How to treat income?
This query is : Resolved
Querist : Anonymous
Querist :
Anonymous
(Querist)
19 February 2015
I want to know how to treat the income in the following case;
A started shares trading through his D-Mat account on 31st March 2014. He purchased shares of Rs. 1 lakh & sold the same at Rs.1.05 lakh. There was only one transaction for fy 2013-14.
So my question is that whether to treat this income as Speculation Business income or Short term capital gain & why??
A started shares trading through his D-Mat account on 31st March 2014. He purchased shares of Rs. 1 lakh & sold the same at Rs.1.05 lakh. There was only one transaction for fy 2013-14.
So my question is that whether to treat this income as Speculation Business income or Short term capital gain & why??
19 February 2015
it will be speculation business income in this case/
Querist : Anonymous
Querist :
Anonymous
(Querist)
30 November 2015
Thank You Sir. Please mention the reason.
28 July 2024
In India, the treatment of income from share trading depends on the nature of the transactions and the frequency of trading. Here's how to classify the income in your case:
### 1. **Short-Term Capital Gain vs. Speculation Business Income**
#### **Short-Term Capital Gain (STCG):**
- **Definition:** STCG arises when you sell shares or securities within 12 months of their purchase.
- **Tax Rate:** STCG on listed shares is taxed at 15% under Section 111A of the Income Tax Act, plus applicable cess and surcharges.
#### **Speculation Business Income:**
- **Definition:** This refers to profits earned from trading in shares or securities where transactions are frequent, and the primary intention is to profit from short-term price movements.
- **Tax Rate:** Income from speculation business is treated as business income and taxed as per the individual's income tax slab rate.
### **Determining the Classification**
1. **Frequency and Volume of Transactions:**
- **Capital Gains:** If you trade occasionally (e.g., only one transaction in the financial year), the income is generally classified as **Short-Term Capital Gain**. In your case, since there was only one transaction, it would likely be treated as STCG.
- **Speculation Income:** If trading is frequent and the primary intention is to profit from short-term price fluctuations, then it might be classified as **Speculation Business Income**. This is less likely in your case since you have mentioned only a single transaction.
2. **Nature of the Transaction:**
- **Capital Gains:** In your case, since the shares were held for less than 12 months and sold after a short holding period, the gain is classified as **Short-Term Capital Gain**.
- **Speculation Business:** This classification usually applies when the trading is substantial and continuous, which does not seem to apply to a single transaction.
3. **Intent and Frequency of Trading:**
- **Capital Gains:** Your intent appears to be investing rather than running a trading business, given the single transaction. Therefore, the income is considered as STCG.
- **Speculation Business:** If you had multiple transactions and treated the activity as a business with a regular pattern, then it might be classified as speculation business income.
### **Conclusion**
Given your scenario with only one transaction of buying and selling shares, the income should be treated as **Short-Term Capital Gain**.
#### **Reasoning:**
- **Number of Transactions:** Only one transaction in the financial year indicates that the activity was more of an investment rather than a business.
- **Holding Period:** The shares were held for less than 12 months, which aligns with the classification of STCG.
- **Tax Treatment:** Short-term capital gains on listed shares are taxed at a flat rate of 15%, whereas speculation business income is taxed based on the individual's income tax slab rate.
### **Practical Steps**
1. **Report the Income:** Report the income under the capital gains section of your income tax return.
2. **Calculate Tax:** Calculate the STCG tax at 15% of the gain (₹5,000 in this case) and include it in your total tax liability.
Always ensure to keep accurate records of transactions and consult with a tax advisor for any specific queries related to frequent trading or other complex scenarios.
### 1. **Short-Term Capital Gain vs. Speculation Business Income**
#### **Short-Term Capital Gain (STCG):**
- **Definition:** STCG arises when you sell shares or securities within 12 months of their purchase.
- **Tax Rate:** STCG on listed shares is taxed at 15% under Section 111A of the Income Tax Act, plus applicable cess and surcharges.
#### **Speculation Business Income:**
- **Definition:** This refers to profits earned from trading in shares or securities where transactions are frequent, and the primary intention is to profit from short-term price movements.
- **Tax Rate:** Income from speculation business is treated as business income and taxed as per the individual's income tax slab rate.
### **Determining the Classification**
1. **Frequency and Volume of Transactions:**
- **Capital Gains:** If you trade occasionally (e.g., only one transaction in the financial year), the income is generally classified as **Short-Term Capital Gain**. In your case, since there was only one transaction, it would likely be treated as STCG.
- **Speculation Income:** If trading is frequent and the primary intention is to profit from short-term price fluctuations, then it might be classified as **Speculation Business Income**. This is less likely in your case since you have mentioned only a single transaction.
2. **Nature of the Transaction:**
- **Capital Gains:** In your case, since the shares were held for less than 12 months and sold after a short holding period, the gain is classified as **Short-Term Capital Gain**.
- **Speculation Business:** This classification usually applies when the trading is substantial and continuous, which does not seem to apply to a single transaction.
3. **Intent and Frequency of Trading:**
- **Capital Gains:** Your intent appears to be investing rather than running a trading business, given the single transaction. Therefore, the income is considered as STCG.
- **Speculation Business:** If you had multiple transactions and treated the activity as a business with a regular pattern, then it might be classified as speculation business income.
### **Conclusion**
Given your scenario with only one transaction of buying and selling shares, the income should be treated as **Short-Term Capital Gain**.
#### **Reasoning:**
- **Number of Transactions:** Only one transaction in the financial year indicates that the activity was more of an investment rather than a business.
- **Holding Period:** The shares were held for less than 12 months, which aligns with the classification of STCG.
- **Tax Treatment:** Short-term capital gains on listed shares are taxed at a flat rate of 15%, whereas speculation business income is taxed based on the individual's income tax slab rate.
### **Practical Steps**
1. **Report the Income:** Report the income under the capital gains section of your income tax return.
2. **Calculate Tax:** Calculate the STCG tax at 15% of the gain (₹5,000 in this case) and include it in your total tax liability.
Always ensure to keep accurate records of transactions and consult with a tax advisor for any specific queries related to frequent trading or other complex scenarios.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- ESI Contribution after implementing COSS
- Cg on ancestral property sale distribution
- Can huf give gift to karta or kartas wife and son
- Query on applicability of Small Company, CARO & IFC
- Outward HSN details in Table 17 - unable to enter more than 6 HSN codes - Reg.
- TDS deduction liability ?
- FY 24-25 Invoice Booked in FY 25-26 & ITC Claimed in FY 25-26
- Negative liability in GSTR-3B
- GSTR - 9 Input Tax Credit
- Revised Income Tax Return AY 25-26
- Schedule VDA
- Applicability of GST on Paying Guest
- Articlehsip_temination
- Salary journal entry
- Design work
- Goods stopped by DRI department at port
- Inventory Valuation and Closing Stock entry in books and opening stock entry in books
- IGST refund with GST amendment deadline over
- ITR revision intimation recd.
- "Please ensure that the Total of the Deductions u/s 54F match the same in Table D in Sch CG"
Trending Online Classes
-
FR & Direct Tax (Regular Batch Combo) For May 26 & Onwards
CA Bhanwar Borana & CA Aakash Kandoi
CAclubindia
