26 February 2015
We have one client partnership firm with two partners providing professional services. Both the partners are only directors in a company which is also consulting and advisory service provider. Company have some foreign clients and partnership firm employs its own employees to client places. Company charges from the clients itself and partnership firm raises invoice from the company.
Now if the firm will raise any invoice from the company then it has to charge service tax also on the invoice and when the company will make payment to the firm, then it will have to deduct the TDS @10% u/s 194J.
Is there any way to save the client from this procedure of service tax and TDS applicability ?
28 July 2024
To navigate the applicability of TDS and service tax (now GST) in the scenario you've described, you need to understand the nuances of the tax regulations. Here are some ways to address and potentially mitigate the impact of TDS and service tax/GST:
### **1. **Understanding TDS Applicability**
#### **For TDS (Section 194J):** - **Applicability**: TDS is applicable under Section 194J for payments related to professional services, which includes consulting and advisory services. - **Rate**: TDS on professional services is generally 10% of the payment amount.
### **2. **Understanding Service Tax (Now GST)**
#### **For Service Tax (Before GST Implementation):** - **Applicability**: Service tax was applicable on the provision of services. If the partnership firm was providing services, it would be required to charge service tax on its invoices. - **Rate**: The rate of service tax was 15% (which included the Swachh Bharat Cess and Krishi Kalyan Cess) before GST was implemented.
#### **For GST (Post GST Implementation):** - **Applicability**: GST applies to the supply of goods and services. If the partnership firm is providing services, GST is applicable. - **Rate**: The GST rate depends on the type of service and the GST slab applicable to that service.
### **3. **Ways to Mitigate TDS and GST Impact**
#### **1. **Evaluate the Service Arrangement:** - **Review Contracts**: Check if the services provided are correctly classified. Ensure that the nature of services and billing arrangements are correctly interpreted for TDS and GST purposes. - **Reclassify Services**: Sometimes, reclassifying the type of service provided or changing the service structure can impact the applicability of TDS and GST.
#### **2. **Optimize Invoicing and Contracts:** - **Consolidated Invoicing**: If possible, consolidate services and fees in a manner that may minimize the total invoice amount subject to TDS and GST. - **Service Tax/GST Exemptions**: Investigate if any exemptions or reduced rates under GST are applicable to the services provided.
#### **3. **Intra-group Transactions and Agreements:** - **Intercompany Agreements**: Ensure that intercompany agreements between the partnership firm and the consulting company are clear and comply with transfer pricing regulations. This might help in avoiding unnecessary TDS deductions. - **Management Fees**: If the consulting company provides management services to the partnership firm, check if these are chargeable under a different head, which might have different TDS or GST implications.
#### **4. **Utilize Available Deductions or Credits:** - **Claim Input Tax Credit (ITC)**: For GST, ensure that the partnership firm claims ITC on inputs and services used to offset GST liability. - **TDS Credit**: Ensure that TDS deducted is properly reflected and claimed as a credit in the partnership firm’s income tax returns.
#### **5. **Consult with Tax Professionals:** - **Tax Advice**: Engage with tax professionals or consultants who specialize in GST and TDS to get personalized advice. They can provide insights into specific exemptions, deductions, or structuring opportunities. - **Legal Review**: Have a legal review of the contracts and payment structures to ensure compliance and optimal tax treatment.
### **6. **Documentation and Compliance:** - **Maintain Records**: Keep detailed records of all transactions, invoices, TDS certificates, and GST filings. Proper documentation is crucial in case of any audits or scrutiny. - **Timely Filing**: Ensure timely filing of TDS returns and GST returns to avoid penalties and interest.
### **Summary**
To minimize the impact of TDS and GST: - Review and optimize service contracts and invoicing. - Ensure compliance with TDS and GST regulations. - Utilize available exemptions, credits, and deductions. - Seek professional advice for specific structuring and compliance issues.
Implementing these strategies will help you manage the tax implications effectively and ensure that you are compliant with tax regulations.
CAclubindia
