Shareholders right in joint venture

This query is : Resolved

Ankul Maheshwari (Querist)
Follow

07 November 2011 Two entities are there A and B both are forming Joint venture called AB JV Company if equity shareholding ratio of company A and B in JV is 60:40 respectivily. What are the normal and special rights of company B which has 40% in JV and what difference compare to having 60% will come in front of Company B.
Please help me....

Best:
Ankul

RG - A Helping Hand

RG - A Helping Hand (Expert)
Follow

21 November 2011 Friend,

In case of a JV everything is dependent on the JV Agreement. So I would suggest you to plz go through the JV Agreement.

RG

Ankul Maheshwari

Ankul Maheshwari (Querist)
Follow

21 November 2011 Dear Richank,

I want to know as per company act. what extra or more power or special right company A (Which own 60% in JV) will be having in AB JV Company

Best:
Ankul

Ankul Maheshwari

Ankul Maheshwari (Querist)
Follow

22 November 2011 this JV is based on 60:40 shareholding and AB JV company is incorporated under company act, 1956.

please assist with some valuable answer

Asha Kanta Sharma

Asha Kanta Sharma (Expert)
Follow

25 July 2025 Great question, Ankul! Here's a clear legal and practical breakdown of **shareholders’ rights in a Joint Venture (JV) company** — particularly comparing a **60% shareholder (Company A)** vs. a **40% shareholder (Company B)**, under the **Companies Act, 1956** (which has been replaced by the Companies Act, 2013 — but the principles still apply similarly).

---

### ✅ **1. General Legal Position (Statutory Rights)**

In a JV company under Indian company law, **rights are proportionate to shareholding** unless modified by a **Joint Venture Agreement (JVA)** or **Articles of Association (AoA)**.

Let’s break this into two parts:

---

### 🔹 Company A (60% Shareholder) — What Rights It Gets by Default:

| Type of Power | Implication |
| ------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- |
| **Majority Voting Power** | Can pass **ordinary resolutions** alone (requires >50%). |
| **Board Control** | Likely to appoint majority of directors (if agreed in JVA). |
| **Day-to-day Control** | Practical control over operations and decisions. |
| **Dividend Control** | Can influence dividend declaration by voting power. |
| **Removal of Directors** | Can remove and replace directors through majority votes. |

---

### 🔹 Company B (40% Shareholder) — What It Can/Cannot Do by Default:

| Right/Possibility | Situation |
| ----------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Block **special resolutions** | ✅ Yes, as special resolutions need **75%** — B can block it with 40%. |
| Influence ordinary decisions | ❌ No — Company A can pass them with its 60% alone. |
| Appoint director(s) | Only if provided in JVA / AoA — not a statutory right at 40%. |
| Veto powers | ❌ Not automatic — must be granted contractually in JVA. |

---

### ✅ **2. Special Resolutions – Where Company B (40%) Can Exercise Power**

Special resolutions require **75% shareholder approval**. So, Company B **can block** decisions such as:

* Alteration of **Memorandum or Articles**.
* Change in **registered office across state**.
* **Issue of further shares** (if it dilutes B’s holding).
* **Merger/amalgamation** decisions.
* **Winding up** the company voluntarily.

So while Company B can’t control day-to-day decisions, it has **blocking power over strategic matters** — **unless Company A also gets a third party on its side.**

---

### ⚖️ **3. Importance of JV Agreement (Critical!)**

Under both the Companies Act and practical governance, most **special rights** (like vetoes, board appointments, reserved matters) must be defined in the **Joint Venture Agreement** or **Articles of Association**.

These may include:

* **Affirmative voting rights** for B on key decisions.
* Right to **nominate director(s)**.
* **Pre-emptive rights** on further issue or transfer of shares.
* Exit mechanisms (tag-along, drag-along, buyback).

Without such a JVA or express provisions in AoA, Company B's influence is limited to what the Companies Act permits at 40% holding.

---

### 🔍 Key Comparison – 60% vs. 40%

| Rights/Control Area | 60% Shareholder (A) | 40% Shareholder (B) |
| --------------------------- | ---------------------------- | ------------------- |
| Pass ordinary resolutions | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
| Block special resolutions | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Appoint majority directors | ✅ Typically, yes (if in JVA) | ❌ Only if in JVA |
| Day-to-day control | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
| Veto on strategic decisions | ❌ No (but can force) | ✅ If holding ≥ 25% |

---

### ✅ Final Advice:

* **Review the JV Agreement** — it governs most rights between the parties.
* Company B should **insist on veto rights** and **reserved matters** in writing to protect its 40% stake.
* In absence of such rights, legal remedies are limited to **blocking special resolutions**.

---

Would you like a **sample list of “reserved matters” for a JV agreement** or a checklist of rights to secure for minority shareholders (like B)?

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now