS amount calculation example:**
| Particulars | Amount (Rs.) | Note | | ---------------------- | ------------ | ------------------------------------------------------ | | Bill amount (Printing) | 1,00,000 | Service + materials | | VAT @ 5% | 5,000 | Separate VAT on bill | | Gross amount | 1,05,000 | Amount payable to printer | | TDS @ 2% | 2,100 | Deduct on gross or excl. VAT (clarify with accountant) |
---
### 5. **Important notes:**
* Some experts recommend deducting TDS on **amount excluding VAT** because VAT is a tax collected on behalf of the government, not income to the printer. * Clarify with your accountant whether to deduct TDS on bill amount excluding VAT or on gross amount including VAT.
---
### Summary
| Aspect | Details | | ------------------ | ----------------------------------------------------------- | | TDS applicable? | Yes, if payment is for printing service (works contract) | | Applicable section | Section 194C | | Rate of TDS | 1% for individuals/HUF, 2% for others (companies) | | Deduction base | Gross amount or amount excluding VAT (preferably excl. VAT) |
---
If you want, I can help draft a sample TDS deduction statement or provide more references on this. Would that help?