Query on validity of ITR

This query is : Resolved

Quick Summary

This discussion clarifies the validity of an Income Tax Return (ITR) rectification order and associated demand. The demand raised in an earlier rectification order, once paid, remains valid unless explicitly overturned. Regarding finality, rectification orders are generally considered final unless a clear mistake can be demonstrated, in which case further rectification or an appeal might be possible.

Rahul Singh

Rahul Singh (Querist)
Follow

22 March 2025 "Subject: Clarification on Rectification Order and Validity of Demand

I am seeking clarification on the rectification order and demand validity related to my updated return. Here's a brief background:

- Rectification filed on January 21, 2024, was processed with a demand of Rs. 5,160, which was paid.
- Updated return filed on March 27, 2024, was rejected on December 4, 2024, due to Part B ATI refund issues.
- Another rectification was filed on December 7, 2024, but was rejected on March 17, 2025.

Fact of the Case:

1. Is the demand of Rs. 5,160, raised in the first rectification order dated January 21, 2024, still valid?
2. Will this rectification order be considered as a final order, or are further rectifications possible?

Please provide clarification on these points to ensure I take the necessary steps.

Dhirajlal Rambhia

Dhirajlal Rambhia (Expert)
Follow

22 March 2025 1. Yes, valid..
2. Not possible.

CA Rashmi Gandhi

CA Rashmi Gandhi (Expert)
Follow

23 March 2025 1) Validity of Demand of ₹5,160 from Rectification Order Dated January 21, 2024
You filed a rectification request on January 21, 2024, which resulted in a demand of ₹5,160.

You paid this amount, meaning the demand was settled.

Since there has been no further modification or cancellation of this rectification order, the demand is valid, unless overturned by a subsequent order.

However, since a later rectification request (filed on December 7, 2024) was rejected, it suggests that the January 21, 2024, rectification order is still the final effective order.

2) Is the January 21, 2024, Rectification Order Final, or Can Further Rectifications Be Filed?
A rectification order (u/s 154 of the Income Tax Act) is considered final unless there is an apparent mistake or legal error that justifies another rectification.

Since your December 7, 2024, rectification request was rejected, it indicates that the Income Tax Department does not see any rectifiable mistake in the order.

However, if you still believe there is an error in the order, you have two options:

File another rectification request if you can point out a clear mistake.

File an appeal before CIT(A) if you disagree with the demand or rejection of rectification.

Next Steps for You:
If you agree with the demand and no further correction is needed, the matter is settled.

If you believe the rectification rejection (dated March 17, 2025) was incorrect, consider:

Checking the reasons for rejection.

Filing a grievance on the Income Tax Portal or

Filing an appeal before CIT(A) (if valid grounds exist).

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now