This discussion clarifies whether an individual can sell goods from their GST-registered proprietorship firm to their GST-registered HUF proprietorship firm. The consensus is that this is permissible as long as the HUF firm pays the invoiced amount and proper GST is applied. The main challenge is providing satisfactory reasons to the GST department for such transactions. Suggested reasons include urgent business needs or the HUF firm trading in those specific goods.
22 December 2025
Can I make sales to my gst huf proprietorshipship firm from my sole proprietorship firm? If I can make sales what reasons should I give for sales? Please clarify with examples?
23 December 2025
Yes huf firm paying me the invoiced amount but the gst department is asking why I sold to huf firm and they are asking me the reason .please clarify?
24 December 2025
Yes trading with goods and seperate gst no huf have. Still gst department asking why sold from proprietorship to huf.what reasons should I give?
25 December 2025
There is no rule that HUF firm cannot purchase from individual firm; while GST paid and invoice generated. You can reply that the goods were purchase in urgent situation.
14 November 2026
Such sales are legal. The department asks because sales between related persons can be used to pass ITC or inflate turnover. Answer with commercial reasons and evidence.
The law • You (individual) and your HUF are separate persons with separate GSTINs, so a sale between them is a normal taxable supply. • You and the HUF (of which you are Karta) are related persons for valuation (Explanation to Sec 15). Value must be the open market value (Rule 28). If the HUF firm is eligible for full ITC, the invoice value is deemed to be open market value (second proviso to Rule 28).
What to tell the department (adapt to your facts) • Commercial reason: for example, the HUF firm deals with specific customers or markets, or uses these goods in its own business; you buy in bulk at better rates and supply to it; it has storage or a location advantage. • Pricing: at market rates, comparable to your sales to unrelated customers (attach sample invoices). • Genuine movement: e-way bills, transport receipts, goods inward records at the HUF firm. • Payment: received through bank (attach statements). • Onward supply: the HUF firm sold these goods with tax paid (GSTR-1/3B extracts).
Income tax • The HUF is a related party (Sec 40A(2)(b)). Excessive prices can be disallowed in the buyer's hands. Keep separate books and bank accounts for each.