Set off of interest income against interest expenses
This query is : Resolved
13 October 2012
Dear Sir,
Is there any restriction under Section 80(IB)10 that interest income cannot be set off against interest expenses in the case of construction/Real Estate Business?Kindly revert back to me on cabhuvnesh@sify.com
Thanks & Regards,
CA Bhuvnesh S.VILAYATRANI
Surat
+09377506208
Is there any restriction under Section 80(IB)10 that interest income cannot be set off against interest expenses in the case of construction/Real Estate Business?Kindly revert back to me on cabhuvnesh@sify.com
Thanks & Regards,
CA Bhuvnesh S.VILAYATRANI
Surat
+09377506208
14 October 2012
iT IS A GENERAL PRICIPLE THAT INTT INCOME CANNOT BE SET OFF AG INTT EXP THIS IS NOT A FEATURE OF 80-IB(10). rEFERE TO TUTICORIN ALKALI AND BOKARO STEEL CASE BY SC
CA MANOJ GUPTA
JODHPUR
09828510543
CA MANOJ GUPTA
JODHPUR
09828510543
Message likes :
1 times
14 October 2012
But Dear Sir,There are many case laws of Honorable HC/SC/ITAT that Interest Income can be set off against Interest Expenses...My question is still open that whether Section 10(IB) has some restrictions on such set off?
Regards
Bhuvnesh
Regards
Bhuvnesh
25 July 2025
The query you raised is about whether **interest income** can be **set off against interest expenses** in the context of a **construction/real estate business** claiming deductions under **Section 80-IB(10)**.
Let's break it down:
### **1. General Principle on Interest Income vs Interest Expenses:**
Under the general principles of **Income Tax**, interest income and interest expenses are usually treated as **separate heads of income**. This means that:
* **Interest income** is typically included under **Income from Other Sources**.
* **Interest expenses** are typically allowed under **Business Income** (if they are incurred for business purposes).
According to the **Supreme Court’s rulings** in cases like **Tuticorin Alkali Chemicals** and **Bokaro Steel Ltd**, interest income from investments or deposits is generally **not eligible to be set off** against business interest expenses, because they are treated as **separate sources of income**.
### **2. Section 80-IB(10) Overview:**
Section **80-IB(10)** specifically provides a **deduction** for profits from the **business of developing and building residential units**. The deduction is available to taxpayers engaged in the business of:
* Developing and constructing residential houses or flats, which are sold or leased.
For **eligible businesses** under Section **80-IB(10)**, the **entire profit** derived from the development of such projects is exempt from tax, subject to specific conditions:
* The project must comply with certain **size restrictions** (e.g., the built-up area of residential units should not exceed 1,000 sq. feet for non-metro cities).
* The project must be completed within a specified period.
### **3. Does Section 80-IB(10) Impose Restrictions on Set-Off of Interest Income?**
* **Section 80-IB(10)** itself does **not** have any **explicit restriction** on setting off interest income against interest expenses. The provision primarily focuses on **profits from business**, and it does not address the specific issue of whether **interest income** can be set off against **interest expenses**.
* **Section 80-IB(10)** aims to provide a **deduction on the profits of the business** (including profits from the sale or leasing of residential units), but it does **not interfere with general provisions relating to interest income and expenses**.
### **4. Issue of Set-Off of Interest Income and Expenses:**
The **issue of interest income vs interest expense** set-off is generally governed by the **Income Tax Act’s provisions for set-off and carry-forward of losses**:
* **Interest expenses** incurred by the **real estate business** can be **set off against business income** (if they are genuinely for the purpose of business).
* However, **interest income**, especially if earned from **fixed deposits** or other investments not related to the real estate business, is treated separately and **cannot be directly set off against interest expenses** incurred in the **real estate business**.
### **5. Relevant Case Laws:**
There have been cases where **interest income** was **set off against interest expenses** in certain circumstances, but these typically arise when the income is directly related to the business. For example:
* **Interest income earned on funds** temporarily parked in a fixed deposit for business purposes may be allowed to be **set off against interest expenses** under certain conditions.
In the case of **Tuticorin Alkali Chemicals Ltd. (1997)**, the Supreme Court ruled that interest income earned from short-term investments cannot be **set off against business interest expenses** because they arise from two distinct sources of income.
Similarly, in **Bokaro Steel Ltd. (1999)**, the Supreme Court clarified that **interest income** arising from the use of surplus funds (such as deposits) does not qualify as income from the business and cannot be set off against business interest expenses.
### **6. Practical Application in Real Estate / Construction Business:**
For a **real estate developer** claiming **Section 80-IB(10)**:
* **Interest expenses** incurred for loans taken for **construction and development** of residential properties can be **deducted** as part of the **business income**.
* **Interest income** earned on **temporary deposits**, **advances**, or **surplus funds** not directly related to the project (e.g., interest on FDs or other investments) will typically be treated as **Income from Other Sources** and cannot be **set off** against **business interest expenses**.
### **Conclusion:**
* **No explicit restriction** is mentioned in **Section 80-IB(10)** regarding the **set-off of interest income** against **interest expenses**.
* However, as per general principles of **Income Tax**, interest income and interest expenses are generally treated as **separate sources of income** and cannot be directly set off against each other.
* The **set-off of interest income** against interest expenses is allowed only when both arise from the **same business**.
If the interest income is directly related to the **real estate business** (e.g., interest earned on funds directly used in the construction project), it may be eligible for set-off, but if it arises from investments or surplus funds, it **cannot** be set off against business interest expenses.
---
Let me know if you need further clarification or specific references!
Let's break it down:
### **1. General Principle on Interest Income vs Interest Expenses:**
Under the general principles of **Income Tax**, interest income and interest expenses are usually treated as **separate heads of income**. This means that:
* **Interest income** is typically included under **Income from Other Sources**.
* **Interest expenses** are typically allowed under **Business Income** (if they are incurred for business purposes).
According to the **Supreme Court’s rulings** in cases like **Tuticorin Alkali Chemicals** and **Bokaro Steel Ltd**, interest income from investments or deposits is generally **not eligible to be set off** against business interest expenses, because they are treated as **separate sources of income**.
### **2. Section 80-IB(10) Overview:**
Section **80-IB(10)** specifically provides a **deduction** for profits from the **business of developing and building residential units**. The deduction is available to taxpayers engaged in the business of:
* Developing and constructing residential houses or flats, which are sold or leased.
For **eligible businesses** under Section **80-IB(10)**, the **entire profit** derived from the development of such projects is exempt from tax, subject to specific conditions:
* The project must comply with certain **size restrictions** (e.g., the built-up area of residential units should not exceed 1,000 sq. feet for non-metro cities).
* The project must be completed within a specified period.
### **3. Does Section 80-IB(10) Impose Restrictions on Set-Off of Interest Income?**
* **Section 80-IB(10)** itself does **not** have any **explicit restriction** on setting off interest income against interest expenses. The provision primarily focuses on **profits from business**, and it does not address the specific issue of whether **interest income** can be set off against **interest expenses**.
* **Section 80-IB(10)** aims to provide a **deduction on the profits of the business** (including profits from the sale or leasing of residential units), but it does **not interfere with general provisions relating to interest income and expenses**.
### **4. Issue of Set-Off of Interest Income and Expenses:**
The **issue of interest income vs interest expense** set-off is generally governed by the **Income Tax Act’s provisions for set-off and carry-forward of losses**:
* **Interest expenses** incurred by the **real estate business** can be **set off against business income** (if they are genuinely for the purpose of business).
* However, **interest income**, especially if earned from **fixed deposits** or other investments not related to the real estate business, is treated separately and **cannot be directly set off against interest expenses** incurred in the **real estate business**.
### **5. Relevant Case Laws:**
There have been cases where **interest income** was **set off against interest expenses** in certain circumstances, but these typically arise when the income is directly related to the business. For example:
* **Interest income earned on funds** temporarily parked in a fixed deposit for business purposes may be allowed to be **set off against interest expenses** under certain conditions.
In the case of **Tuticorin Alkali Chemicals Ltd. (1997)**, the Supreme Court ruled that interest income earned from short-term investments cannot be **set off against business interest expenses** because they arise from two distinct sources of income.
Similarly, in **Bokaro Steel Ltd. (1999)**, the Supreme Court clarified that **interest income** arising from the use of surplus funds (such as deposits) does not qualify as income from the business and cannot be set off against business interest expenses.
### **6. Practical Application in Real Estate / Construction Business:**
For a **real estate developer** claiming **Section 80-IB(10)**:
* **Interest expenses** incurred for loans taken for **construction and development** of residential properties can be **deducted** as part of the **business income**.
* **Interest income** earned on **temporary deposits**, **advances**, or **surplus funds** not directly related to the project (e.g., interest on FDs or other investments) will typically be treated as **Income from Other Sources** and cannot be **set off** against **business interest expenses**.
### **Conclusion:**
* **No explicit restriction** is mentioned in **Section 80-IB(10)** regarding the **set-off of interest income** against **interest expenses**.
* However, as per general principles of **Income Tax**, interest income and interest expenses are generally treated as **separate sources of income** and cannot be directly set off against each other.
* The **set-off of interest income** against interest expenses is allowed only when both arise from the **same business**.
If the interest income is directly related to the **real estate business** (e.g., interest earned on funds directly used in the construction project), it may be eligible for set-off, but if it arises from investments or surplus funds, it **cannot** be set off against business interest expenses.
---
Let me know if you need further clarification or specific references!
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Notice from IT DEPTT IF FD AMOUNT EXCEEDS 10 LACS
- GST payable under RCM
- Applicablity on tds
- Unable to generate and save json file for updated return
- Which SAC code should be selected??
- Audit of F and O T/O
- Section 194I not showing in TDS RPU for Compnay Assessee for TDS on rent
- GSTR9- ITC
- Regarding TDS not deducted on rent
- Tax audit & Switching from Presumptive taxation
- Import purchase entry
- Rule 54(1A) for Distributing ITC
- EXCESS CREDIT REALTED GST REVERSAL
- Export invoice not reported
- CA Articleship Extension Matter
- GST OFFICER WRONG NOTICE
- "Please ensure that the Total of the Deductions u/s 54F match the same in Table D in Sch CG"
- Composition Dealer GST Annual Return Filing process
- Revision under Section 264 in The Income Tax Act, 1961
- TDS under section 195.
Trending Online Classes
-
LIVE Course on GSTR-9 & GSTR-9C (Technical | Practical | Concept - Based)
Sachin Jain03 November 2025
CAclubindia
