banner_ad

2(22)(e)

This query is : Resolved 
Profile Image

Profile Image

(Querist)
22 December 2010 Mr. D is 20% Beneficial share holder of U Ltd.(Closely Held Co.)
as well 15% Beneficial share holder of P Pvt.Ltd.(Closely Held Co.)
U ltd holds 40% Share holding in P Pvt. Ltd.

Now If P Pvt. Ltd. Receive Loan and advances(suppose U ltd has sufficient accumulated profit) from U Ltd.

While calculating substantial interest:
Direct holding of Mr. D in P pvt. ltd is 15%
Holding through U ltd 40%*20%= 8% so total holding = 15+ 8 = 23%

Is this calculation is valid.
Please quote case law if any.
Profile Image

CA. R. B. SAH

Profile Image

CA. R. B. SAH (Expert)
22 December 2010 calculation is not valid.
Profile Image

CA ASHISH GUPTA

Profile Image

CA ASHISH GUPTA (Expert)
22 December 2010 Not valid.
No case law required.
Law is very clear.
Profile Image

Dipendra

Profile Image

Dipendra (Querist)
23 December 2010 How can we say that indirect holding can't be added while calculating Substantioal interest? Since law is silent. Would you elaborate please.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now


CCI Pro
Join the CA Students WhatsApp Community for ICAI Updates, Trending Courses & Notes!


Similar Resolved Queries


loading


Unanswered Queries


banner

Trending Online Classes

view all classess

CCI Pro
Meet our CAclubindia PRO Members
Subscribe Now

Follow us
add to google news



Answer Query



Quick Links



Browse by Category




Latest Job Openings

View all
Company
29 April 2026
Internal Auditor

SNCO

Mumbai

CA Inter

View Details
Company
19 May 2026
Article, CA & Paid Assistant Positions

Aggarwal Sarawagi and Co

New Delhi

CA

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 30 April 2026
Article Assistant

M/s G.K. Choksi & Co.

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
25 April 2026
Tax Executive/Manager

BDMV & Co, Chartered Accountants

Mumbai

CA Final

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 05 May 2026
ARTICLED ASSISTANT

JS ADVISORS

New Delhi

CA Inter

View Details
Company
29 April 2026
Associate - Audit, Tax & Compliance

Open Co Consulting LLP

New Delhi

B.Com

View Details
Company
05 May 2026
Accountant

Sanjay K Pathak & Associates

Noida

Graduate (Any)

View Details
Company
ARTICLESHIP 23 May 2026
Article Assistants

Acupro Consulting

Gurgaon

CA Inter

View Details