Same partners in different firms.

This query is : Open

sathiya (Querist)
Follow

24 July 2019 If partners of a Firm want to create another firm with the same set of partners and same percentage of share of profits for convenience purpose, is it allowable? Will the income of both the firms be merged in the hands of AO??

Bhaskaran Chackrapani Warrier

Bhaskaran Chackrapani Warrier (Expert)
Follow

24 July 2019 Chances of clubbing can be expected, if nature of business is one and the same.

Message likes : 1 times

sathiya

sathiya (Querist)
Follow

25 July 2019 Thank you Sir. If the nature of business is completely different, can they create another firm?

PARAS CHHAJED

PARAS CHHAJED (Expert)
Follow

25 December 2023 If two partnership firms with same partners and same profit sharing ratios are constituted may be for same line of business or for different line of business then in my opinion they are to be assessed as a single firm.

If they are allowed to have multiple firms with same partners and same ratio then each firm shall get different PAN, different registration and they shall be claiming allowable remuneration to partners in terms of s. 40(b) for each firm and thereby the remuneration allowable shall be higher as compared to consolidated one.

To put it simply, each firm shall be allowed to pay remuneration @ 90% of first 3 lakhs of book profit.

Therefore, in my opinion multiple firms with same partners and same profit sharing ratio should not exist and instead they should be treated as one firm.

For different verticals, i.e. different line of activities one may have multiple GSTINs and need not constitute multiple firms. One may have different trade names for different branches, different nature of business but should have only one Legal Name.

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now