Admissibility of expenses from business income as per law

This query is : Resolved 

04 September 2013 One of our Professional colleague is practicing as Chartered Accountants under the Status of partnership Firm having 3 Partners.

The Firm is paying Partner's Remuneration to partners as specified in partnership Deed & as per I.T.Act.

During the year 2012-13 one of Partner who headed/Looked after the office is getting Rs.600000/- as Partner's Remuneration & the same is allowable as expenses in the hands of Firm as per law.

The said partner is also having a Motor Car
in his individual name but the same is used for official purposes of Firms Profession. Moreover the partner also have vehicle Loan
on the said car for which he is paying Interest on such loan.

Now query is whether the partner is eligible to claim as expenses like Depreciation on Motor car,Petrol Expenses & Interest on such Motor car Loan paid during the year under consideration from the Partner's Remuneration of Rs.6.00 Lacs as Business or Professional Income while computing his Individual Taxable income for the purposes of filing of ITR relevant to Astt.year 2013-14 or not.

If yes then cited any case law as per I.T.Act.

04 September 2013 If it is exclusively used for ca firm work purpose only then related exp like petrol, dep to car will be enjoyed by the firm

If the car is also used by the partner and also for firm then all exp shall be divided on ratio of usuage)(onm logical basis) like on time basis etc.

You have not mentioned who is showing the car in its bal sheet-firm or partner?

04 September 2013 Dear Tushar ji,

Thanks for prompt reply.Please note that car is shown in Personal Balance Sheet of Partner as Individual.

Then what will be situation.

04 September 2013 still i think the exp shall be divided if used for both and there are even cases where even if a person is not the owner still can claim dep and related exp to such assets if uses for own business puporse u can refer VK Singhania having few cases in that.


You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now


CCI Pro
CAclubindia's WhatsApp Groups Link


Similar Resolved Queries


loading


Unanswered Queries


CCI Pro
Meet our CAclubindia PRO Members


Follow us



Answer Query