Garner vs murray

This query is : Resolved

CA Gyati Gupta (Querist)
Follow

11 April 2013 under garner vs murray rule,even if the partner has debit balance bt solvent,can he be asked to bring the loss of insolvency of an insolvent partner?

CA Sourabh Agarwal

CA Sourabh Agarwal (Expert)
Follow

12 April 2013 No. He cannot be obligated by application of this rule.

C A S.S.Agarwal, M.Com.,LL.B,

C A S.S.Agarwal, M.Com.,LL.B, (Expert)
Follow

28 June 2013 I DO NOT AGREE WITH THE EXPERT ON THIS ISSUE AS THE RULE IN THIS CASE IS VERY CLEAR

When a partner’s capital account shows a debit balance on dissolution of the firm, he has to pay the debit balance to the firm to settle his account. If the partner becomes insolvent, he is unable to pay back the amount owed by him to the firm in full. The amount not paid is a loss to the firm which under the Garner vs Murray Rule is to be borne by the solvent partners.

According to Garner vs Murray Rule:

The loss on account of insolvency of a partner is a CAPITAL loss which should be borne by the solvent partners in the ratio of their capitals standing in the balance sheet on the date of dissolution of the firm.

Notes:

“Capital” in this case relates to the real capital of the partners and not capital as may be standing in the books of partnership firm in the names of different partners. This distinction is especially critical when the partners are maintaining their capital accounts on fluctuation capital system. The true capitals according to this rule will be ascertained after making all adjustments regarding reserves, drawings, unrecorded assets on the date of the balance sheet on the date of dissolution of the partnership firm. When the capitals are FIXED, no such adjustment is required.
Where a partner is solvent but has a debit balance in his/her capital account, just before the dissolution of the partnership firm, such a partner will not be required to bear the loss on account of insolvency of a partner.

The rules dictates that:-

The solvent partners should bring in cash equivalent to their respective share of loss on realization and
The loss due to the insolvency of a partner should be then be divided among the solvent partners in the ratio of capitals standing after the partners have brought in cash equal to their share of loss on realization.

You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now